Cameron Fens yesterday filed a lawsuit against the NCAA in Orange County, NC Superior Court. The suit alleges that the NCAA has failed Fens on two fronts. First, Fens claims he should be eligible for a fifth year due a misdiagnosis of foot injury suffered at South Dakota that would have resulted in a successful red shirt year if diagnosed correctly. In turn, that red shirt would make Fens eligible to play this season under the old NCAA rules, “five years to play four.” Second, Fens argues that he’s
also eligible under the plain text of the new “five for five” rules passed by the NCAA earlier this year.
Today’s hearing in front of Judge Alyson Grine sought a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO), a legal mechanism now familiar to most college sports fans. A TRO grants one party in a lawsuit temporary relief while a legal argument proceeds in court. The basic idea is that a party suffering harm while the lawsuit unfolds cannot recover that harm even if he or she wins their case. In other words, Fens’ lawyers today argued that Fens’ suit has enough merit to be successful but that missing games now irreparably harms him. Those games can’t be given back if he wins his suit in a few months.
It should be noted that the misdiagnosis on the foot has been appealed to the NCAA and still awaits resolution. The NCAA has promised an answer on that appeal by tomorrow. If the NCAA grants that appeal, Fens becomes eligible under the old “four to play five” rules, and the lawsuit becomes no longer necessary. The case filing seems to suggest Fens, his lawyers, and UNC do not feel that the NCAA has necessarily been approaching the appeal in good faith to this point.
The TRO now enters an appeal process. The appeals court could find Judge Grine ruled in error and remove the TRO, which would leave Fens again ineligible. This is what happened in Fens’ original case in Tennessee, where a superior court judge ruled in favor of a number of players, only for the Tennessee appellate court to overrule. Fens has requested to be removed from that case, and the Tennessee court granted that request. This lawsuit in Orange County court appears to be Fens’ final effort to gain eligibility for the 2026 season.
Fens, a 7’0”, 255 pound center, fills a need in the UNC front court. He played two years at Illinois-Chicago and then the last two years at South Dakota. He averaging 14.4 points and 8.7 rebounds last season for the Coyotes. Michael Malone in an affidavit to the court testified that Fens would play immediately if granted a TRO.













