When the Los Angeles Rams placed Puka Nacua on injured reserve last week, they did so with the expectation that he would miss about a month and be activated in time for the final stretch. He would miss the required four games and then hopefully return in time for matchups with the Cowboys, Seahawks, Buccaneers and Seattle again in the final four weeks.
But on Friday, Sean McVay told reporters that Nacua underwent surgery to repair his injured MCL and will likely miss the rest of the season. The way he delivered the news was certainly interesting.
"Puka Nacua decided to get surgery on his MCL on Tuesday, so that'll be a couple months for him," McVay said.
The words "Puka Nacua decided to get surgery" are telling. He didn't say, "Puka Nacua needs
surgery" or "We decided Puka Nacua should get surgery." It was, "Puka Nacua decided."
That suggests Nacua, not the team, wanted the surgery. In other words, Nacua is prioritizing his long-term health over the short-term outlook of potentially returning to the Rams this season. For a player whose contract expires in March, and someone who's bound to get a massive payday soon, it's understandable.
That wasn't the only alarming remark from McVay. He said "they" were great with their communication, and that "it's a learning opp."
"It was something that we always knew was a possibility and they were great with their communication with us, and that's really kind of all I can add to it," he said. "Other than it was something that, based on the steps and the protocols that took place, something that we thought was a possibility, and it's an unfortunate thing. It's a learning opp."
He continued, saying the injury "happened a while ago" and there has been "a lot of discussion and dialogue behind the scenes." Not to get too granular, but is McVay frustrated that it took this long to come to a decision about surgery? Is that why he pointed out that it "happened a while ago?"
"It's something that obviously happened a while ago that there's been a lot of discussion and dialogue behind the scenes, and, you know, we'll learn from it, we'll grow," he said.
What's there to learn from? How can they grow from it?
McVay said that when the injury happened, he knew "this was more likely the direction this would go," which contradicts what he said over a week ago. He originally said Nacua would miss about a month, and there was a point when the Rams weren't even going to put him on IR until they "needed a roster spot." It was clear they fully expected him to be back this season.
So what changed? Nacua got more information and likely considered his future beyond this season.
"It's just more of, you know, you had to get some different information, talk to people, and there's a lot of thought and conversations that go into whether you're gonna do that or not, and what's the best plan of action for return to performance for him? Not exclusive to this year, but, you know, for his career moving forward," McVay said. "And so he was very thorough and deliberate about that, but I did think that this was a possibility. I knew that was a serious injury that he sustained, whether he got it fixed or not, with the shot that he took to his knee. He had the toe injury, and so in my mind, this was kind of always a direction that we had to plan upon anyways."
Rich Eisen and Daniel Jeremiah took notice of McVay's phrasing, too. They were alarmed by the lack of "we" in his comments, and the frequent "he" and "they" word choices.
"It doesn't sound like they were completely on the same page because there was no 'we' there. So I think probably some frustration on the team side of things," Jeremiah said. "And understandably because of where Matthew Stafford is in his career and you're trying to make a push here. You go literally all-in all-in to get Aaron Donald to come back on top of the Aaron Donald move and the (Trent) McDuffie move."
"It doesn't sound like they were completely on the same page." @MoveTheSticks responds to Sean McVay's comments on Puka Nacua having surgery.
— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) November 20, 2026
(via @RichEisenShow) pic.twitter.com/jGMnwuy2Ra
Nacua is notably set to be a free agent in March. The Rams opted not to extend him last offseason, likely in part because of Nacua's off-field slip-ups. And now with Nacua set to sign a massive contract (or franchise tag), he's protecting himself ahead of what will be the biggest offseason of his career.
If the Rams had signed Nacua in the offseason, it's reasonable to think that maybe he'd push through the injury and play this season, putting off surgery until a later date. He would've already gotten paid, securing his financial future. But right now, he has no long-term security with the Rams, and that may have played into the decision to get surgery.
This article originally appeared on Rams Wire: Sean McVay's phrasing around Puka Nacua's surgery raises questions













