Mark Prior, as you surely know, is one of the biggest “what if”s in all of Cubs history.
Selected by the Cubs in the first round (second overall) out of USC in 2001, he rocketed through the Cubs system and was in the major leagues only a year later.
Prior made 19 starts for the Cubs in 2002, posting a 3.32 ERA and striking out 147 in 116.2 innings, finishing seventh in NL Rookie of the Year voting.
2003 was the year he burst onto the scene as one of the best pitchers in MLB. He led NL pitchers with
7.4 bWAR, went 18-6 with a 2.43 ERA (2.47 FIP) and struck out 245 in 211.1 innings. That’s the sixth-most strikeouts by any Cubs pitcher in a single season in the Modern Era.
2003 was also the year the injury bug began to bite Prior. In a game July 11 against the Pirates, Prior collided with Pirates second baseman Marcus Giles. The whole story is in this BCB article, including video. As noted in that article, Prior didn’t leave the game after the collision with Giles, but he wound up missing about three weeks. He came back better: In the 11 starts made after his return, Prior posted a 1.52 ERA and 1.004 WHIP, with 95 strikeouts and only 16 walks and only four home runs allowed in 82.2 innings.
All of us know about Dusty Baker leaving Prior in too long in Game 6 of the NLCS in 2003 and I’m not going to belabor that. What I will note is that in Game 2 of that NLCS, Baker left Prior in to throw seven innings and 116 pitches even though the Cubs had a 12-0 lead after five. THAT was the time to give Prior some rest so he’d be better in Game 6.
Anyway.
Prior missed significant time in 2004 with an Achilles issue, making only 21 starts, and overall his numbers were down. But his last start of that year, Sept. 30 against the Reds, was magnificent — nine shutout innings with a career-high 16 strikeouts. But the Cubs only scored one in regulation and lost the game in 12 innings.
Prior started out the 2005 season well, but on May 27 he was hit in the elbow by a line drive hit by Brad Hawpe of the Rockies. That story is in this BCB article. I was at that game. When that injury happened, I was convinced it was season-ending, if not career-ending. Instead, Prior was back on the mound in four weeks. I am further convinced that, while this has never been stated or confirmed by anyone involved, that coming back too soon likely made subtle changes in Prior’s motion and delivery and could have led to the shoulder issues that ended his career. Prior posted 15.7 bWAR in his five years with the Cubs.
That happened the following season, when those shoulder injuries prevented Prior from throwing in a MLB game until June 18, when he faced the Tigers at Wrigley Field. They pounded him for seven hits and eight runs, including four home runs. It was sad, watching that great talent fade away. Prior made eight more starts and then was shut down. He left the Cubs as a free agent after the 2007 season, and signed minor-league deals with the Padres, Rangers, Yankees, Red Sox and Reds. He actually did throw pretty well as a reliever for Triple-A Pawtucket in the Red Sox organization in 2012 — 19 games, 38 strikeouts in 25 innings — but never got called up.
As you know, Prior is now the pitching coach for the Los Angeles Dodgers, and has held that position since 2021; for the three years before that he was their bullpen coach. He’s been highly respected by that organization and, of course, has three World Series rings as a Dodgers coach. I’m happy for Prior that he’s done this. If only those injuries could have been avoided.













