The New York Giants’ loss to the Washington Commanders on Thursday tightened the NFC East race and made their weekend off less enjoyable than it could have been. Thanks to the San Francisco 49ers outscoring the Dallas Cowboys on Sunday, though, the Giants’ division lead entering Week 11 is not as tenuous as it could have been.
The 5-3-1 Giants have a 2½-game lead over the 4-6 Cowboys and a two-game lead over the 3-5-1 Commanders. The Athletic’s playoff simulator gives the Giants a 56% chance of winning
the NFC East and making the playoffs. The Cowboys are at 28%, and the Commanders 16%.
Much has been made of the fact that the Giants’ schedule, beginning this weekend with the 7-2 Jacksonville Jaguars, is about to get tougher. Over the Giants’ first nine games, their opponents were a combined 25-49-1, a .340 winning percentage. Their upcoming opponents are a combined 43-33, a .566 winning percentage.
Head coach John Harbaugh said recently that the Giants “don’t live in that scared world” of worrying about schedule difficulty.
The Giants are a resilient team. Harbaugh has made them that way. They have, to this point, overcome the losses of quarterback Jaxson Dart and star edge defender Brian Burns. In each of their five wins, they have made plays late in the game to secure the victory.
Fight and resilience alone, though, won’t win the NFC East title for the Giants. The Giants are an imperfect team that has things to fix in order to win the division. Below are some of the things the Giants are going to have to do better over the final eight games.
Four-minute offense
The Giants, holding a 21-17 lead, intercepted Washington quarterback Jayden Daniels twice in the last 5:31 of Thursday’s game. That should be enough for the Giants to have won that game. But it wasn’t.
The Giants went three-and-out after both interceptions, failing to run significant time off the clock or force the Commanders to use up their timeouts on either occasion.
The first possession included three runs, with the last being a Jameis Winston third-and-1 sneak on which running back Cam Skattebo never really got out of his stance to participate in the play. Harbaugh explained that this was a straight sneak, not a tush push.
The second possession, which started at the Washington 46-yard line with 2:15 to play, also featured three runs. The last was a designed quarterback run for J.J. McCarthy on which the Giants didn’t even have a running back on the field.
You can see from the jump he got that Washington linebacker Sonny Styles knew this play before the ball was snapped. Center Bryan Hudson had no chance to block him.
“We had thought we had good runs. We thought we could get it with the runs. Also keep the clock running and make them burn the timeouts. We thought we could do both,” Harbaugh said. “But looking back on it, I think a good pass there might’ve been good too. I think if you throw the ball and you throw three incompletions or whatever, the question is flipped, you know, “why didn’t you run the ball, make them burn the timeouts?” Being successful really is the bottom line. It’s not like we’re trying to play it safe or anything like that. We’re not afraid to throw the ball there. The run that we had, the last run that got the two-yard loss, that’s got a chance to crack them. It’s a quarterback-driven run with an extra blocker. They had everybody up on the line. Honestly, on that one play, we can block that play better. And so that’s the way the game went in that situation.”
The problem is, four-minute offense failure has been a theme for the Giants.
- In Week 3 against the Tennessee Titans, the Giants got the ball with 5:31 to play, protecting a 12-7 lead. They got a quick first down on a 12-yard Jameis Winston to Malik Nabers pass, but then punted with 3:12 to go after two runs and an incomplete pass. Jevon Holland bailed the Giants out, intercepting Cam Ward in the end zone with :24 to play.
- In Week 4 against the Arizona Cardinals, the Giants got the ball at midfield with a 3-point lead and 4:47 to play. They could muster only 16 yards in five plays, with a Dominic Zvada 52-yard field goal giving them a 20-24 lead with 2:16 to play. It took a Deonte Banks 98-yard interception return on the final play to seal that victory.
- In Week 5 against Washington, Skattebo’s fumble at the two-minute mark in overtime cost the Giants a chance to win.
- In Week 8 against the Philadelphia Eagles, the Giants got the ball with 1:56 to play after a Jake Elliott field goal pulled the Eagles within one score. After three handoffs to Devin Singletary netted just 2 yards, the Giants punted and once again relied on their defense to bail them out.
“That’s something that I’ve always prided myself [on], playing on an offense that’s able to ice the game,” fullback Patrick Ricard said after Thursday’s loss. “I feel like this year we haven’t been able to do that as an offense. Only probably Week 1 that we actually ran the ball or got first downs, and were able to kneel the game out.
“We’ve always had to rely on our defense, and our defense is very clutch, and they’ve been winning a lot of games for us. It’s something that we as an offense have to really harp on to finish games out like that because we can’t keep relying on our defense to keep going out there and just keep getting stops after stops. We need to be able to convert first downs in those moments.”
I don’t have the answer. A head coach in his 19th season and a veteran offensive staff, though, need to do everything they can to figure it out. The Giants can’t ask their defense to close every game in the final seconds. We saw that on Thursday night.
Placekicking consistency
We went in-depth on Zvada’s issues from the right hashmark on Saturday. It simply isn’t possible to design an offense to get every field goal attempt from the left hashmark. This is something that Zvada and veteran special teams coordinator Chris Horton are going to have to figure out.
Harbaugh’s refusal to move on from Zvada, an undrafted rookie who won the job with a fantastic summer, after his struggles since Week 9 has driven the fan base to distraction.
I understand Harbaugh’s desire to ride things out with Zvada and hope he becomes the kicker the Giants believe he can be sooner rather than later. Look around the league. For every team that has a Brandon Aubrey, Cam Little, or a solid veteran like Chris Boswell, there are teams riding what former special teams coordinator Thomas McGaughey called the “kicker train”, and finding it an unpleasant experience.
Just like there aren’t 32 top-10 caliber quarterbacks in the NFL, there aren’t 32 kickers teams feel good about every time they need three points. Or even one point.
Zvada, 23, has the leg strength and talent to be one of those long-range placekicking weapons every team is seeking. Hall of Fame kicker Adam Vinatieri kicked for 24 years, but made 80% of his field goal attempts just once in his first four seasons.
Former Giants kicker Lawrence Tynes certainly believes in Zvada:
Over the years, the Giants have seen many good young placekickers like Chris Boswell, Brandon McManus, and Joey Slye get away from them and go on to have excellent careers. They don’t want Zvada to be the next one.
Still, with a playoff berth at stake, how patient can they be?
Don’t be so conservative
Everything good about the Giants’ season comes from Harbaugh. The credibility he brought when the Giants hired him and the way he has led this team and made it believe it deserved to, and could, win have meant everything. Hiring Harbaugh is the best decision the Giants could have made. He is the biggest reason the Giants have a chance to win their first division title since 2011.
Harbaugh, though, was never going to be perfect. He wasn’t in Baltimore, which is a big part of why he is now in New York.
In a game Harbaugh said was “for all the marbles,” against Washington, the Giants were far too cautious.
The Giants punted three times in Commanders’ territory. Two of those came in the fourth quarter. Two were also within field goal range for Zvada. When I asked him about those, Harbaugh said they were “risk-reward” decisions and that with the weather conditions “sometimes it’s better to play a field position game.”
I used to criticize former Giants coach Joe Judge because he seemed to have a “play for later rather than try to win the game now” philosophy. This, to me, was that kind of game for Harbaugh.
In our post-game podcast, Tony Del Genio raised the idea that Harbaugh showed a lack of faith in the Giants’ offense. My take is a little different. I see it as an old-school coach employing old-school “take as few risks as possible” thinking.
I always say that good play calls or decisions are those that work. Bad decisions or play calls are those that don’t.
Still, I thought Harbaugh and the Giants were too conservative a couple of times in the fourth quarter. Early in the fourth quarter, the Giants had third-and-three at the Washington 46-yard line. Analytics were clear that this was a for-for-it if you got to fourth down situation.
Instead, J.J. McCarthy threw a pass that Theo Johnson dropped, and the Giants punted. Johnson, of course, could have made the Giants right. He did not.
The other situation was the McCarthy third-and-3 run after the Ar’Darius Washington interception with 2:15 left in the game. It’s easy to say a short pass to Isaiah Likely or Malik Nabers was the right call, because it probably was. The biggest problem with the run play, to me, is that the personnel (no running backs in the game) and formation made it crystal clear what the play call was.
The Giants punted with 1:54 to play.
By re-litigating this, we are crying over spilt milk. Nothing can be done about the Washington game now. A lesson, though, needs to be learned.
You don’t win games by trying not to lose them. Especially with the Giants stepping up in class for many of their final eight games, they are going to have to be willing to take some risks.
Unleashing Abdul
By some measures, Abdul Carter has been excellent. Through Week 9, Carter was second in the NFL in pass rush win rateat 35%. He is tied for seventh in the NFL in quick pressures with 17, per NextGen Stats. His time to pressure of 2.42 seconds is 19th among edge defenders and linebackers. And, yes, it seems like Carter is forever being held — though many of them go uncalled.
Still, it is a production game. Carter has just two sacks despite, per NextGen Stats, his 285 pass rush opportunities being the most of any linebacker or edge defender in the league. Carter’s pressure percentage of 9.8 is 104th. His sacks percentage of 0.7 is 94th.
Whatever the stats are, and whatever the reasons are for the low sack numbers, the reality is the Giants need more from the 2025 No. 3 overall pick.
Former Giants linebacker Carl Banks has some ideas:
Whatever it takes, the Giants are going to need Carter to make more plays.













