Some NFL teams wait decades to find their franchise quarterback. The New York Giants may have found two in two years.
Last year, they traded up into the first round to nab Jaxson Dart of Ole Miss. Dart came in, wowed the league with his arm, legs, and swagger and injected much-needed life and imagination into the Giants' offense.
This year, Dart came out of the box firing on all cylinders, leading the Giants to a convincing opening-night win over the Dallas Cowboys. The next week, however, disaster struck. Dart suffered a knee injury in the first half of the Giants' road loss to the Rams in Los Angeles, which required surgery and will sideline him for the next three months.
First-year head coach John Harbaugh and general manager Joe Schoen aren't
a pair inclined to sit back. They knew backup quarterback Jameis Winston, although talented, wasn't the ideal candidate to run their offense. They began to seek out solutions.
The Minnesota Vikings had demoted 2024 first-round pick J.J. McCarthy to third string. He had not meshed with head coach Kevin O'Connell, and the Vikings were looking to part ways with him.
Schoen swooped in and sent Minnesota a fifth-round pick for McCarthy. The Giants saw him as a player with a skill set similar to Dart's. Harbaugh and his staff went to work to integrate McCarthy into the offense they designed for Dart.
It has gone exceedingly well. So far, McCarthy has made the Giants viable again. He is a playmaker very much in the vein of Dart.
JJ McCarthy
— Derek Brown (@DBro_FFB) November 16, 2026
Among 35 qual QBs
(per @FantasyPtsData)
3rd in yards per attempt
19th in passing success rate
7th in catchable target rate
1st in hero throw rate
12th in EPA per dropback pic.twitter.com/oDpSUHxo2B
Giants great Phil Simms, who knows a thing or two about quarterbacking in New York, believes the Giants have gotten more than lucky with McCarthy.
“I would tell Giant fans, ‘You’re lucky as hell,’” Simms told Steve Serby of The Post. “You had a quarterback that we knew and believed would have got it done and led the Giants to the playoffs. “But you got this second guy because of the [Dart] injury coming in that he has kinda kept hope alive.”
Simms believes McCarthy, who has led the Giants to a 2-2 record as a starter, has done well, with the two losses by a score or less. He sees McCarthy as someone who exudes confidence and is "fun to watch."
“I think he’s so far exceeded all expectations from anybody,” Simms said. “He is an aggressive decision-maker and aggressive thrower...He’s given the Giants a chance to win every game.”
The Giants are 5-3-1 and in first place in the NFC East with eight games remaining. They have some tough tests ahead. The first test is this Sunday against the Jacksonville Jaguars (7-2), the first team the Giants will face this season with a winning record.
Simms isn't too concerned with the daunting road ahead. According to him, the Giants are already far ahead of the game.
“It’ll be interesting down the stretch here," he said. “The Giant fan has seen they got another quarterback who’s exciting, who can really get the ball down the field, and you can tell he has confidence. I want the coaches to have more faith … to do even more. They will, because he’s already passed those other tests. He’s got the answers to a lot of ’em. So what do you do? Well, ‘Let’s give him a little more and see if he can figure this one out.’"
McCarthy has been settling into the offense and the culture with each passing week. He has the faith of the coaches and his teammates and soon, the fans.
Simms is right. If anything, the next few months will be interesting. This season has gone from one on life support to one filled with hope.
This article originally appeared on Giants Wire: Phil Simms: Giants are 'lucky as hell' to have landed J.J. McCarthy













