The New England Patriots could be facing a make-or-break moment for their 2026 NFL season, and that's not an understatement. Injuries are part of the game; players know that, coaches know that, and fans know that, but losing a quarterback like Drake Maye with the team sitting at 5-5 is an obvious cause for concern.
Maye's injury specifically could be a season-shifting moment for the Patriots, as ESPN's Adam Schefter reported early Monday that there's concern that he may have fractured his ankle, which could sideline him for the rest of the season.
The Patriots are concerned that QB Drake Maye fractured his ankle, per sources. Maye remained in Germany to undergo additional testing to determine whether he needs surgery. Either way, he is out indefinitely,
if not for the season. pic.twitter.com/54Znb8Xwug
— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) November 16, 2026
NFL Network's Ian Rapoport also added that while the Patriots flew back home from Germany, Maye stayed behind and will be evaluated further when he returns.
Obviously, the specific injury is unknown, but the Patriots seem to be bracing for the worst. If that is the case, what's next for New England at quarterback? Tommy DeVito stepped in and completed 12-of-24 passes for 81 yards, one touchdown and one interception in a game that the Detroit Lions had control of by the time halftime hit.
Assuming the Patriots want to look outside their quarterback room, here are a few options they could consider.
Jimmy Garoppolo
Is it officially time for Jimmy G to make his return? Coming back to the place where his career began would be quite the storyline. And admittedly, with the trade deadline now past, Garoppolo could be their best option among the free-agent quarterbacks currently on the market. I wouldn't be surprised at all if the Patriots at least bring him in for a workout and to get a feel for where he's at, and that could be a situation to monitor.
Derek Carr
I'm far from convinced that Derek Carr is still contemplating any sort of an NFL comeback. However, he retired in May 2025 and is only 35. While Carr battled injuries specifically in his final NFL season, he completed 67.7% of his passes over 10 games in 2024, throwing for 2,145 yards, 15 touchdowns and five interceptions.
If Carr is still in football shape and the door to a return to the NFL remains open, the Patriots should at least get on the phone and see if it's possible.
Cooper Rush or Brandon Allen
This is sort of the "bring in competition and see what happens" move. Let Cooper Rush or Brandon Allen compete with DeVito, and the best quarterback gets the nod. It's far from ideal, and not the type of move you'd hope for when all is said and done, but adding one of the two veterans (at least) gives you some competition and options to work with while deciding how to approach the rest of the season.
Rush and Allen's recent stops are an obvious cause for concern, especially the former, who started two games this year for the Atlanta Falcons and four last year with the Baltimore Ravens. Over that stretch, he threw just one touchdown pass against eight interceptions, so we'd need to see Rush revert to his days stepping in for the Dallas Cowboys before we could feel confident he's a better option than DeVito.
This article originally appeared on For The Win: 3 Patriots QB options after Drake Maye injury, with 1 reunion that (finally) makes sense













