Since 2023, Manny Machado and Xander Bogaerts have locked down the left side of the San Diego Padres’ infield. Unsurprisingly, both veterans backed up that reputation with above-average defensive metrics last season.
But the infield defensive alignment needs to get younger across the board, and moving Machado to full-time DH is worth exploring.
Machado’s days at third base numbered?
With Machado turning 35 in 2027 and showing clear signs of decline, it’s time to build a starting lineup that doesn’t rely on him at third base every day.
Last
season, Machado played 139 games at third base and made only three errors with a .990 fielding percentage. However, he graded out poorly with a -8 Fielding Run Value (FRV). At this stage of his career, Machado can field every ball hit directly at him, but his range to cover the line is slipping.
The move helps solve two growing problems: getting the lineup younger and more athletic while keeping Machado’s bat productive all summer.
Padres need to preserve Machado’s offensive impact
One of the biggest mysteries of the 2026 season was Machado’s prolonged first-half batting slump. Without his expected production, the Friars’ offense struggled to score runs.
After a slow start hitting at .226, Machado fell into a deeper slump, batting .127 with 29 strikeouts over 102 at-bats in May. A power surge began in June and continued into July. He raised his slugging percentage to .490.
Machado finished the 2026 campaign with a .217 batting average, 57 points lower than his career average (.274). As the season progressed, his bat speed seemed to slow down through the strike zone. Machado posted his highest strikeout rate (21.3%) since 2022.
Adjusting to a new role may come with early struggles for Machado. Last season as a DH, he batted .158 with one home run in 19 starts. Rather than a permanent position change, Padres manager Craig Stammen may cap his third-base workload at 120 to 125 games to keep his legs fresh.
While Machado still packs plenty of punch as a middle-of-the-order threat, his run production has tapered off. He hasn’t driven in 100 runs in three of the last four years. The Friars are counting on Machado to bounce back and thrive in pressure-packed at-bats.
Finding the right fit matters
Any potential move only works if the Friars land a young infielder with an outstanding glove. The front office will have to look outside the organization since their farm system lacks an in-house candidate. However, if the Padres cannot find a quality trade option, then the club should scrap the idea until 2028.
This scenario depends on how much the Padres’ new owners, Kwanza Jones and Jose E. Feliciano, are willing to spend to improve the team. It may come down to signing multiple free-agent starting pitchers and keeping the lineup intact for another season.
At some point, the roster needs to evolve. It will be fascinating to see if this suggestion becomes a reality.
Padres News:
- Nick Pivetta missed much of 2026 with an arm injury, but he returned for the final weeks of the season and performed well. He logged enough innings to receive his grade from Lincoln Zdunich of Gaslamp Ball.
- The Padres need pitching and they are one of the teams in talks with Tarik Skubal. With new owners and unknown budget, there is no reason to think they could not land the ace.
- Recent draft classes for Padres are drawing attention from baseball publications.
Baseball News:
- Several players around MLB are drawing trade interest and they play positions all over the diamond.
- MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred does not think a deal between MLBPA and MLB owners will be consummated without a salary cap.
- Sonny Gray agrees to two-year deal with the Minnesota Twins.
- The Kansas City Royals and the Seattle Mariners made the first big trade of the offseason.
- The Boston Red Sox acquired catcher Nick Fortes in a trade with the Tampa Bay Rays.
- Here are the latest rumors around MLB.













