Sunday's defeat at the hand of the 49ers showed the football world what, deep down, they already knew. The Cowboys are able to hang with any team in the league... but only for a while. They are capable of beating bad teams (though not always convincingly), except they just as often come up short in embarrassing fashion. And against the good teams, it's just a matter of time before they step on a rake.
The power rankings heading into Week 11 seem to finally have everyone settled on this obvious truth. The 46-40 loss didn't even drop Dallas in the eyes of some experts, as the end result was completely expected. Some rankings dropped the Cowboys a slot or two, and a few bumped the Cowboys up slightly, just for the reminder that their offense can
hang 40 on occasion... but this is nothing more than the inconsequential shuffling of the cards that reside in the bottom half of the deck.
Dallas has a real chance to win their next two outings and crawl back to the .500 mark, but a gauntlet of actual postseason contenders awaits in December. And at this point, everyone seems to have a good idea of how that will play out.
The team has already shown us.
Here's what the major outlets had to say about the Cowboys after 10 games, and where they rank heading into Week 11.
ESPN: No. 20, --
[On Quinnen Williams being the non-QB midseason MVP]: "Considering the porous nature of the Cowboys' defense, it's difficult to say a player on that unit deserves this honor, but that's how well Williams has played. He leads the team with six sacks, the most for a Dallas defensive tackle in a season since 2017, and is second in QB pressures. Williams leads the NFL with 15 tackles for loss and is tied for fifth with three forced fumbles. He is doing everything he can to raise the level of play on defense. He just needs more help."
NFL.com: No. 18, ▲4
"We knew the Cowboys’ defense couldn’t stop a nosebleed. We knew their offensive firepower represented their only chance of success. Dallas seemingly acknowledged this reality, too, with Sunday’s performance against San Francisco. This offense remains good enough (in most weeks) to keep the 'Boys in the playoff hunt, but the defense won’t ever give them a real chance of winning anything significant without some changes. It just is what it is."
The Athletic: No. 19, ▼2
[On Ryan Flournoy being the team's breakout player]: "The third-year wide receiver, a sixth-round pick in 2024, has found a role even with CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens getting most of the targets. Flournoy had six catches for 71 yards and a touchdown Sunday and is on the doorstep of a career year with seven games left. He has 38 receptions for 466 yards this season."
CBS Sports: No. 18, --
"That defense is putrid right now. They bust coverages and the effort lacks at times. They just can't stop anybody."
USA Today: No. 22, ▼1
"Christian McCaffrey > Christian Parker. But Dallas' defensive breakdowns obviously go way beyond Sunday, when the Cowboys surrendered three TDs of at least 66 yards. Dallas has allowed at least one from 55 yards in each of its past three games."
SI.com: No. 26, ▲1
"Brian Schottenheimer wouldn’t commit to the status quo at defensive coordinator and, while I feel like it’s a pile-on festival with Christian Parker at this point, I’m not sure that he can last much longer without a major riot on behalf of the fan base at this point."
ProFootballTalk: No. 24, ▼1
"The defense has gotten worse, not better."
Yahoo Sports: No. 22, ▼2
"There's not much more that can be said about the Cowboys' defense. Even noted Cowboys fan Post Malone was absolutely fed up. After allowing 584 yards in a 46-40 loss to the 49ers, Brian Schottenheimer made perhaps his harshest comments on the team since becoming head coach. 'I thought the second half was unacceptable,' Schottenheimer said, according to the team's site. 'Tackling was atrocious. We're going to do a deep dive and see why.' It's not like the Cowboys' offense has been the 1999 Rams or anything: fifth in points scored, eighth in yards gained, fifth in EPA per play and sixth in DVOA. That still should be enough to win a poor division. The defense is ruining the Cowboys' season, though DVOA still gives Dallas a 32.4% chance to win the NFC East."
Bleacher Report: No. 19, ▲1
"The story remains the same for the Dallas Cowboys. The offense can consistently move the ball and score points, but the defense remains a constant source of disappointment. The San Francisco 49ers offense amassed a staggering 584 yards during Sunday's meeting. It's the most the team has accumulated during the Kyle Shanahan era, according to NBC Sports Bay Area's Matt Maiocco. The output was the most Dallas ever surrendered during a home game. Once again, the Cowboys rank last in total defense. As The Ringer's Sheil Kapadia noted, the unit is also dead last in EPA per drive for the second straight season. Sadly, the Dallas offense is fun to watch but continues to be wasted, because the Cowboys somehow can't find a way to even slow an opponent."
Todd is on X at @ToddBrock24f7. Also, follow Cowboys Wire on Facebook to join in on the conversation with fellow fans!
This article originally appeared on Cowboys Wire: Power Rankings Roundup: Cowboys' deserved place near bottom 'is what it is' in Week 11













