To some extent, every NFL quarterback is a rhythm quarterback. Ups and downs and good starts and bad starts are part of the job. Some quarterbacks are streakier than others, though - and you can make a case that there is no starter in the league that's more streaky than Michael Penix of the Atlanta Falcons.
Penix's return to the lineup in Week 3 at first appeared to be a turning point for this franchise - he played so well over the next five weeks that we were ready to crown him QB1 for the Falcons going forward.
In the three weeks since Penix has regressed so badly that many are wondering if the team should draft a QB in 2027 and start another quarterback competition next off-season - one that does not involve Tua Tagovailoa.
With such highs and
lows it can be difficult to fairly grade a QB. For what it's worth, Carter Bahns at CBS Sports has him at a C in his new piece grading each starter on their rookie contracts.
"With all of the star talent on the Falcons offense, the team needs its quarterback to perform at a high level and get the most out of Bijan Robinson and Drake London. As they enter the prime of their careers, it is paramount that Penix makes strides. The franchise cannot afford to let its two greatest assets go to waste. In that sense, Penix's slow development is a problem. But at the same time, his flashes suggest that there is a franchise quarterback in him. Back-to-back three-touchdown games in October were emblematic of the ceiling that made him worthy of a first-round pick."
You could make the case that Penix has been more good than bad this season, but a C grade isn't unfair if we're looking at the season as a whole.
Odds are Penix's struggles will continue at least another game - as the Falcons face the Minnesota Vikings and their top-ranked scoring defense when they return from their bye week. Perhaps the extra time will help Penix and the Falcons offense get things turned around before Week 12 arrives.
Hopefully Penix can rebound after that against a series of softer opponents. If he can't, then the Falcons' brass might correctly assume that he's broken - at least broken enough to warrant bringing in some competition next year and not just giving him the QB1 job by default.
This article originally appeared on Falcons Wire: Falcons QB Michael Penix Jr. gets a C grade from CBS Sports













