We don’t know exactly when, but Anthony Volpe is nearing a return to the Yankees. Once the team ends his rehab assignment and brings him back to the big leagues, the expectation is that Volpe will resume his duties as the starting shortstop or, at the very least, play the majority of games there going forward. That means José Caballero, who has filled in for the former first-round pick as he recovered from his offseason shoulder surgery, will be pushed off shortstop.
The Yankees trusted Caballero
to handle shortstop duties in Volpe’s absence, and the talented, speedy infielder managed to overcome a slow start to become everything the organization wanted him to be while the starter was gone.
Before taking the field on Monday, Caballero was slashing a solid .271/.314/.417 with a 104 wRC+, three home runs, 11 stolen bases, and 0.7 fWAR, third on the Yankees among position players. That fWAR output is higher than that of established stars such as Jazz Chisholm Jr., Trent Grisham, and Giancarlo Stanton.
It’s important to point out, however, that things weren’t always going this smoothly for Caballero in the still-young 2026 campaign. From the start of the season until April 14, he was actually hitting a disappointing .179/.220/.286 with a 39 wRC+ and a 28.8 percent strikeout rate in 59 plate appearances. Some criticized the Yankees for not having a better plan to replace Volpe.
Patience proved to be a virtue. The Yanks didn’t have much of a choice, but they stuck with Caballero and were rewarded. In 43 trips to the plate from April 15 until Sunday, the utilityman slashed .400/.442/.600 with two doubles, two home runs, five stolen bases, and a 192 wRC+. His strikeout rate over that span is at a solid 16.3 percent.
Defensively, Caballero has also been an asset. In 238.2 innings at shortstop before Monday’s game, he racked up five Defensive Runs Saved, or DRS. He is also tied for the American League lead in steals with Cleveland’s Jose Ramirez, through Sunday’s games. In other words, Caballero has been a net positive in all three facets of the game for position players: hitting, fielding, and baserunning.
Now that his playing time at shortstop will be cut due to Volpe’s presence later this week, the Yankees will have to find creative ways to keep one of their hottest players in the lineup. In the last two years alone, Caballero has played second base, third base, shortstop, and the three outfield positions. He could potentially find playing time at all those spots, but things could get crowded for him once Volpe returns.
The main takeaway for Caballero and the Yankees is that he rose to the occasion when the team needed him. He had a month to impress and managed to achieve his goal, even if the road wasn’t always smooth. Perhaps he isn’t the most willing walker, and he sure can be streaky, but Caballero has been a very solid addition to the Yankees ever since he came before last year’s deadline. The team asked for league-average offense, strong defense, and bold baserunning from the shortstop position during Volpe’s absence, and it ended up getting all three. Acquired at last year’s deadline and under team control through 2029, Caballero looks like he should be a more than fine super utilityman for years to come.
If everybody’s healthy, Caballero is probably not an everyday player. Still, manager Aaron Boone knows he has a capable Swiss Army knife ready to cover almost any position on the field capably. It may not always be pretty, but Caballero usually finds ways to contribute, and he managed to produce in all facets of the game these last few weeks.
