The 2024 NFL Draft lived up to the hype in terms of being one of the deepest quarterback classes that we've seen in recent years. Six quarterbacks were drafted in the first 12 picks, including Michael Penix Jr. going to the Atlanta Falcons with the eighth overall selection.
After two and a half seasons, the six quarterbacks have found varying levels of success. Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams looks like a star, Washington Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels won the Offensive Rookie of the Year award and New England Patriots QB Drake Maye was the runner-up for the MVP award last season.
Penix backed up Kirk Cousins during his rookie year, and suffered a torn ACL in 2025. Thus far in 2026, Penix has been more good than bad, but he needs
to show more consistency to prove he's the long-term answer.
Denver Broncos quarterback Bo Nix has been the most consistent, but he frequently gets knocked down due to his lack of big-time throws down the field - essentially the opposite of the criticisms around Penix.
J.J. McCarthy has had the rockiest tenure of the six quarterbacks drafted. After a brutal first two seasons in Minnesota, McCarthy was traded from the Vikings to the New York Giants and has played better following the trade.
NFL.com's Bucky Brooks broke down all six signal-callers and assessed whether or not their respective teams should pick up theirfifth-year options. While Penix was praised for his physical tools, he was ranked dead last among the quarterbacks.
"Penix is one of the league's most naturally gifted passers, thanks to his exceptional arm strength and quick whip," wrote Brooks. "He forces opponents to defend every blade of grass with his unlimited range and high-arcing deep ball. In an offense that allows him to throw to multiple blue-chip playmakers (Drake London, Kyle Pitts and Bijan Robinson), Penix could post ridiculous numbers while operating like a point guard leading a fast break."
However, the article brought up Penix's injury history and lack of overall consistency. For these reasons, Brooks determined that Atlanta should not pick up the quarterback's fifth-year option.
"Penix hasn't played enough yet to earn a fifth-year option from the Falcons. Despite a handful of impressive performances, the injuries overshadow his play and make him a risky proposition on the books. Perhaps playing the contract out will allow the Falcons to better assess the risk/reward equation, but there is no way Matt Ryan can sign off on extending the deal based on Penix's offerings thus far."
Fortunately, the Falcons don't have to make that decision at the moment, and frankly, they should be in no rush to do so. Due to their own unusual approach of signing Kirk Cousins a month before drafting Penix, they didn't turn to their young QB until the final three games of his rookie year.
It's also interesting that Penix is ranked below McCarthy on this list, despite the Giants QB showing nowhere as much upside. McCarthy has had a few good games, but has been every bit as injury prone as Penix since entering the NFL while having less success (13 touchdowns to 14 interceptions).
Penix has seven games left to show what he can do, and while he has played poorly over the team's current three-game losing streak, he also has four games with a passer rating of 100 or higher this season.
Atlanta has played a brutal schedule thus far, with games against the Pittsburgh Steelers, Green Bay Packers, Cincinnati Bengals, Chicago Bears, San Francisco 49ers and the Kansas City Chiefs. Quarterbacks tend to struggle against elite defenses (see Drake Maye).
Regardless of the level of competition, though, Penix needs to produce like he did earlier in the season in order for the front office to fully buy in. His problems when pressured are well documented, and he's been entirely too streaky.
For his career, Penix has passed for 4,487 yards, 22 touchdowns and 13 interceptions, while adding 175 rushing yards and two more touchdowns on the ground.
The NFL's fifth-year option deadline is still a ways away on May 1, 2027.
This article originally appeared on Falcons Wire: NFL.com breaks down 2024 QB class, Michael Penix Jr.'s future













