I remember vividly where I was when Indiana men’s basketball last faced John Calipari: spring break in the Florida Keys, freshly 21-years old and scaring my family with how many beers I drank in the first ten minutes of the game just trying to calm my nerves.
Besides the natural tension that comes from historically successful teams from bordering states, the Calipari era of the Indiana/Kentucky rivalry came with a contrast in cultures between the programs that served as microcosms of their broader
histories. While Calipari was stacking some of the best recruiting classes on a yearly basis, Indiana’s 2016-17 teams were powered by breakout stars like OG Anunoby, a 3-star recruit who only showed flashes of the two-time NBA champion he’d become.
Calipari was at Kentucky, a place that was always rumored to have under-the-table deals going on in recruiting. He brought some of that rep with him, with NCAA violations at his previous coaching stops, but he was far from the worst case running around back then. His once and future SEC contemporary Will Wade lost his job for getting caught attempting to arrange payment for a recruit. Within the state, Rick Pitino seemed to be caught in a new recruiting violation investigation every week.
In that context, Calipari was far from the sport’s biggest sinner, but he sure wasn’t the (maybe naive) saintly figure that Crean was. When Indiana beat him during that era, it felt like a win for a style of program management.
In 2026, that recruiting philosophy is beyond dead. Pitino and Wade are back at the top of high major programs, openly paying recruits for their services. Calipari is at Arkansas. Crean is a TV analyst.
Maybe the most surprising thing to come of the changes to the sport is the way Calipari has emerged as a somewhat sympathetic figure, the casualty of perhaps unreasonable standards in an age when most fans of college athletics believe that the next Curt Cignetti is out there waiting to be discovered by a savvy AD.
In an era when everyone else is rushing for the portal to grab all the talent they can, even for just a year, Calipari’s running his programs just like he always has. Talented freshmen, particularly in the backcourt, lead the way for Cal as they always have.
Back to standards, Indiana fans are well aware of how harmful they can be. Moving on from Crean may have been the right move given the direction the sport was going in when he was fired, but Indiana simply has not come close to that level of success since his firing.
Catching Cal at this stage of his career is a brutal reminder of how fleeting success really is in this sport. Not many programs will experience sustained success like Kentucky did during his tenure there or like Indiana did under Bob Knight.
In the NIL and portal era, UConn and Danny Hurley appear to be the only ones who really know the formula to consistent greatness. This is precisely why UConn fans have to sweat it out every time a marquee NBA job opens up and why Michigan had to replace wunderkind Dusty May a few months after a national championship.
Three years out, it’s not even clear that Kentucky won the Calipari split its fans so desperately craved. Mark Pope looked like a home run hire in year one, but has hit some rockier waters in subsequent seasons and may have more to prove than Darian DeVries when the two meet this coming Friday.
Meanwhile, Calipari took Arkansas to the Sweet 16 in years one and two and continues to win recruitments like Darius Acuff’s or Miika Muurinen’s, landing the kind of player that can carry you to March Madness run on their own.
You, an Indiana fan might not like Calipari for his past, but his ability to win at every stop at the highest level is a testament to the coach he is. There are bad years in there for his detractors to point to, but few coaches can get multiple programs on deep tournament runs the way Calipari jas
Even if Arkansas vs Indiana lacks some bite on paper, playing a coach like Cal in Madison Square Garden will always be an occasion worthy of hype and celebration in college basketball, no matter what year it is. Chances like this only come around every so often.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- Improved notifications system!
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
Download the SB Nation app on iOS or Android.













