The Los Angeles Rams’ Super Bowl hopes took a significant hit on Friday when Sean McVay told reporters that Puka Nacua underwent surgery on his MCL and will miss a couple of months. The injury will likely cause Nacua to miss the rest of the season, and while McVay wouldn’t rule him out for the playoffs, he’s “planning on not having him” the rest of the way.
The worst part is the injury might’ve been completely avoidable.
It occurred on the Rams’ final offensive snap against the Washington Commanders in Week 9. They were leading 20-13 with 1:44 left in the fourth quarter and Washington was out of timeouts.
McVay called a jet sweep to Nacua, his 15th touch of the game, which went for 5 yards on third-and-11. McVay knew the Rams probably weren’t going
to pick up the first down on that play – only seven of Nacua’s 40 career carries have gained at least 11 yards – but it was a way to kill the clock and get the ball into his best player’s hands.
Nacua had already touched the ball 14 times before that, taking a beating throughout the game. Even though he’s their more reliable offensive player, Nacua didn’t need to be the guy touching the ball on that final play. A simple handoff to Kyren Williams or Blake Corum would’ve done the job.
But McVay tried to get creative and catch the defense off guard by giving it to Nacua in the backfield. It didn’t work, and that one virtually meaningless play may have derailed the Rams’ season.
Rams WR Puka Nacua suffered the knee injury that required surgery Tuesday on this play. He finished that game with 14 catches for 150 yards and a touchdown. pic.twitter.com/BubkWyGrJa
— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) November 20, 2026
Sure, you could argue that the game wasn’t over, and the Commanders even made things interesting on the ensuing drive by getting to the Rams’ 31-yard line. But any play to keep the clock running would’ve done the job on third-and-11. It’s not as if it was third-and-short where the Rams were likely to move the chains and end the game.
McVay even admitted a day after the game that he was “kicking” himself for that play call and has questioned the decision “over and over,” knowing the consequences of losing Nacua. That was almost two weeks ago, before the Rams knew Nacua needed surgery.
“I'm kicking myself about those things,” he said. “… I'd be lying to you if I said I haven't questioned the decision making on that last play over and over in my head of what could have been another option that you felt like could have gotten a conversion and maybe end of the game that would have led to him not taking a violent hit to his right knee. It’s stuff that I feel tremendous responsibility for, and we have to be able to figure out how to protect these guys while also putting them in positions that help our team and allow them to be able to shine.”
Now that he’s likely out for the year, it makes the call even worse.
Among the Rams’ pass catchers, Nacua has been the most trustworthy and consistent all year. It was already going to be tough for them to make a run to the Super Bowl with him, but the odds are stacked against them now that he’s out a couple of months.
Davante Adams will miss at least one more game, as will Terrance Ferguson. Maybe the passing game will kick into gear when those guys return. But for another week, it’ll be Konata Mumpfield, CJ Daniels, Tutu Atwell and Xavier Smith leading the receiving corps.
Injuries happen in the NFL, but there are times when coaches can keep their players out of harm’s way. That final play against the Commanders was one of those times.
This article originally appeared on Rams Wire: One questionable play call may have crushed Rams' Super Bowl chances













