Over the past few years, the Yankees have coveted a good deal of players from other teams who, despite not possessing star status, had profiles that Brian Cashman and his cohort of front office personnel nonetheless found appealing. Ryan McMahon was one of those players who routinely came up again and again in MLB trade rumors, and time after time, those rumors linked him to the Bronx.
Third base had been a sore spot for the Yankees for a few seasons, and when the hot corner situation reached its
nadir last summer, Cashman finally pulled the trigger with a somewhat-limited market for improvement available to him. McMahon was at last a Yankee. One unspectacular half-season later, he enters his first full year in the Bronx with subdued expectations — even on a contract that will pay him $32 million across 2026-27.
Can McMahon finally unlock the full potential of his long-tantalizing toolset? Or will he continue to be a merely cromulent glove-first third baseman?
2025 statistics (total): 154 games, 586 PA, .214/.312/.281 (86 wRC+), 20 HR, 53 RBI, 32.3 K%, 11.9 BB%, 10 Defensive Runs Saved, 6 Outs Above Average, 1.9 fWAR
2025 statistics (with NYY): 54 games, 185 PA, .208/.308/333 (84 wRC+), 4 HR, 18 RBI, 33.5 K%, 11.4 BB%, 7 DRS, 0.6 fWAR
2026 FanGraphs DC projections: 113 games, 490 PA, .211/.304/.371 (91 wRC+), 17 HR, 1.7 fWAR
Once arriving in his new environments, McMahon did exactly what people figured he’d do: provide excellent defense at the hot corner while striking out far too often to be a productive presence at the plate. By the end of the year he was effectively part of a platoon with Amed Rosario, whom the Yankees re-signed this winter. While certainly Rosario is a nice depth add across the board, his return signals that the team is not bursting with confidence that McMahon will take a step forward at the dish.
And entering his age-31 season, there isn’t much reason to think differently. Despite consistently providing solid power numbers and demonstrating above-average plate discipline, McMahon has never posted a wRC+ above 97 in his nine-year MLB career. This is mostly because roughly 30 percent of his over 4,000 career plate appearances have resulted in strikeouts. In fact, McMahon had the highest strikeout rate among all qualified hitters in 2025. The tightrope you have to walk to eat that many K’s and remain productive is unforgiving, and McMahon has never been consistent enough in doing damage with the contact he makes to walk it effectively.
That’s not to say he can’t do damage. McMahon has always run high hard-hit rates and had a 12.1 percent barrel rate in 2025, the highest of his career. Last year also saw a massive jump in the percentage of batted balls that were pulled in the air: up to 17 percent from 11.1 percent. This is an encouraging development, and hints at the possibility that McMahon could become more consistent in reaching the seats with his fly balls if that trend continues into 2026.
But of course, there’s also the platoon stats you have to worry about. McMahon throughout his career has been worse against lefties, but in the normal way—a sizable but not dramatic split. In fact, he actually hit better against lefties in 2024. Last year, though, the gulf widened in the other direction: he managed just a .534 OPS against lefties compared to a .739 OPS against righties. That was the impetus for Rosario taking a bigger chunk of his at-bats versus southpaws down the stretch. Platoon splits can be volatile, so I wouldn’t be surprised if he does a little bit better this season, but if he doesn’t, that timeshare with the returning Rosario will continue.
Thankfully, McMahon remains dependable in the field. While he’s never won a Gold Glove for his work at third base, he made a big late push last year with 7 Defensive Runs Saved in his time with the Yankees alone. He’ll be in the mix to unseat incumbent Maikel Garcia and win the award at the hot corner this year, which will give him a leg up on Rosario—a comparatively poor fielder—in that platoon arrangement. And he’s already produced some spectacular highlights, most notably that Derek Jeter-esque catch in Game 3 of the Wild Card Series last year.
Ultimately, unless McMahon seriously shaves his strikeout stubble, there’ll always be a bit of a five o’clock shadow around his triple slash, so to speak. His defense nonetheless gives him a high floor even when he struggles at the dish—and eighth or ninth place hitters are never expected to challenge for the batting title anyway. We’re not prognosticating an All-Star selection for him, a Gold Glove could be in the offing—and if he can sniff that elusive 100 wRC+ figure, so much the better.
See more of the Yankees Previews series here.
