The Atlanta Falcons and the New Orleans Saints both know what a good quarterback looks like. Back when the NFC South was a semi-respectable division, Matt Ryan and Drew Brees used to routinely dissect opposing defenses.
However, replacing these two franchise legends has been no cakewalk. The 3-7 Falcons are still evaluating third-year quarterback Michael Penix Jr., who's shown some impressive highs and frustrating lows in his limited starting experience.
The 3-6 Saints have also been a disappointment this season, and second-year quarterback Tyler Shough has started to bear some of the blame. Obviously, quarterbacks are going to come under fire when their teams struggle, but one NFL analyst is ready for the two franchises to go in a different direction.
NFL analyst Ben Solak was highly critical of the two NFC South quarterbacks in his new feature for ESPN, calling for both the Falcons and Saints to make a change in 2027. Here's what Solak said about Penix.
"There are too many limits in Penix's game. The injury history creates unreliability and limits how easily the offense can get the ball down the field with him. The mechanical issues create accuracy sprays that limit the efficacy of quick games and make the passing game one-handed. There will undoubtedly be more and more splashes as the season goes on -- there always will be with a quarterback of Penix's arm talent. But even if he ends the season hot, the Falcons need to see the forest through the trees and understand that they'll never get the level of consistency they want from the position with a player like Penix under center."
Much of Solak's criticism of Penix is warranted, and the lack of consistency with the quarterback's mechanics has been a problem. However, his final analysis lacks some nuance - even if the article is stuffed with advanced stats.
Penix rushed back from an ACL injury and played better than anyone could have predicted right from the jump. In fact, the Falcons offense looked so good in Penix's first four games back that Solak himself deemed Kevin Stefanski as his pick for Coach of the Year - even though the team was just 3-4.
Atlanta's offense as a whole has fallen off drastically since then. Beyond that, Stefanski's scheme is somehow making Bijan Robinson look like an average player as of late. That would seem to be something worth mentioning, along with the fact that Falcons traded starting center Ryan Neuzil for peanuts at the deadline.
Penix's flashes helped him win NFC Offensive Player of the Week just three weeks ago, and while I agree with many of the issues Solak raises, his final analysis saying the Falcons should essentially ignore any success Penix has later in the year doesn't make sense.
Shough received a similarly harsh assessment. Solak highlighted the second-year quarterback's lack of aggression and age (27) as his primary concerns.
"Shough will likely get a longer grace period than Penix might, seeing as he's only a second-year pro, but he is 27 and it's hard to imagine him improving much at this age. Of all the things difficult to teach a quarterback, aggression is perhaps the most challenging. Unless I see Shough decide to push the ball into tighter windows down the stretch of 2026, I'll wonder just how committed the Saints are to a second-round pick -- remember, he doesn't have a first-round pedigree! -- as the unquestioned starter." - Ben Solak, ESPN
Shough's surface-level numbers are solid - 2,173 passing yards, 15 touchdowns, seven interceptions and a 90.2 passer rating - but he hasn't pushed the ball down the field much this season and is averaging 6.3 yards per attempt.
Saints fans will likely take issue with Shough being on Solak's list, and it's hard to argue. The moral of the story is that NFL teams don't make meaningless decisions about the future with half of a season left to play.
At the same time, NFL analysts don't get paid to wait and see.
This article originally appeared on Falcons Wire: ESPN analyst thinks two NFC South teams need new starting QBs













