Steve Smith Sr. offered pointed criticism of New York Giants wide receiver Malik Nabers this week, labeling the third-year star “a bit entitled” while acknowledging he remains a fan of the player.
On his 89 podcast, the former Carolina Panthers wide receiver addressed Nabers’ recent public comments questioning the Giants’ play-calling following a loss to the Washington Commanders. Smith, known for his old-school approach, said young players sometimes need to “shut up and sometimes not talk.”
“Here’s where things are going to get a little dicey," Smith said. "And I have to be very careful because I am a Malik Nabers fan. I’m also old school in regard to veterans. I also believe young guys need to shut up and sometimes not talk. Nabers is a hell
of a talent who will be a staple in whatever community. Malik Nabers is also a bit entitled. He has a very very shallow file in his career in the NFL.”
Smith expanded on the theme in a post on X.
I love Malik Nabers. That's exactly why I'm gonna get on him.
— Steve Smith Sr. (@SteveSmithSr89) November 18, 2026
Being gifted don't mean you earned the right to demand the ball. Everybody in this league is gifted.
You EARN that 👇https://t.co/dOwa2NnNHU
The comments come amid scrutiny of Nabers’ body language and on-field demeanor. FOX analyst Greg Olsen recently noted the fine line between demanding the football as a competitor and allowing that intensity to detract from teammates.
Smith agreed with the spirit of that critique from an analyst’s perspective, stressing that great receivers must still celebrate others’ success and adopt a growth mindset.
Nabers has produced as the Giants’ clear No. 1 option when healthy, including a strong rookie campaign in 2024 before a torn ACL limited him in 2025. Smith has previously graded Nabers’ skill set highly and called him a dynamic playmaker. His latest remarks frame the critique as constructive, rooted in the belief that talent and draft status alone do not automatically grant the standing to publicly challenge the offense.
Nabers continues to insist his emotion comes from a desire to win and nothing more. Neither head coach John Harbaugh nor any of his teammates have complained about Nabers' fiery personality.
This article originally appeared on Giants Wire: Steve Smith calls Giants' Malik Nabers 'entitled' with 'shallow file' in NFL













