A little over a month ago, Ohio State went into Bloomington and beat No. 5 Indiana 19-15. The Buckeyes were 6-1, they'd just knocked off a top-five team on the road, and the season still had everything in front of it.
They haven't won a game that mattered since. Three losses in four games — 30-18 at USC, 41-28 to Oregon, 31-28 at Nebraska — with only a 28-19 win over Northwestern in between. Ohio State is 7-4, the Big Ten title and College Football Playoff hopes are gone, and Indiana coach Curt Cignetti said this week what everybody in Columbus has been thinking.
"We ripped the heart out of that team," Cignetti said. "They haven't been the same since, without the quarterback."
He's not wrong. Here's what went wrong.
The Sayin injury changed everything for Ohio State
Ohio State coach Ryan Day said
that QB Julian Sayin is out indefinitely. There’s a plan being put in place for Sayin not being available for both the regular season and postseason. He said there’s no specific timeline on the recovery. He’s dealing with an injury on his throwing… pic.twitter.com/b3AZ669S21
— Pete Thamel (@PeteThamel) October 20, 2026
The Indiana win cost Ohio State its starting quarterback. Julian Sayin fractured his right elbow in Bloomington and is out for the season, and the offense hasn't been the same without him. True freshman Luke Fahey was thrown into the lineup, and he's been what you'd expect a true freshman to be — flashes of real talent, and stretches where the moment gets to him.
Fahey was terrific in the first half at Nebraska, going 9-of-12 for 163 yards and two touchdowns. The second half was a different story: 7-of-15 for 96 yards, and a fourth-quarter interception that set up the touchdown that put the game away. He finished 16-of-27 for 259 yards, two touchdowns and a pick. That's the story of the last month in a nutshell — good enough to compete, not good enough to close.
The Ohio State defense can't get off the field
Ryan Day on the defense’s performance: “We’re not gonna win many games if we’re giving up 31 points and only getting two stops in the whole game.”
— Dan Hope (@Dan_Hope) November 21, 2026
Asked about potential coaching staff changes, Day said Ohio State will evaluate after next week’s game against Michigan.
The defense gave up 30 or more points in each of the three losses, and the Nebraska game was the worst of it. The Huskers ran 73 plays to Ohio State's 49, held the ball for 35:05, converted 10 of 16 third downs, and went 4-for-4 in the red zone. Ryan Day said it himself after the game: "We're not gonna win many games if we're giving up 31 points and only getting two stops in the whole game."
The defensive line was a question mark coming into the season, and it took 11 games to show how thin it really is. Nebraska ran for 176 yards, and when Ohio State needed a stop in the fourth quarter, it got a field goal, then a touchdown, then a third-down conversion to run out the clock. Defensive coordinator Matt Patriciais under as much scrutiny as anybody on the staff right now, and Day didn't exactly rush to his defense on Saturday. "We don't have a choice," Day said. "We've got to get this thing together next week to go win this game."
The mistakes keep piling up for the Buckeyes
Offensive mistakes, defensive collapse derail Ohio State in loss to Nebraska https://t.co/iHtmnasQXH
— Columbus Dispatch (@DispatchAlerts) November 21, 2026
The turnovers and penalties have been a season-long problem, and they were the difference in Lincoln. Ohio State turned it over twice and Nebraska turned it over zero times, and both Buckeye giveaways turned into Nebraska touchdowns — 14 points in a three-point game. Isaiah West fumbled at midfield in the second quarter, and Fahey's fourth-quarter interception set up the score that made it 31-21.
Then there were the penalties: seven flags for 55 yards, including two false starts, two holding calls, a delay of game, and one on Day himself for sideline interference. After the 14-play, 76-yard drive that tied the game at 21 in the third quarter, Ohio State's next two drives went for minus-13 total yards. That's how a season slips away — not in one big moment, but in a pile of small ones.
The Ohio State offensive line has not been good enough
Ohio State has several veteran offensive linemen that frankly haven't gotten better. Joel Klatt just accurately criticized them. The Buckeyes needed the unit to be a strength.
— Ryan Burke (@ryanburke24) November 21, 2026
Day gushed about the offensive line during fall camp, and it made everyone think that not going into the portal to get some talent there was going to be the right move. After all, it was a veteran line with returners at all spots, some holdovers from a national championship run in 2024.
At this point in the season, it's clear that the line has not been up to the task. The rushing game hasn't been explosive because the guys up front haven't been able to push quality defensive lines around, or hold blocks at the point of attack to open up holes for Bo Jackson and company. The line hasn't been good in pass protection either. Julian Sayin suffered a bit in his accuracy this season, got knocked out of the lineup with injury, and Fahey has had pressure in his face since coming on as well. All of it is because the big uglies can't keep the pocket clean.
Jeremiah Smith has been the only constant
Despite the loss, Jeremiah Smith is still in a league of his own 👑
— ESPN Insights (@ESPNInsights) November 21, 2026
🌟 17 Rec TD, tied the single season Ohio State record
🌟 18th career 100-yard receiving game, most in Big Ten history
🌟 First WR in Big Ten history to eclipse 4,000 receiving yards
He is the current favorite… pic.twitter.com/NpD02wPu2F
Through all of it, Jeremiah Smith has been Jeremiah Smith. He had six catches for 165 yards and two touchdowns against Nebraska, and he's now at 86 catches for 1,482 yards and 17 touchdowns on the season. The 165 yards gave him his 18th career 100-yard game, a Big Ten record, the second touchdown tied Terry Glenn's Ohio State single-season record, and he became the first Big Ten receiver ever to reach 4,000 career receiving yards.
Nebraska coach Matt Rhule said after the game that Smith should win the Heisman. He might be right, and it might not matter — no player has won the Heisman on a team with four regular-season losses since 1969. The best player in college football is having a historic season, and his team is 7-4.
What's next for Ohio State: Michigan week
Ohio State was the preseason No. 1 team in America and up 23-3 against No. 4 Texas in Week 2.
— Conner Smith (@CSmithMedia) November 21, 2026
They are now fight to finish 8-4 next week against Michigan…wow. Not the season we all thought we’d see.
What's left is Michigan, next Saturday at noon ET in Ohio Stadium, and that game is now the whole season. Ohio State is looking for its first back-to-back wins in the rivalry since the eight-game winning streak ended in 2019, and Day knows what's at stake. "We gotta go beat the team up north," he said after the Nebraska loss. "At the end of the day, you come to Ohio State to go win that game, so that's all that matters."
After that comes an offseason that figures to look a lot like a reboot. Day has already said a lot of things have to change, and the staff evaluation starts the moment the Michigan game ends. The Buckeyes went 1-3 in a four-game span twice in the past year — something that hadn't happened since the end of 2013 and the start of 2014. That tells you how far this season has fallen from where it was supposed to go.
Contact/Follow us @BuckeyesWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Ohio State news, notes and opinion. Follow Phil Harrison on X: @PhilHarrisonBW.
This article originally appeared on Buckeyes Wire: Ohio State was 6-1 and rolling. What has gone wrong since Indiana?













