What Sparked the Controversy?
The issue exploded into public view after acclaimed Tamil novelist Perumal Murugan raised alarms about the collection at a newly opened library in Coimbatore. In an online article, he pointed out that nearly 1,800 books in the Tamil section, supplied
by a little-known publisher called Agal Vilakku Pathippagam, seemed suspicious. The red flags included unfamiliar author names, factual errors, questionable ISBNs (International Standard Book Numbers), and exceptionally high prices for the books. For instance, one book was reportedly priced at ₹1,445 for just 300 pages and incorrectly described a classic Tamil text. This initial exposé triggered a wider outcry from writers and publishers, leading to legal action.
The 'AI Scam' Allegation
While it has not been definitively proven that artificial intelligence was used to write the books, the scandal has been dubbed by the state's School Education Minister as potentially 'India's first AI scam'. The term refers to the suspicion that generative AI tools may have been used to quickly produce large volumes of low-quality, inaccurate, or plagiarised content that was then sold to the state at inflated prices. Experts note that AI can create superficially credible books—complete with covers and chapter structures—that are filled with fabricated information, making it difficult for standard procurement processes to detect fraud. The court has acknowledged that books with AI-generated or plagiarised content fall into a category of 'doubtful taste' and should not be purchased for public libraries.
The High Court Steps In
The Madras High Court has taken a very serious view of the matter, describing it as a 'colossal fraud' and a blatant breach of its previous orders on transparent book procurement issued in June 2024. That earlier ruling was meant to stop a 'scam' where old, out-of-copyright books were being repackaged with new titles and authors to secure new purchase orders. In the current case, the court has ordered the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) to register an FIR and launch a full investigation. It also ordered the freezing of bank accounts linked to the publisher, which held around ₹22 lakh, and the suspension of five library officials involved in the procurement process.
What the November 16 Deadline Means
The court has been pushing for accountability, expressing frustration that officials had not yet identified the culprits. It has demanded that the Director of Public Libraries submit a detailed affidavit by November 16, identifying every person involved in the fraudulent procurement 'from top to bottom'. This includes producing all relevant purchase records for the court's scrutiny. The deadline is a critical step in the contempt proceedings, as the court seeks to enforce its 2024 transparency directives and ensure that those responsible for misusing public funds are held accountable. The hearing scheduled for today is expected to review the compliance with these orders.
Broader Political and Systemic Issues
The scandal has also ignited a political blame game, with the current state government pointing fingers at the previous DMK administration, which has denied the allegations. However, the court dryly noted that the problem has persisted across different political administrations, remarking, 'Actors change, actions do not'. Beyond the politics, the case exposes deep systemic failures in public procurement. The court highlighted how a proper mechanism to encourage good publishers is lacking and warned that if things don't change, Tamil Nadu's public libraries could suffer a fate similar to the ancient Library of Alexandria. In response to the scandal, the government has cancelled book tenders worth ₹30 crore for another major library project and ordered a wider audit of collections across the state.
















