The Jays picked up Spencer Miles in the Rule Five Draft last year. Heading into spring training, it looked like he and Angel Bastardo (a Rule Five pick-up from the year before, who missed the 2025 season after spring training) would battle for one spot (if the team wanted to use a roster spot on a pitcher with little pro pitching experience).
Miles was a fourth-round draft pick in 2022 by the Giants. He missed the 2023 season after back surgery and made just four appearances in 2024 because of a flexor
strain, which ended up with him getting Tommy John surgery. He pitched just 14.2 innings in the minors, with a 4.30 ERA, 5 walks and 22 strikeouts, which shows why the Giants figured he would make it through the draft.
Bastardo didn’t have a good spring training, giving up 7 walks in 7.2 spring innings, and the Jays returned him to the Red Sox (who ended up trading him to the Royals).
Spencer made it onto the Jays roster. How did he do?
| Age | WAR | W | L | ERA | G | GS | GF | SV | IP | H | R | ER | HR | BB | IBB | SO | HBP | BK | WP | FIP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | 2.4 | 6 | 2 | 2.73 | 49 | 8 | 9 | 2 | 95.2 | 80 | 31 | 29 | 5 | 25 | 1 | 93 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 2.65 |
Generated 11/19/2026.
I’d say amazingly well.
Baseball Reference has him at 2.4 WAR, and Fangraphs has him at 2.0, valuing him at $16.0 million to the Blue Jays.
Miles had a 2.65 FIP and 3.11 xFIP.
He had a .284 BABIP (team average .283). 75.8% of the base runners he allowed were stranded (team average 72.4).
Spencer’s line drive rate was 21.8% (team average 19.4). His ground ball rate was 51.1% (team 42.3). And the fly ball rate was 27.1% (team 38.2). 6.9% of his fly balls left the park (team 11.0).
His strikeout rate was 24.0% (team 23.1), while his walk rate was up 6.4% (team 9.7).
Spencers’ soft contact rate was 15.2% (team 17.2). Hard contact was 29.7% (team 32.3).
He was much better vs. RHB (.191/.260/.204) than LHB (.247/.286/.374).
Miles was slightly better at home (batters hit..210/.259/.300 with a 2.57 ERA) than on the road (.240/.294/.293 with a 2.72 ERA).
He was about the much the same in the first half (2.85, .211/.273/.283) as the second half (2.27, .241/.276/.321). He threw 60 innings in the first half and 35.2 in the second.
Spencer by month:
- April: 9 relief appearances, 1-0, 2.87. Batters hit .217/.277/.333 with 2 home runs, 5 walks and 15 strikeouts.
- May: 7 games, 2 starts, 1-1, 3.92. Batters hit .221/.286/.286 with 1 home run, 7 walks and 19 strikeouts.
- June: 7 relief appearances, 1-0, 1.84. Batters hit .154/.214/.212 with 1 home runs, 4 walks and 16 strikeouts..
- July: 7 games, 2 starts, 1-1, 3.79. Batters hit .274/.303/.356 with 1 home runs, 3 walks and 18 strikeouts.
- August: 12 games, 1 start, 1-0, 1.35. Batters hit .240/.278/.340 with 0 home runs, 2 walk and 9 strikeouts.
- September: 7 games, 3 starts, 1-0, 0.73. Batters hit .208/.269/.229 with 0 home run, 4 walks and 16 strikeouts.
The Jays were 4-4 in his starts, 27-22 in his appearances. They scored 3 or fewer runs in 3 of his 8 starts.
By catcher:
- Tyler Heineman: 10.2 innings: 1.69 ERA, batters hit .233/.283/.349.
- Alejandro Kirk: 35 innings: 2.83 ERA, batters hit .197/.277/.276.
- Brandon Valenzuela: 50 innings: 2.70 ERA, batters hit .237/.270/.300.
Miles was good with RISP, holding batters to a .178/.250/.267 line.
In high-leverage spots, batters hit .206/.282/.254. Low leverage .200/.251/.269.
Spencer averaged 2.75 innings per start, but he was more an opener in most of his starts.
As a starter he had a 5.73 ERA, batters hit .289/.326/.389 in 22 innings. In relief he had a 1.71 ERA, batters hit .200/.257/.267 in 73.2 innings.
Random Baseball Savant numbers:
- Fastball Run Value: 97th percentile.
- Breaking Ball Value: 69th percentile.
- Offspeed Run Value: 42nd percentile.
- Fastball Velocity: 78th percentile.
- Chase %: 16th percentile.
- Whiff %: 6th percentile.
- Strike %: 62nd percentile.
- Walk %: 85th percentile.
- Barrel %: 96th percentile.
- Groundball %: 87th percentile.
We have had some very good Rule Five picks over the years: George Bell, Willie Upshaw, Kelly Gruber, Jim Acker, Manny Lee and Joe Biagini, so Spencer has a long way to go until he’s ranked at the top of the list, but he’s off to a good start to his time with the Jays. Someone in the Jays scouting department deserves a raise…though since Miles didn’t pitch much in the minors before we picked him, I’m not sure how much scouting to do with picking him.
And he’s still just 26; he’s under team control for a long time; he’s not a free agent until 2032, at the earliest.
Next season (presuming there is a next season)? The team says they aren’t sure if he’ll be a starter or a reliever. I’m voting reliever, but I guess that depends on how well they load up on starters. Last year, it looked like they’d have a surplus of starters, but we still had bullpen games way too often for my liking.
And, of course, if he is a starting pitcher, that will be better for his future bank balance.
It will be interesting to watch his career. He didn’t get the usual amount of time to learn to pitch in the minors, so there was a certain amount of learning on the fly.













