With the Philadelphia Eagles idle in Week 10, fans and the media had a little extra time on their hands. That probably meant watching more football featuring other teams than usual. There was one obvious benefit to the weekend. For once, an Eagles game wasn't going to be the source of everyone's stress.
The action got started Thursday night when the New York Giants hosted the Washington Commanders. With two NFC East teams facing each other, somebody was guaranteed a win unless the game ended in another tie. Thankfully, it didn't. The Commanders escaped with a road victory in a wildly entertaining contest.
Sunday brought another division matchup of sorts, with the Dallas Cowboys hosting the San Francisco 49ers at AT&T Stadium. At times, the crowd
sounded more like a 49ers home audience, which probably wasn't what Dallas had in mind. There isn't much new to report on Joe Milton with the Eagles on bye. Still, the other three starting quarterbacks in the division gave us plenty to evaluate as the individual stocks of these players, and the teams they play on, continue to fluctuate as Week 11 in the NFC East is on the horizon.
Joe Milton, Philadelphia Eagles (Idle in Week 10)
Week 10 verdict: Possibly overbought
In the stock market, an 'overbought' investment has climbed too quickly, leaving it vulnerable to a correction. That's a reasonable way to describe the expectations surrounding Joe Milton as he tries to prove he's a good NFL starter while leading a troubled Eagles team. The physical tools are intriguing, but the circumstances surrounding his arrival and first start make it difficult to know what Philadelphia actually has.
Two questions are worth asking before drawing firm conclusions: Where is the opportunity for success in this situation, and how fairly can Milton be judged when so much around him is working against him? He has already been asked to operate behind a struggling offensive line and within an offense that has offered little consistency.
Week 11 should provide another piece of the evaluation, but expecting one performance to answer every question would be premature. The market may have gotten ahead of itself, but the next game should tell us more about whether the investment has real staying power.
Jayden Daniels, Washington Commanders
Week 10 verdict: High-beta stock
High-beta stocks tend to move dramatically. They can deliver impressive gains when conditions are favorable, but they can also take a considerable hit when things turn against them. Jayden Daniels provided a little of both Thursday night. He finished with 23 completions on 33 attempts, 249 passing yards, three touchdown passes, two interceptions, and 28 yards on 11 carries.
The Commanders got the win, and Daniels finished with three touchdown passes. That's the headline Washington would prefer to emphasize. However, his two late interceptions nearly turned a victory into another frustrating result, making it fair to wonder how much attention should be paid to the mistakes when the quarterback also delivered the winning score. Winning matters most, but those turnovers cannot simply be brushed aside.
Washington is now 3-5-1, while the Giants sit atop the division. There is also the lingering concern whenever Daniels takes a significant hit or goes to the ground awkwardly. His arm brace serves as a visible reminder of the injury concerns that have followed him. The talent is undeniable, but the volatility makes him one of the more difficult quarterbacks in the division to evaluate week to week.
J.J. McCarthy, New York Giants
Week 10 verdict: Climbing a wall of worry
On Wall Street, climbing a wall of worry describes a stock that keeps rising despite plenty of reasons for investors to be nervous. That's an appropriate description of the Giants, who have somehow worked their way to the top of the NFC East despite a revolving door at quarterback.
Jaxson Dart went 1-1 as a starter, Jameis Winston went 2-1-1, and now J.J. McCarthy is adding another chapter to the unlikely story. McCarthy is 2-1 as a starter after beginning his New York tenure by stepping in and playing well in relief.
As a starter, he has thrown two touchdown passes and two interceptions. The numbers leave plenty of room for debate about what comes next. The Giants are enjoying success, but there is understandable skepticism about how sustainable it will be.
McCarthy has shown enough to keep the team competitive, yet questions remain about whether his current level of play represents a foundation for growth or something closer to his ceiling.
Dak Prescott, Dallas Cowboys
Week 10 verdict: Swimming against the tide
Sometimes a stock can be fundamentally sound while the broader market around it is falling apart. Dak Prescott is in that position with the Cowboys, at least when he's playing like he did Sunday. He threw for 343 yards and five touchdowns against the 49ers, added an interception, and somehow, he still walked away with a loss.
Quarterbacks receive plenty of credit when their teams win, and they often absorb more than their share of blame when things go wrong. Prescott deserved better from the people around him in this one. Five touchdown passes should be enough to put a team in position to win, but Dallas continues to find ways to undermine its own efforts.
The Jekyll-and-Hyde nature of the Cowboys remains difficult to ignore. They can look like a legitimate contender one week and then find another way to disappoint when an opportunity presents itself. Prescott may be doing enough to keep Dallas in the conversation, but the supporting cast and the team's overall inconsistency remain significant obstacles. The Cowboys still have a path to the NFC East title, but they may have to keep swimming against the tide to get there.
This article originally appeared on Eagles Wire: NFC East QB stock watch: Dak Prescott shines, Jayden Daniels rallies













