The Denver Broncos are coming out of their bye week and had a little downtime to reflect on the season that has been while also looking forward to and preparing for what is left of the regular season before, hopefully, a strong run in the postseason.
The bye week came right at about the midway point of the season, giving us some time to look back at certain aspects of the season and we are going to do that here with the team's rookie class. Head coach Sean Payton has long taken the approach of playing his rookies sparingly, and that has been the case even more so than usual this season.
That will be reflected in this report card, but we'll run this exercise again at the end of the season and see how it compares. We will look back at the team's
draft class and assess how each of those rookies has performed to this point in the season, giving each a letter grade. They will be graded on their performance, or lack thereof, through the first nine games of the season, along with how their selection in the draft looks for the team's future.
Broncos rookie report card through first half of 2026 season
Round 3, No. 66 overall: Tyler Onyedim, defensive lineman, Texas A&M
Much is still unknown about this prospect, as Tyler Onyedim had been a healthy scratch in each of the first eight weeks of the season. He made his debut last week against the Carolina Panthers, with Eyioma Uwazurike being placed on injured reserve.
Onyedim had one tackle in the game and hopefully he sees more of an opportunity as the season progresses. To this point, however, regardless of the reason for him not seeing the field much, the pick hasn't made much sense.
Grade: C-
Fourth round, No. 108 overall: Jonah Coleman, RB, Washington
Jonah Coleman is the only rookie who has seen significant playing time for the Broncos this season, but even he missed some action due to an ankle injury. He has carried the ball just 47 times for 191 yards with three touchdowns, but his 4.1 yards per carry average is encouraging. He also has 13 catches for 128 yards and his 51-yard catch-and-run against the Kansas City Chiefs in Week 8 was one of the top plays for the team this season so far.
Coleman is easily the top running back on the roster for the foreseeable future.
Grade: B+
Fourth round, No. 110 overall: Kage Casey, OL, Boise State
Kage Casey looked good during the summer and projects as a future starter for the team. But with a starting offensive line already in place, there wasn't much room for him to push for playing time as a rookie, and he's been inactive in each of the team's first nine games.
That could easily remain the case throughout the season, but this still looks like a good pick made by the team. However, with him being on the sidelines all season, the only fair way to grade him would be right down the middle. The pick still looks like it was a good one, but patience will be required.
Grade: C
Round 5, No. 152 overall: Justin Joly, TE, North Carolina State
The Broncos moved on from their fifth-round pick quickly, cutting him at the end of the preseason despite an exciting 88-yard touchdown in the preseason finale against the Minnesota Vikings.
The move was seen as surprising and the Broncos didn't even get a chance to bring him back to the practice squad, as he was claimed on waivers by the Miami Dolphins. He has been active in one game for them this season.
This was a bad pick by the Broncos, as no fifth-round choice should ever be cut right after training camp. This was a bad job done by the scouting department and it led to a wasted choice.
Grade: F
Round 7, No. 246 overall: Miles Scott, S, Illinois
There was some thought that Miles Scott could push for a spot on the 53-man roster when the team got a look at him in rookie minicamp, but that soon went away once camp started and he had some clear deficiencies. The team did bring him back to the practice squad after being cut, but he doesn't project as a long-term member of the roster.
Still, as a seventh-round pick, we can't be too harsh.
Grade: C-
Round 7, No. 256 overall: Dallen Bentley, TE, Utah
With Evan Engram, Adam Trautman, Nate Adkins and probably even Caleb Lohner ahead of him, seventh-round pick Dallen Bentley never really had much chance to contribute as a rookie, but he remains on the 53-man roster. The fact that the Broncos keep him there rather than on the practice squad, despite being a healthy scratch each week, is telling, as it prevents another team from grabbing him.
Bentley could get a chance to make an impact with this team next year, but his rookie season will likely stay quiet.
Grade: C
Round 7, No. 257 overall: Red Murdock, LB, Buffalo
Despite a terrific preseason, fans were stunned when the Broncos cut Red Murdock, this year's Mr. Irrelevant, following the preseason. Luckily, he was not claimed by any other team and was signed back to the practice squad.
With the lack of depth at inside linebacker, it would be interesting to see the team try Murdock during the regular season, but it doesn't seem like a move this coaching staff will make. Instead, Murdock can look to become a bigger part of this team's plans starting next season.
Grade: C+
UDFA: Kolbe Katsis, WR, Northern Arizona
Kolbe Katsis is the only member of this year's undrafted free-agent class to see action during the regular season to this point for the team, and that was only as an elevation from the practice squad in Week 3 when Marvin Mims Jr. was out with an injury against the Los Angeles Rams.
Katsis handled kick and punt return duties in that game, returning four kickoffs for 107 yards and three punts for 39 yards, including one he brought back for 28 yards. Katsis was terrific in the preseason and likely earned confidence from the coaching staff with this performance.
He could easily become the future replacement for Mims (who is a free agent after this season), particularly if he can show more as a wide receiver.
Grade: B
Social: Follow Broncos Wire on Facebook and Twitter/X!
This article originally appeared on Broncos Wire: Grading the Broncos’ rookies from first half of the 2026 NFL season













