The Phillies signing of Adolis Garcia this offseason was met with at best a shrug and at worst rightful comparisons to former one year deal outfielders past. Garcia hadn’t been an average or above hitter since 2023 and was non-tendered by the Rangers after a 2025 campaign that saw him hit .227 with a .665 OPS. But the Phillies and Dave Dombrowski elected to sign Garcia to be their starting right fielder, believing that he could rebound into being a productive right fielder at best and a defensive
upgrade over Nick Castellanos at worst.
So far in 2026, that bet is looking good. Garcia is 7-22 (.318) with a home run and one walk to five strikeouts. The metrics also back up the eye test, with a 96.8 MPH average exit velocity, .314 xBA, and .460 xSLG all suggesting that Garcia is putting good swings on the ball. He’s routinely hit the ball hard, but some of them have been line drives right into gloves. One of the biggest things the Phillies worked on with Garcia this offseason was a change in his batting stance. That led to Garcia being late on some balls this spring, but it seems he is starting to get his timing down in the season’s early going.
The other thing the Phillies worked on with Garcia was plate discipline. He has always been a free swinger, but the Phillies wanted him to cut down on his contact on pitches outside the zone, as he made contact on 58% of the pitches he saw outside the strike zone in 2025. Entering Wednesday’s game, Garcia’s outside the zone contact was down to 46.2% while his contact rate on pitches in the zone was 84.6%. He was still swinging and chasing at his normal levels, but he was also making contact on better pitches to hit at a higher rate.
Garcia hasn’t exactly stood out in a major positive way on defense yet however, as he misplayed a fly ball on Sunday and had an errant throw skip into the dugout on Tuesday. But he did have an impressive sliding grab on Saturday that likely saved at least one run from scoring.
Of course, this is all in a ludicrously small sample size. After all, some of these things could have been said about Max Kepler at this point last season. This could just be an early hot streak for Garcia rather than a harbinger of a good season. So, what are your first impressions of Adolis Garcia?
