New York Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy produced the best statistical game of his young NFL career on Thursday night, completing 23 of 36 passes for 293 yards with a touchdown and an interception during a Week 10 loss to the Washington Commanders.
The outing led former NFL scout John Middlekauff to revisit the circumstances of McCarthy’s September trade from Minnesota.
On his 3 and Out podcast, Middlekauff contended that Vikings head coach Kevin O'Connell disliked the quarterback and played a central role in moving him.
“If you’re a Vikings fan watching that game, you have to be asking yourself -- and I’m not trying to play Monday morning quarterback -- it’s just a reality. The move was made because he didn’t play well and the coach hated him,"
Middlekauff said. "And if I wanted to speak for you in regard to J.J. McCarthy, you hated his guts as a player. You couldn’t [expletive] stand him."
Middlekauff described the coach as the driving force behind demoting McCarthy to third string and supporting the trade, paraphrasing the internal view as “We gotta get this guy out of here. Fifth-round pick, I’ll drive him to the airport.”
He noted that coach-quarterback friction of this kind has occurred before and will again.
Middlekauff then contrasted McCarthy’s recent work for the Giants under Matt Nagy and Greg Roman with the Vikings’ quarterback situation afterward, observing that New York’s version has looked better than what Minnesota fielded.
Selected 10th overall in 2024, McCarthy missed his entire rookie season with a torn meniscus. As a starter in 2025, he threw for 1,632 yards with 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions while going 6-4 before losing his starting job and sliding down the depth chart. With the Giants, he has 915 passing yards on 63.5 percent completion with two touchdowns and two interceptions.
The comments raise fresh questions about O’Connell’s handling of the former first-round pick as McCarthy continues to show signs of progress elsewhere.
This article originally appeared on Giants Wire: Ex-scout: Kevin O'Connell 'hated' J.J. McCarthy and pushed Giants trade













