10 weeks down. Four to go. The sprint to the fantasy football playoffs has begun.
That means tough decisions need to be made for rosters ravaged by injuries or sitting on their league's cut line. Underperforming stars have to be sent to the bench or worse. Inconsistent sleepers may not produce the juice needed to justify a squeeze. As margins for error narrow, success and regret even out the scales of fantasy justice.
Let's see if we can't tilt them closer to the former.
Keep, drop or trade is our weekly breakdown of the underperforming studs and overperforming sleepers who could be in for a sudden momentum change that could sink fantasy rosters or carry them to pretend sports Valhalla. I'm joined by our resident fantasy expert and Rhode Island
Scumbag Mike "Yaj" Boyajian to talk about six players who might have you cursing projected point totals on a weekly basis.
Who should you keep? Who should you bench? And who should you trade or drop as the actual NFL season crashes into its back nine?
Hopefully we can clear things up for you.
WR Tetairoa McMillan, Carolina Panthers
Christian: Hold and start. If only to avoid the hindsight embarrassment of missing out on a 40-point explosion in favor of a seven-point day from someone like Tank Dell. McMillan is still getting red zone and end zone targets, even if they’re coming much less frequently. Bryce Young was never going to be the high impact passer he was in Weeks 1-5, but he’s also better than he has been the last four weeks when his average passing yards per game have dropped by more than 100. The only way out is through if Young wants a fat contract extension. That means defaulting to McMillan whenever possible.
Yaj: Hold. For me, this is what you sign up for with someone like McMillan. He’s going to have some incredibly lean weeks, but those will be accompanied by some really nice booms. The problem is predicting the peaks and valleys.
The targets will always be there. It simply comes down to what he can do with them. Either way, he’s a low WR2 or high WR3.
WR Jalen Coker, Carolina Panthers
Christian: Hold and bench. In all honesty, you should probably drop him. But this is not an objective decision for me. It’s a very subjective one as a card-carrying Coke-head.
Coker’s numbers have dropped off a cliff when it comes to fantasy stats and regressed back to league-average from an advanced stat perspective. He only has 19 targets and seven catches his last four games and receiving bagel on us against the Saints (he gained three yards via carry and that’s it).
He’s struggled as a supersized slot receiver this year, but still has potential split wide, where he’s averaging nearly nine yards per target. My lizard brain wants to believe Dave Canales, who has adjusted on the fly to strong results in the past, is capable of doing that again. Like McMillan, there’s too much pressure to ignore what works in Charlotte.
Yaj: Trade. Coker had a couple awesome weeks, especially Week 1, but hasn’t done much over the course of the season if we look at the big picture. The positives are the Panthers have not stopped throwing the ball and he continues to see a moderate amount of targets. But McMillian and Hubbard lead the way in this offense. If you drafted him, it was a nice score for a late round dart throw. With bye weeks still pending and the season winding down, ship him to a receiver-needy manager and strengthen your squad instead.
TE Tyler Warren, Indianapolis Colts
Christian: Hold, bench if possible. Warren has turned 20 targets into 63 yards and zero touchdowns since returning from injury in Week 8. But, look, someone has to catch passes for the Colts. From the 2025 group that helped fuel a Daniel Jones breakout:
- Alec Pierce is injured.
- Michael Pittman is injured (and also, a Pittsburgh Steeler).
- Josh Downs is a Kansas City Chief.
At some point, Jones will fully revert to his Giants form and rely solely on short checkdowns and hope his playmakers can do the heavy lifting from there. That’s great news for Indianapolis’s running backs. It should be, at least in theory, great news for Warren as well.
Yaj: Bench. The Colts don’t have much left in terms of pass catchers. Warren happens to be the best one left. One would think this would lead to a Brock Bowers-esque level of targets and usage, but that hasn’t been the case.
You simply can’t trust him right now. Daniel Jones looks terrible. Unless we see Anthony Richardson get some playing time, Warren’s value may simply stay cratered. I was not encouraged by the usage with the “new look” offense after the trades of Josh Downs and Keenan Allen.
RB Tyler Allgeier, Arizona Cardinals
Christian: Drop. The bloom is off the onion. Allgeier isn’t taking opponents by surprise. His 60 rush yards over the last two weeks are 15 fewer than a similar back would be expected to get in the Arizona offense. Carson Beck’s presence will only heighten the focus on the Cardinal backfield. Then, even if he has some productive weeks, he’s set to be supplanted by Jeremiyah Love on the rookie’s return from injured reserve.
Yaj: Drop. The explosion of production we saw in Week 8 was a nothingburger. He’s gone right back to his plodding ways, even with the extended opportunity he’s been given with Love on IR. The team simply isn’t very good, and Bam Knight has looked objectively better by comparison in almost every opportunity he’s been given.
Let this be someone else’s problem. Drop him for Knight if you want a piece of the Cardinals backfield.
RB Braelon Allen, New York Jets
Christian: Trade. Allen’s volume has seen its expected decrease with Breece Hall’s return. His efficiency has dipped as well – 16 carries the last two weeks have resulted in -14 rush yards over expected (RYOE). He’s brought minimal utility in the passing game (three targets, 27 yards). He has value as a fill-in with a solid floor, but that stretch of guaranteed double-digit performances is over. Can you interest someone in your league in a high value backup with an impressive 2026 resume and limited prospects barring another injury?
Yaj: Hold. Yes, it’s been a tough couple weeks with Breece Hall back in the fold, but the schedule is softening up a bit in the coming weeks, with matchups with the Chargers and Dolphins on tap. Allen is still getting the majority of the early downs work. The problem is the Jets have spent a lot of time in catchup mode, and that’s Breece Hall’s role.
The upcoming weeks will be very telling. I’m leaning towards Allen getting back on track with his production.
TE Chigoziem Okonkwo, Washington Commanders
Christian: Hold. He’s turned 59 routes into 15 targets the last two weeks. The Commanders will be trailing plenty over the back half of the regular season. The points will come.
Yaj: Hold. This is a tough one for me. Mainly, the numbers aren’t numbering. He’s getting plenty of targets (at least seven in three of the last four games), he’s just not doing much with them. He’s faced some defenses that are really tough on tight ends (the Philadelphia Eagles, Los Angeles Rams and New York Giants all are top 10 worst matchups for fantasy TEs), but the schedule softens up moving forward.
Unless someone like Mark Andrews is on the wire (Brissett loves his tight ends), you are sticking with Chig anyway. Keep the faith. He should turn it around.
This article originally appeared on For The Win: Fantasy football keep, drop, trade, Week 11: What to do with Tyler Warren, Panthers WRs?













