Texas A&M's 22-7 home loss dropped the Aggies to 4-6 and 1-6 in SEC play, thanks to another horrific offensive performance: senior quarterback Marcel Reed threw for 71 yards and an interception on 179 total yards, including just 86 on the ground.
Defensively, the Aggies held star Tennessee running back DeSean Bishop to just 97 yards and zero touchdowns, while allowing 114 passing yards. Again, Texas A&M's defense isn't the problem, and it gave the offense plenty of chances to respond in the second half.
Marcel Reed's tenth start was by far his worst, but third-year coach Mike Elko continued to defend his senior quarterback, stating that the "inept" offense was a product of poor play-calling and game script, without directly calling out Holmon
Wiggins, while star freshman running back KJ Edwards' one second-half carry was equally confusing.
With just minutes left in the fourth quarter, backup quarterback Brady Hart came in and immediately completed two passes before throwing an interception, likely because the targeted receiver ran the wrong route.
Hart's limited playing time amid Marcel Reed's struggles may or may not be due to his lack of development, especially under Holmon Wiggins and QB coach Joey Lynch. However, Mike Elko said after the game that Marcel Reed's ability as a runner, despite not calling any designed runs, is the primary reason Hart didn't come in earlier.
"I think it's not about Brady. When things are breaking down the way they were, the plus one ability Marcel gives you is the only thing that keeps them off us. That's what I see."
Even with Marcel Reed's advantage as a runner, Texas A&M's offense hasn't benefited much from designed runs, and while Brady Hart might be developed enough to start now, what's the harm in giving him a shot over the last two games?
Hart is obviously the more natural passer, and Mike Elko's messaging is as bad as it gets for a quarterback who may easily enter the transfer portal if he doesn't feel the coaching staff believes he can take the reins.
Even after passing for 71 yards, I expect Marcel Reed to start against Oklahoma on Saturday, which doesn't make much sense, but that's where we're at.
Contact/Follow us @AggiesWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Texas A&M news, notes and opinions. Follow Cameron on X: @CameronOhnysty.
This article originally appeared on Aggies Wire: Is Texas A&M's backup QB getting a fair shake?













