A disappointing day for Northwestern basketball. One has to question what re-evaluations are needed for any program as Northwestern falls to Columbia 75-53, let alone a Big Ten team struggling just to get over the 50-point mark against an Ivy League program. For context, the last matchup between these teams came in the 2018-2019 season, when Northwestern defeated Columbia 75-54. Now, seemingly, the tables have turned.
As the crowd began to exit Welsh-Ryan, it felt unlike any other loss. Losing by
over 20 to a mid-major program is a new reality for ‘Cats fans. A reality that saw highly anticipated transfer Jack Karasinski shooting 3-for-14 from the floor. A reality where Northwestern’s star player, Jake West, shot just 4-for-12 and Ciaravino led the pack with 14 points.
For Columbia, leading scorer Gerard O’Keefe finished with 20 on 7-for-12 shooting. As a team, Columbia blocked five shots from Northwestern and outrebounded them 43-29.
After another lost tip for the Wildcats, Mason Ritter laid in an easy two-pointer to start the game for the Lions, but Jack Karasinski quickly answered with a two that kept the score tied for quite some time. After both scoring on their first trip, the score remained level until the 16-minute mark, when LA Pratt gave the ‘Cats a 4-2 lead with a layup under a collapsing Columbia defense.
Karasinski, coming off a low-scoring game against DePaul, started off just 1-for-4 from the field in the first five minutes. The Lions also locked down Jake West, who had no shot attempts in the first six minutes. His first attempt came on a blocked layup during a drive to the basket.
The Lions tied the game on free throws and, after an empty Northwestern possession, the Wildcats gave up three straight offensive rebounds, and Columbia went to the line, made 1-for-2 and took the lead, 7-6. More ugly basketball followed as the ‘Cats tacked on two more Karasinski misses from deep to drop him to 1-for-6 on the day. Seeing early action, Symon Ghai was fouled under the rim and made both for the ‘Cats to get the lead back. After over eight minutes, Northwestern had scored only eight points to Columbia’s seven.
After another empty possession, the Wildcats got another stop, holding Columbia to seven. West finally cashed in his first bucket of the game with a free-throw line jumper followed by a Karasinski three-pointer to extend the ‘Cats’ lead to six.
Following a quick two-pointer on a well-designed play from the Lions fresh out of the huddle, Aleksej Kostic cashed in his first points of the season on a layup to make it 15-11 ‘Cats at the under-eight timeout. A Ciaravino jumper extended Northwestern’s lead, but a Columbia layup from Connor Igoe as the shot clock expired brought the Wildcat’s lead back to four. After a missed jumper from West and a foul on Ciaravino, Josiah Cunningham hit an excellent two-pointer to cut the deficit to two.
Then what can only be described as disgusting basketball, the ‘Cats gave up a two-point stepback jumper to Gerard O’Keefe, and a poor pass from Colin Smith on the inbound led to an easy layup from Cunningham to give Columbia the lead at 19-17, and a foul from Smith brought the Wildcats into the under-four timeout. Josh Pratt (LA Pratt’s brother, who plays for Columbia) cashed in his first point of the game after going 1-for-2 on free throws and subsequently draining a three from the right corner.
The Lions caught fire, extending it to an eight-point lead when Karasinski committed an offensive foul while driving to the basket with 30 seconds on the clock. Northwestern had committed over ten fouls to Columbia’s five, but caught another break when the Lions made just one from the line again, totaling four misses. Okku Federiko then threw the ball away to end the first half with the ‘Cats trailing by nine to Columbia.
Karasinski led the half with seven points for Northwestern, while Gerard O’Keefe and Mason Ritter led the way for the Lions with six points each.
Coming out of the half, another three from Josh Pratt put the ‘Cats down 11 after just a minute had passed, but two consecutive Jake West and LA Pratt three-pointers brought it back to a more manageable five-point deficit. After Ritter hit another layup, the Lions’ lead extended to seven, but a persistent Karasinski worked through bodies to get to the rim. Northwestern can’t have nice things, though, and O’Keefe drained another three, then a two. With Columbia’s lead now at ten, West worked his way to the basket and cashed in to make it 39-31 Lions at the under-16 timeout.
An and-one from Ciaravino made it 41-34 with 14 minutes remaining. The ‘Cats gave it right back, though, handing Columbia an and-one also, as they extended the lead to ten. Hampton Sanders drained another one from behind the arc to extend the lead to 13 for the Lions, before Ciaravino slammed one down to reinvigorate the crowd and bring Northwestern back to within 11.
Colin Smith drained a triple out of the break to cut the deficit to eight as Douglas Langford lost his dribble out of bounds, handing possession back to the Wildcats. A push down the court looked promising for Northwestern, but Phoenix Gill had his dunk rejected by Langford and gave the ball right back to the Lions.
O’Keefe banked in a jumper for the Lions to put them up 12, then a quick steal and score put them up 14 with just under nine minutes remaining. Another three quickly made it 17 as the lead slipped away.
As time kept falling on the clock, it got worse for the ‘Cats. By the time there was a minute remaining, Northwestern was down 24. Columbia fans took to their feet in a standing ovation as the Lions roared to victory, 75-53 over Northwestern to hand the ‘Cats their second consecutive pre-Big Ten loss.
Up next, the ‘Cats head to Charleston to take on Virginia Tech on Friday at 2:00 PM CST on ESPN2.













