Sunday saw the New Orleans Saints drop their third of four games in the Superdome. This one was a 20-17 loss to NFC South foe Carolina Panthers on the last play. The Saints fell to 3-6 with the loss, as the Panthers took over sole possession of first place in the division. Thank god this division is utterly pathetic, as the Saints only drop to a second-place tie with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and ahead of the 3-7 Atlanta Falcons. It dropped the Saints to 0-2 in the division, but with four of their last eight games coming against NFC South opponents.
New Orleans was absolutely putrid in the first half, putting up zero points and just 106 total yards while committing two costly turnovers. They had some moderate success in the second half, but quarterback
Tyler Shough was again the victim of bad play-calling, even worse blocking, and some of his own poor decisions. Defensively, the Saints played a strong game but again killed themselves with awful tackling efforts and costly breakdowns late in the game. Here's the good, bad, and ugly from a game extremely hard to watch.
The Good: Saints defense
Brandon Staley's unit kept the Saints in the game through the first few quarters. New Orleans held the Panthers to only 283 total yards, including a respectable 97 on the ground and just 3 yards per carry, while sacking Bryce Young three times. Young completed only 56% of his throws, as the Saints bottled up Tetairoa McMillan for just 3 catches and 35 yards.
It tells you all you need to know about this game that one of the very few ''goods'' was also responsible for some ''bads'' that were back-breaking. For the third time in four games, the Saints defense had costly breakdowns in the fourth quarter. After New Orleans took a 14-10 lead with less than four minutes to go, Panthers back Chuba Hubbard steamrolled through a suddenly helpless defense. Kaden Elliss, who otherwise had a good day, missed an easy tackle that resulted in a 28-yard gain. Two plays later, a lazy Justin Reid put out a feeble effort on a 33-yard Hubbard gain down to the goal line for an eventual touchdown and a 17-14 lead. After Shough positioned the Saints for a game-tying field goal, a ridiculous 30-yard pass interference by Kool-Aid McKinstry set Carolina up for the game-winning field goal. Such is the 2026 season for New Orleans; where even a good outing by what's been an abysmal defense turned into one of the major contributing causes for a loss.
The Good: Jordyn Tyson
Tyson caught 11 passes for 80 yards to lead both teams in receiving. On a day when Chris Olave, Devaughn Vele, and Juwan Johnson were all contained with a combined 7 catches and 72 yards, Tyson came through in a big way. Many felt that the 2026 eighth overall selection would be on a somewhat limited snap count in only his second game back from a hamstring injury. Instead, Tyson became the primary source of the offense's production.
New Orleans got their rookie involved heavily, showing remarkable chemistry with Shough. Tyson was targeted 13 times, making several acrobatic grabs on intermediate routes and impressive agility after short throws. The Saints clearly don't have much, but Tyson's addition to a crew that includes Olave, Vele, and Johnson should be fun to watch down the stretch.
The Bad: Offensive Line/Running Game
Going up against a Carolina defense that ranked a lowly 28th against the run, the Saints rushed the ball for 49 yards and 2.1 per carry. No, that's not a typo. Tyler Shough was again the team's leading rusher with 25 yards, as New Orleans running backs carried the ball 17 times for 24 yards, a pathetic average of 1.4 per run.
Shough was sacked three times and too often hurried by a Panthers defense that had only 11 sacks in their first eight games. Countless times this season, the Saints were bullied in the trenches and unable to accomplish the simplest of tasks. That trend continued against Carolina, as we're watching Shough's decisions start to get affected by the enormous punishment he's taking.
The Ugly: Kellen Moore
Concerns surrounding the Saints offensive line were plenty coming into this game. Center Erik McCoy (biceps) and right tackle Taliese Fuaga (knee) were out, with Cesar Ruiz sliding from guard to center and Asim Richards stepping in for Fuaga before his putrid play caused a move to rookie Mason Murphy. Despite this, Moore's game plan design did seemingly nothing to account for these shortcomings.
New Orleans had a strong tandem of tackle Kelvin Banks Jr. and guard David Edwards on the left side. It's where the Saints had the majority of their rushing success last week against Cleveland. Given that and the issues on the right side, PLEASE explain why in the world the Saints ran the ball exactly ONE time to the left??
When New Orleans was driving for a game-tying field goal, Moore's play-calling and the offensive execution got extremely conservative. As a result, Charlie Smyth faced a 55-yard attempt. It was a ridiculous gamble for a team who had missed five of eight field goal tries from beyond 50 yards. Smyth converted the kick. However, a more aggressive approach might have bled more time off the clock or even resulted in a touchdown that would have all but put the game out of reach.
The New Orleans Saints have a ton of problems everywhere. At the very top of the list is Kellen Moore, defensive coordinator Brandon Staley, and the entire coaching staff. The Saints are unlikely to make a coaching change during the year, as much as it is deserved, but Moore and his staff's fates are all but sealed.
This article originally appeared on Saints Wire: Recapping the good, bad, and ugly from Saints' loss to Panthers













