OK. Things at this point are getting a little uncomfortable. One would think that the Indianapolis Colts had learned their lesson when it comes to Jonathan Taylor after that disastrous offseason three years ago, but it looks like we are headed for a rinse and repeat cycle. The rumor mill is picking up and speculation is running wild about what the Colts will do with Taylor. Trade destinations are being proposed and perceived compensation put into the ether. Could the Colts really make such a move?
In short, why not? Everyone is expendable. If the Colts are willing to move on from Peyton Manning, absolutely no one is safe. Taylor is in the last year of his deal and running backs don’t normally get better at this point. It’s a game of chicken. At some point he will hit the wall, and Taylor is hoping he gets another payday before that point. The Colts are hopeful they don’t get stuck holding the bag. Sure, Daniel Jones going down had a huge impact, but Taylor disappeared over the back half of 2025. This might be the highest his value reaches.
What is that value? Speculation has it at a third-round pick. That doesn’t seem like enough juice for the squeeze. Running back is a devalued position, but look at what he did the first half of the year. He carried the team at times. Although last year was a mixed bag, it appears he has more in the tank. Letting one of your best players go for a third-round pick seems ill-advised if you truly want to be competitive this year. If the Colts make this move, there could be instant regret watching Taylor run roughshod over the rest of the NFL in a different jersey.
The Colts can do anything they want. If they find a trade partner and feel the return is satisfactory, that is their call. That doesn’t mean it would be a wise decision. Jonathan Taylor looks like he has another contract in him. Extend him for three years with an option in the third year. He is the best the Colts have on the roster. Paying Jones and Pierce big bucks to send Taylor away seems counterintuitive. Give Taylor one last ride and bet he will reward the decision.
