Sometimes the numbers tell a different story than the game itself. This is not one of those times.
The Cowboys
played poorly in their season opener, massively underwhelming on both offense and defense after an offseason that had even the haters warning of a Dallas resurgence. Instead, it was John Harbaugh's Giants who impressed in the 28-20 win that was never really as close as the final score might suggest.The defense is catching most of the flak, and deservedly so. But the offense was just as uninspiring, leaving very little for fans to feel good about.
An examination of the official game stats shows just how not-ready-for-primetime the Cowboys were in several key areas, on both sides of the ball. Was it merely Week 1 rust for a group of starters
who largely sat out the preseason? Or are some of these figures the beginning of a trend and cause for lasting concern?
Unfortunately, we may not know until Week 2's home date against Washington. Until then, Cowboys Nation can do little more than rehash the myriad things that went wrong in the Meadowlands and provided a sad and sluggish start to what was supposed to be a return-to-glory season.
Here's a look, by the numbers, at a few of the stats that help tell the story.
3.4: Yards-per-carry average for Javonte Williams
Brian Schottenheimer admitted the Cowboys couldn't establish the run. The stats back that up, with Javonte Williams averaging a meager 3.4 yards per rush on the night. That's his lowest clip since Week 8 of last season and almost a full yard and a half under his 2025 season average (4.8). But the fact is, Dallas gave up on the ground game early. Williams had just 12 carries the entire game; only three of them came after halftime.
8:27: Cowboys' total time of possession in second half
Over the summer, the Cowboys announced their lofty intentions to be "Greatest Offense There Is." But by halftime of Week 1, just getting themselves back onto the field seemed unattainable. The Giants went keep-away mode in the second half, chewing up 8:01 and 8:11 on touchdown drives of 12 and 13 plays respectively and then closing out the game by taking the ball at 5:21 and running out the clock. Dak Prescott & Co. showed the ability to move downfield and reach the end zone on their only two second-half possessions, but the defense was utterly incapable of getting the ball back to give them enough chances.
20: Total number of game appearances by DeMarvion Overshown
Overshown is a fantastic story and an absolute missile when he's on the field. And therein lies the problem. When the fourth-year linebacker limped off Sunday grabbing at his hamstring, Cowboys fans everywhere had a collective case of here-we-go-again-itis. Word out of The Star is that Overshown may only miss a game or two with his latest lower-body issue, but he's already been sidelined for 32 of the 52 games the Cowboys have played since he was drafted. Now the team has to go to Plan B with the green-dot duties. At some point, Overshown's durability has to become a real conversation point.
81.8%: 3rd-down conversion attempts allowed by defense
Actually, this number gets worse the deeper you dive. Consider that the game's final kneeldown by Jaxson Dart came on third down; that's technically a failed conversion, even though the Cowboys sure don't deserve credit for a stop. So the Giants moved the chains on nine out of 10 third downs where they ran a real play: a 90% conversion rate. Of those 10, New York sat at 3rd-and-10 once and 3rd-and-9 on three occasions... and converted every single time. The other half-dozen third-down tries came with an average of just 2.5 yards to go... which means the Cowboys' first- and second-down defense was equally porous. And on Big Blue's first possession of the third quarter, their longest drive of the night in yards gained (74), the Cowboys never even forced a third down during the Giants' 12-play, eight-minute march to a touchdown.
134.2: Jaxson Dart's career-high passer rating allowed
The 23-year-old Giants quarterback had a strong showing on Sunday night, posting just his second-ever three-touchdown game as a pro and completing a personal-best 79.3% of his throws. Yes, his 15th overall game appearance makes for a small sample size, but after all the offseason buzz about Christian Parker's overhaul of the Dallas defense and the personnel upgrades made in the secondary, Dart setting a new career high with a 134.2 passer rating- shattering his previous high-water mark of 110.2- was not on anybody's bingo card.
175: Total passing yards from Dak Prescott
Obviously, New York severely limited the Cowboys' offensive opportunities, especially in the second half. But Prescott threw for just 175 yards, one of the 20 lowest game totals of his career, and that came on a perfectly-reasonable 34 attempts. He threw for less in the 2025 season-finale versus the Giants, but Joe Milton played much of that contest. He finished with just 133 against Atlanta in 2024, but that's the day he injured his hamstring and exited early. To find an instance where Prescott played the whole game but threw for under 175, you have to go back to the late-December 2023 no-show in Buffalo. Near-constant pressure in the pocket and a few egregious drops from his receivers sure didn't help his numbers, but for an early supposed MVP contender, Prescott was bottled up big-time by Big Blue. His 5.1 yards per attempt bordered on a bottom-10 career performance.
Todd is on X at @ToddBrock24f7. Also, follow Cowboys Wire on Facebook to join in on the conversation with fellow fans!
This article originally appeared on Cowboys Wire: By the Numbers: Dak Prescott, Javonte Williams also come up short in Cowboys' Week 1 loss
