We knew it was going to be ugly, but did the New Orleans Saints have to make it so frustrating? They had a chance to upset the Chicago Bears on Sunday, but all of their critical flaws came home to roost. Head coach Kellen Moore's indecision cost the team most of their timeouts in the second half and did little to cut into the scoring deficit. His incoherent play calling failed to put points on the board. And yet the defense fought hard enough and enough stops to keep the team in it. They just lacked the ability to seize on those opportunities offensively. The final tally, 21-16, says it all.
So let's break it down by answering several key questions:
- What went right?
- What went wrong?
- What's the bottom line?
- What comes next?
What went right?
The defense actually did their job this week, holding one of the league's best offenses to just
16 points off of 11 drives. They sacked Caleb Williams twice and came away with two turnovers while only allowed five third-down conversions on a dozen tries (plus a stop on fourth down). The Bears did rush for 146 yards but Chicago only won the time of possession battle by less than a minute. Brandon Staley's unit did enough to win this week.
Offensively, there wasn't much to write home about, but we finally saw why the Saints signed Travis Etienne Jr. in free agency. Etienne's 46-yard sprint was the longest rush by a New Orleans running back in five or six years. They just need to stop taking the ball out of his hands to give rookies with fumbling problems opportunities instead. Chris Olave surged back to the top of the receiving corps with nine catches for 102 yards.
What went wrong?
The pass protection was ugly, again, but Shough didn't do himself any favors. He was bailing out of clean pockets and missing open receivers because he was rushing himself through his reads all afternoon. He looks like a second-year quarterback who didn't start enough games in college and has been broken down by a bad situation. Weeks of no help from his coaches, run game, or offensive line put too much pressure on his shoulders, and he crumbled. He was sacked six times and threw another interception. He's continuing to regress.
The special teams were a mess. Each of Ryan Wright's three punts fell into the end zone for touchbacks, giving up critical field position and sometimes resulting in net changes of as little as 21 yards. The Saints drafted Lorenzo Styles Jr. for his skills and experience on special teams but he was penalized early for jumping offsides against a field goal try. They couldn't recover the onside kick later, either.
What's the bottom line?
This team stinks. Moore is obviously out of his depth and has no sense for when to go for it on fourth down and when to take the points (as far as that goes, he can't find a kicker he can trust, either). Nothing is easy offensively and his poor coaching has destroyed Shough's confidence. There are so many mistakes being made in each phase that the Saints ran out of timeouts with about seven minutes left in regulation while trailing by two touchdowns.
Despite all of that, the Saints had a chance to upset the Bears. With better execution in the red zone and more competence on the headset and at quarterback, they could have come away with the surprise win of the season. Instead they're stuck at 3-7, right where they belong.
What comes next?
This was just the first leg of a two-week road trip against cold-weather teams angling for a Super Bowl run. The Saints will travel to face the Cincinnati Bengals next Sunday. If this is the best they can do, they'll return to New Orleans with another loss. They aren't coached well enough to win on critical downs or gain two yards when they need them. It's an awful place to find yourself in, but it's exactly what general manager Mickey Loomis has achieved in the five years since Sean Payton left the team.
This article originally appeared on Saints Wire: Instant analysis: What went right, what went wrong in Saints-Bears













