If you're looking for disagreement on whether the Alabama Crimson Tide deserve the No. 3 spot in the latest College Football Playoff rankings, you won't find it from Stephen A. Smith.
During a discussion of the committee's updated rankings on Wednesday's edition of "First Take," Smith said he had "no problem" with Alabama (8-2, 6-2 SEC) being ahead of No. 5 Texas (8-2, 5-2) and No. 9 Tennessee (8-2, 5-2), even with the Crimson Tide's 26-10 loss to the Volunteers on Oct. 17.
Smith said:
"When I look at Alabama, clearly the committee is not holding the (20-17) loss to Georgia against them. I think they should have held the Tennessee loss against them, because they got beat down in that particular game, make no mistake about that. But then I'm looking
at you right here, (and) you beat LSU. You stomped 'em. You won at Kentucky when they were a higher-ranked team. I'm looking at you against South Carolina, against Mississippi State. They were relevant at that particular moment in time when you handled your business against them."
Alabama's 56-23 blowout win over Mississippi State on Oct. 3 came when the Bulldogs were 4-0 and ranked No. 16 in the US LBM Coaches Poll.
South Carolina and Kentucky were unranked heading into their games against the Crimson Tide, but both have been in the selection committee's CFP rankings since their debut. The Wildcats were ranked No. 6 before suffering back-to-back losses to Tennessee and Florida. South Carolina had risen No. 17 before its five-game winning streak was snapped by Arkansas in Week 12.
Alabama rallied from a 17-13 deficit to beat the Wildcats, 45-17, in Lexington on Sept. 12 and hammered the Gamecocks, 49-18, on Sept. 26.
Why Stephen A. Smith agrees with Alabama football's CFP ranking
Smith pointed to Alabama's 31-13 win over LSU in Baton Rouge on Nov. 7 and compared it to Texas needing a last-second touchdown pass from Arch Manning to knock off the Tigers a week later.
"You did stomp LSU just over a week ago. I mean, you beat 'em like they stole something. It wasn't (like) Texas' thriller, 22-21 come-from-behind win in the last second. They beat LSU significantly more convincingly than Texas did. I get that Texas has got five wins in the top 25. I get that, but it's not like Texas got bounced to No. 10 or 12 or something like that. They're right there."
Smith continued:
"I just think that it's appropriate not to put (Texas) ahead of Alabama when you go up against a team like LSU, and you've got to come to the rescue and score in the waning seconds in order to win that game -- when Alabama, just a week earlier, I mean, beat the brakes off of them. I think that does matter, the proximity with those games... I've got to take that into consideration. I have no problem with where Alabama is."
How much is Alabama football paying Chattanooga for Week 12 FCS game?
— Roll Tide Wire (@RollTideWire) November 19, 2026
📸 Jeff Hanisch, USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Con https://t.co/l1DgXJ2V9H pic.twitter.com/4x4jVj9jT4
Alabama football schedule 2026
All times Central.
- Sept. 5: vs. East Carolina Pirates (W, 48-10)
- Sept. 12: at Kentucky Wildcats (W, 45-17)
- Sept. 19: vs. Florida State Seminoles (W, 50-36)
- Sept. 26: vs. South Carolina Gamecocks (W, 49-18)
- Oct. 3: at Mississippi State Bulldogs (W, 56-23)
- Oct. 10: vs. Georgia Bulldogs (L, 20-17)
- Oct. 17: at Tennessee Volunteers (L, 26-10)
- Oct. 24: vs. Texas A&M Aggies (W, 31-20)
- Nov. 7: at LSU Tigers (W, 31-13)
- Nov. 14: at Vanderbilt Commodores (W, 21-6)
- Nov. 21: vs. Chattanooga Mocs, 1 p.m., SEC Network+
- Nov. 28: vs. Auburn Tigers, 2:30 p.m. or 6:30 p.m.
Record: 8-2, 6-2 SEC.
Alabama football Week 12 opponent preview: Chattanooga Mocs
— Roll Tide Wire (@RollTideWire) November 19, 2026
📸 Wesley Hale, IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect https://t.co/Slg0yZN7BD pic.twitter.com/Vc7qcNAGsK
Contact us at @RollTideWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook for ongoing coverage of Alabama Crimson Tide news, notes and opinions.
This article originally appeared on Roll Tide Wire: Stephen A. Smith has thoughts on Alabama football's CFP ranking













