New York Giants head coach John Harbaugh confirmed Friday that he grades every play from every player on the roster as part of a long-standing evaluation system.
The process requires reviewing extensive game film and applying a mathematical equation developed by members of the staff. Grades are produced for each of the roughly 48 players (on the active gameday roster) and are also compiled for the offense, defense and special teams as units from game to game.
“Yeah, you just go through it, and it’s a system we’ve been doing for a long time,” Harbaugh told reporters. “But it’s one thing to have an impression of what you see. It’s another thing to have it validated by just what hopefully is at least my perspective.”
He noted that every grading method,
including those from outside sources such as Pro Football Focus, involves a degree of judgment. Harbaugh said his own assessments carry particular weight in the process.
“To me, I feel like my judgment is important. So, it matters what I think,” Harbaugh said. “So, you go back and you look at it and at the end, sometimes I’m surprised. I’m like, oh, man, he’s a little higher in the rankings maybe than I would have expected or a little lower. Sometimes that happens.”
Players see the grades and are free to ask about them, though Harbaugh said such conversations do not occur often. Discussions more commonly focus on specific plays rather than the overall grades.
The system continues to shape evaluations as the Giants work through the final stretch of the regular season.
This article originally appeared on Giants Wire: Inside John Harbaugh’s every-play grading system for Giants













