On Wednesday, Pittsburgh Penguins general manager/president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas pointed out the biggest problem with the 2026-27 season is the team’s lack of consistency. He specifically talked about how they show flashes of strong play for brief moments, can not sustain it, and then keep losing games as a result.
The team responded on Thursday night against the St. Louis Blues by demonstrating exactly what he was talking about in a 5-2 loss. After a first period that was one of their
best of the season, they followed it up by playing a rather lifeless 40 minutes to close out the game, getting outscored 5-1 during that time.
This is important because Dubas also pointed out that if the season continues on that same trajectory, some changes are going to have to be made. That means trades. Along with that, the returns are likely to be more long-term and futures based.
It is not surprising, and it is the next step and likely escalation of a rebuild that has already been underway for a couple of years now.
The Penguinsreportedly tried to get a start on that earlier this month with a rumored trade involving Rickard Rakell and the Chicago Blackhawks. According to Elliotte Friedman, the apparent return was going to be one of Chicago’s first-round picks in 2027 (belonging to Florida or Edmonton), veteran forward Teuvo Teravainen and an AHL prospect. Quite honestly, that is more than I would have expected for Rakell, and it is likely a sign of Chicago’s desperation more than anything else.
Rakell, however, utilized his no-trade protections and nixed it (as is his right to do).
So now that all of that is out there, and this seems to be the path we are headed down, let’s look at the Penguins best trade assets and rank them. This is not a ranking of who is most likely to be traded. It is a look at which players would bring the most value back in return if they were to be traded.
The unthinkable trade option
1. Sidney Crosby. I don’t think Sidney Crosby is going to get traded. It is ultimately going to be his decision on if he goes and where he goes, and even though his agent put out a really vague statement on Thursday, I just can’t see it going down this path.
Or more accurately, I don’t see it going down this path.
I think it’s more likely that Crosby simply retires after this season.
He’s not playing the way he expects or wants to play, and he doesn’t strike me as the type of player that is going to want to hang on if he can’t reach the level he expects of himself. He also doesn’t strike me as the type of player that wants a season long farewell tour and the attention that comes with it. When he retires, he’s just going to do it (I think).
He also doesn’t need to follow the Ray Bourque path and latch on to a contender so he can finally win something. He’s already won. A lot. He doesn’t have to prove anything to anybody, answer to anybody, or complete a Hall of Fame resume.
Having said that …
If I am wrong about all of that, and if he by some chance he went to the Penguins and said, “I’d like to play in Montreal, or play alongside my buddy in Colorado,” I don’t think Dubas would hesitate to make it happen.
Not only out of respect to Crosby, but also because he just seems like he’s ready to turn the page on this era.
Even though Crosby is 39 and not having a particularly good season, he’s still Sidney Crosby, and he would still warrant some kind of a significant return. Probably better than any other realistic trade option on the team. For that reason, he goes at the top of the list, even if I don’t think it actually goes in that direction.
The more likely trade options with the best value
2. Erik Karlsson. I don’t like the season Karlsson is having, and even though the point total is still fine, his drop in play is one of the biggest factors in the Penguins’ regression from a year ago. He was their MVP and best player during the 2025-26 season, and one of the reasons for their surprising success. He channeled his Norris Trophy/Hall of Fame level and played like the player the Penguins always expected him to be. It was just about points or scoring, either. It was about dictating the pace of the game, having everything run through him, and just being a difference-maker in all three zones.
It is simply not there this season, for whatever reason.
Having said that, he’s still going to have some value to a contender. He plays a premium position, he can still generate offense, and there’s no term on his contract beyond this season, so any team trading for him isn’t going to have to be overly concerned about his long-term outlook. He would be a hired gun at this point, and probably a good one in the right situation.
I’d expect a first-round pick and a mid-level prospect.
3. Tommy Novak. I’m going to put Novak high on this list because I think there’s a lot of value with him. Not franchise-changing trade value. But definitely good value. For one, he’s just a good player, and he’s having a really good season. He also has an extremely cheap contract and has the positional flexibility to play on the wing or at center. He can play in the top-six. He can play on the third line. He can play on the power play. He can carry the puck. He can make plays. He can do a lot. I think a lot of teams would like him and what he does, and they could probably get a surprisingly strong return for him if they moved him.
I also get the sense the Penguins like him. A lot.
They might not LOOK to move him, but I’d be willing to bet people would call, and I’m not sure they would hang up the phone. He also has no trade protections in his contract, which would remove any complications.
4. Evgeni Malkin. Everything I wrote up above regarding Crosby applies here the exact same way. I don’t think he’s going to ask out. Even though his trade protections are small, I don’t think the Penguins are going to aggressively look to move him unless he does ask out. I do think there would be some sort of a market for him given the offense he can still produce. I just don’t know how much value.
Patrick Kane and Brad Marchand were two veteran wingers traded at the ends of their contracts. Both essentially went for a conditional second round pick that would be upgraded to a first rounder based on acquiring team playoff results (which worked in Marchand’s case but did not in Kane’s). That would seem about a ballpark for a potential Malkin trade in 2026, if all the other factors came together.
5. Rickard Rakell. I am still skeptical of the market for him, even with the report of Chicago trying to get him. I think that speaks more to the desperation of the Blackhawks than anything else. As I wrote over the summer, mid-30s wingers with term remaining on their contract are not always attractive trade targets. But that could change as the season moves along and contenders start to get a better idea of what they need and who is actually available. It could also start to change if Rakell keeps scoring more and playing the way he has over the past couple of weeks. As we saw recently, he does have some say over where he goes.
My expectations on the return are low
6. Bryan Rust. I like the idea of Bryan Rust on a contender, and I like the idea of a contender wanting a player like Rust. He is as solid as they come, can play up and down the lineup, is not really out of place in any situation, and has a knack for playing his best in the biggest moments. General managers love players like that. He is also one of the few veteran players on the roster that is currently without any trade restrictions on his contract.
The problem: He’s 34 years old with a year remaining on his deal (the whole mid-30s winger with term thing) and is going to miss 10-20 games every year, or be playing through something. He just is. You can’t ignore that reality. And I think all of that would be reflected in what any potential return looks like.
7. Blake Lizotte. Depth centers that can kill penalties and are signed to cheap contracts can have more value than you might expect, but I still don’t think it would be be anything more than a few lottery tickets. I could easily see a second-rounder, though.
8. Sam Girard. I don’t think he’s a bad player by any means, and as a pending unrestricted free agent he is almost certain to be on the trade block. I just don’t think he’s bringing back anything significant. Maybe a second-round pick.
9. Justin Brazeau. Fine depth player. Cheap contract. Big guy with some skill. General managers, again, love that sort of thing. Maybe a couple of mid-round picks.
10. Trevor van Riemsdyk. He would need to play more and show he can still be a solid defender, but he has enough of a track record that there might be some market for him by the trade deadline.
I don’t see the trade value
11. Andrei Kuzmenko. This is just an unfortunate situation with the way it has played out. I understand what the Penguins were trying to do. Take on a cheap, one-year reclamation project and see if you can get some production out of it to flip it at the deadline, or get a surprisingly good year for another potential playoff run. Anthony Beauvillier. Anthony Mantha. Same idea. I don’t blame anybody for the way it’s worked out because sometimes life just sucks. I just don’t think there’s a trade market.
12. Kris Letang. I actually don’t think he’s been all that bad this season. He is clearly not prime Kris Letang, and there have been some tough moments, but he’s been fine. I just don’t see teams lining up to take the 39-year-old version of him with another year at $6.1 million against the cap remaining.
The rest of the roster
They are not trading Ben Kindel. They are not trading Sergei Murashov. There is no good reason to trade Egor Chinakhov at this point. Ville Koivunen and Rutger McGroarty are the type of players that are probably going to get more of a look as the season goes on, and especially if veteran plays get moved. Same thing applies to Elmer Soderblom. I’m going to be honest, I have no idea where to slot Connor Dewar in any of the above tiers. I don’t know that Arturs Silovs is going to have a big demand, and you still need somebody to play in net.













