The Atlanta Falcons have gotten near-universal acclaim from the media for last week's trade that sent star safety Jessie Bates III to the Jacksonville Jaguars. In return, Atlanta got a 2027 second-round pick, a 2028 fifth-round pick and a score of B-pluses and A-grades from NFL analysts around the web.
It is admittedly difficult to argue with the haul that the Falcons front office got some Jacksonville - especially given Bates' age and contract situation.
What most people glossed over in the process of evaluating the trade is the fact that Altanta's already-slumping defense took a massive body blow in the process. One anonymous NFL exec pointed out that replacing Bates won't be easyin Mike Sando's latest column over at The Athletic.
“Sometimes
those new guys that get in charge of teams can’t wait to collect draft picks and can’t wait to get their own people,” an exec said of the Falcons’ decision to move on from Bates. “It sounds like a great idea, but good luck finding Jessie Bates in the second or third round next year. If you do find him, it’s gonna take him a couple years, so you take a big step back.”
It might take more than just a couple of years to find a safety who can perform at the same level that the Falcons were getting from Bates - who's one of the top-five players at his position.
Bates' presence was about more than just competent coverage - he was a ruthless, turnover-producing machine.
Since joining the Falcons in 2023, Bates had tallied 14 interceptions and 11 forced fumbles to go with four defensive touchdowns. There's only a handful of defensive players around the NFL who are capable of making that kind of impact, and they're all signed to lucrative long-term deals and not going anywhere.
Matt Ryan and Ian Cunningham got a lot of draft capital in return - but turning draft capital into star players is far easier said than done. If they can't find a blue-chip defensive piece for the back end in the next couple of draft classes, this might be a deal that they come to regret.
This article originally appeared on Falcons Wire: NFL exec questions Falcons for trading Jessie Bates III













