The Cleveland Browns are 6-4 and firmly in the hunt for an AFC Wild Card spot. If you had asked Browns fans before the season began, a six-win season would have been perfectly acceptable, but being in the thick of things means Cleveland is well ahead of schedule. However, the franchise has a massive decision to make, and one that might not be as easy as some might think.
Quarterback Deshaun Watson is in the final year of his $231 million extension he signed back in 2021. While he has led Cleveland to multiple game-winning drives late in the fourth quarter of games this season, statistically he has been well below average this season:
- 2,118 passing yards (16th)
- 7 passing touchdowns (T-26th)
- 4 interceptions (T-6th)
- 40.1 QBR (28th)
- 65.1% completion percentage (15th)
There are two ways to truly look at this.
Option 1 is that the Browns see that Watson has Cleveland ahead of schedule
and decide to re-sign the former first-round pick. Statistics aside, Watson has kept Cleveland in games they should have lost and has shown an ability to be ice cold during pivotal drives. He has elevated both rookie wide receivers this year and established tight end Harold Fannin Jr. as an emerging weapon in the league.
Option 2 is to extend Watson as a bridge quarterback and select a quarterback in the first round of the 2027 NFL Draft. The Browns are projected to pick 17th overall, which could be in range to grab a prospect like South Carolina's LaNorris Sellers or Darian Mensah. Or, with Cleveland having two first-round picks this year, they could realize they are close and move up to get a premier option like Notre Dame's CJ Carr.
In this writer's opinion, option two is the correct choice. While Cleveland has done a phenomenal job drafting over the last two years, they still need a few key pieces to take that next step, and they will have limited flexability to do so if they extend Watson long-term for a premium price. This franchise is close, so why not take a shot at moving up for someone like Carr? What would the price be to move up to one or two and select Oklahoma State's Drew Mestemaker?
This article originally appeared on Browns Wire: Should the Cleveland Browns extend Deshaun Watson?













