Colorado put up a fight against Cincinnati to keep their bowl game hopes alive, but ultimately, they couldn't overcome their mistakes. Four turnovers and six untimely penalties led to a disappointing 35-28 loss.
The turnovers started right off the bat, with an interception by Buffaloes quarterback Isaac Wilson. It was one of three he threw in the game, including a pick on Colorado's final offensive possession. In all fairness, two of the interceptions were purely amazing plays by Cincinnati's defenders. Still, the Bearcats scored 14 points off turnovers, which proved to be the difference in the game.
Here is the report card from Colorado's sixth Big 12 loss of the season.
Quarterback
Grade: B
This was certainly not Wilson's best game, with three interceptions,
which tied his career high. However, he did have a career-high of 312 passing yards, and it was just his second game with three passing touchdowns. His 177.3 passer rating in this game was also the second-highest in his career. Also, two of those interceptions are not fully his fault since they were simply great plays by Cincinnati's secondary. He is not the type of quarterback who will carry a team to victory with his performance, but he at least had a decent game. Wilson could be a decent backup for the Buffaloes next season, but he does not seem capable of being a starter.
Running Backs
Grade: C+
Honestly, it was disappointing to see Colorado put up only 121 rushing yards in this game after posting over 200 rushing yards in two of its past three games, including a season-high of 249 rushing yards in their upset win over Houston last week. Richard Young had 99 rushing yards in that game and three different backs had runs over 30 yards. But in this game, Young only had 55 rushing yards and no one on the Buffaloes' roster had a run over 20 yards. It is not like Cincinnati has an amazing run defense; they just gave up 285 rushing yards to Iowa State last week. Colorado's running backs should have been able to take advantage of this defense, and the fact that they didn't is a major reason they lost.
Receivers and Tight Ends
Grade: C
This was another good game from Joseph Williams, who had four receptions for 112 yards, including a 70-yard touchdown in the third quarter. So, Williams gets an A. But DeAndre Moore fumbled twice despite an otherwise solid game, with five receptions for 91 yards and a touchdown; he was lucky not to lose either. Quanell Farrakhan Jr. lost a fumble, and two of Isaac Wilson's interceptions were on targets to Ernest Campbell. However, they also had some explosive plays, with five different players getting receptions of at least 20 yards. There was a lot of good and a lot of bad, but overall, they could have done better.
Offensive Line
Grade: A-
Colorado only had 121 rushing yards, which is disappointing. That partially lies with the offensive line, but more of that is on the running backs. The Buffaloes' offensive line has been one of their more consistent units throughout this season. They have also generally performed well in pass protection, including in this game, giving up only one sack to the Bearcats' defense.
Defense
Grade: D
The key to stopping Cincinnati's offense was containing running back Cole Tabb. Colorado's defense royally failed at that endeavor, allowing him to have 230 total yards and four total touchdowns. He was the Bearcats' leading rusher and leading receiver in this game. They forced a turnover at the goal line in the fourth quarter, but it was easily their best play of the game and ultimately made no difference. They have also allowed over 200 rushing yards in each of the past two games after giving up an average of 149.9 rushing yards in the first eight games of the season, which is also a bad average. Colorado clearly needs to add to its run defense in the transfer portal if it wants to be competitive next season.
Special Teams
Grade: B
I cannot say Colorado did anything bad on special teams. Kicker Daniel Gerlach made all four of his extra point attempts. Punter Damon Greaves averaged 45 yards on his two punts, and DeAndre Moore had a 51-yard kick return. They also kept Cincinnati from having much success in the return game, with only 25 yards on their sole kick return and just 10 yards on their only punt return. Special teams actually played the best of Colorado's three phases, which may be a first since Deion Sanders became the head coach.
Coaching
Grade: C
It seems like in every game, there is at least one play call that doesn't make much sense. On Colorado's second-to-last possession, they took a deep shot on fourth-and-three, and it was incomplete. I get why they did that early in the game, and it worked. However, just because it worked before doesn't mean it will work again, and that didn't seem like the right decision on such a crucial play. They finally had a chance to get points off a turnover and blew it. Also, some of their penalties were easily preventable and should be addressed by the coaching staff.
Overall
Grade: C+
There were a lot of things that Colorado could have done better to win this game, especially minimizing the fumbles and at least partially containing Cole Tabb. However, that didn't happen, which is why the Buffaloes dropped a seventh game and will miss a bowl game for the second year in a row.
Contact/Follow us @BuffaloesWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook for ongoing coverage of Colorado news, notes, and opinions.
This article originally appeared on Buffaloes Wire: Colorado football report card from 35-28 loss to Cincinnati













