The New York Giants had the postseason clearly in their sights in the dysfunctional NFC East…until they let victory slip through their hands against the Washington Commanders last Thursday evening. Now they have made life more difficult for themselves. If you experienced the Tom Coughlin era, you’ll probably remember that this is nothing new. Let’s take a little trip down memory lane:
2007: In Week 14 the Giants beat the Eagles at The Linc 16-13 to get to 9-4 and put the playoffs clearly in their
sights. The the next week they laid an egg at Giants Stadium, losing to Washington 22-10. Not until Ahmad Bradhsaw’s 88-yard TD run as the snow started to fall late in the game in Buffalo the following week did the Giants clinch a playoff spot.
2011: In Week 14 the Giants won in Dallas 37-34 when Jason Pierre-Paul blocked the Cowboys’ last second field goal attempt to get to 7-6. Next week, at home against Washington, the Giants were embarrassed by a 4-9 Washington team at home, 23-10. Not until Victor Cruz’s 99-yard TD reception to spark a win against the Jets and a final week 31-14 win over the Cowboys for the division title did the Giants clinch a playoff spot.
It just seems to be in the Giants’ DNA to play poorly against Washington. Now we’re three years and running that the Giants haven’t beaten them (coinciding with the arrival of Jayden Daniels). Anyway, that’s in the rear-view mirror, and the question is whether the Giants can bounce back as they did in 2007 and 2011 to get to the playoffs anyway. No one sees the Giants as a Super Bowl contender (more on that in a minute), but as 2007 and 2011 showed, you never know. Unlike those seasons, the 2026 Giants are in the driver’s seat in the NFC East even after their loss. Unfortunately, the wins have all been against losing teams and they now face a stretch of some of the best teams in the NFL. What are their chances of reaching the post-season, and which games have the most leverage on their chances?
To answer that we’ll use The Athletic’s NFL playoff simulator. The simulator gives the current chances of each team making the playoffs, as a division champion or wild card, and allows the user to see how individual games affect your team’s chances. Let’s play with the possibilities.
Let’s get one thing out of the way right away: The Giants will not make the playoffs as a wild card this season:
The Giants’ chances of winning the division and making the playoffs are identical, as they are for every NFC East and NFC South team. The Eagles are out of the picture. The Giants’ chances to win the Super Bowl, however, are effectively nil at this point. How does each remaining game affect the Giants chances? Some matter more than others, but at this point they’re all fairly important:
Obviously the Dallas game in Week 18 is their highest leverage game because it could directly decide the division champion. The differences among the other games are all about the NFL tiebreaking critieria. For a two-team tie these are:
Let’s look at a few scenarios. Beating the Jaguars this Sunday would be big, increasing the Giants’ playoff chances from 61% to 76% according to the simulator without considering any other games. A loss however drops their odds to almost 50-50. Fear not – a win the following week over the downtrodden Colts would get them back to two-in-three playoff odds. The figure below shows the odds with me having selected the coming two games in black:
Now let’s consider the brutal reality that the 49ers and Seahawks are next on the schedule. Not that either team is unbeatable – the 49ers had their hands full with Dallas last Sunday and the Seahawks are having a post-Super Bowl hangover. Still, the Giants will be clear underdogs in both games barring injuries to multiple key players on either team. So assuming two more losses:
Three losses in the next four weeks, making it four of five defeats for the Giants, only reduces the playoff odds to about even. Why? It’s because the Cowboys have their own gauntlet to run. After presumable gimmes against the Titans and Eagles in the coming two weeks, they face the Seahawks, Rams, and Jaguars after that, before playing the Giants and Commanders in their final two games.
And that’s the key: Even if the Giants stink up the joint in the coming month, the odds are that they still face the Cowboys in Week 17 with the division title on the line.
So what is the Giants’ most important game? Actually, it’s coming up right after Jacksonville. The Giants absolutely must beat the Indianapolis Colts, who are in disarray after injuries, trading several of their best players, and Daniel Jones’ carriage turning into a pumpkin in his second season as a Colt. If they don’t, and they lose those other games as well:
Even then, all might not be lost if the Cowboys play to form because of their tough December schedule. Let’s imagine that the Giants beat the surprising Cleveland Browns in Week 15, lose to a tough Detroit Lions team the week after, and then take care of business in Dallas and at home against the Eagles in the season finale:
In this desultory performance scenario the Giants weather a five-game losing streak, only win three more games, and still have a 72% chance to win the division at 8-8-1. That’s almost as high as the 76% chance they’d get just by beating Jacksonville this Sunday. Beating the Jags and the Colts increases their chances to 85%, and that only drops to 77% if they lose to the 49ers and Seahawks as expected:
All in all, I would say that the second scenario I presented above (lose to JAX, SF, SEA, beat IND) is the most realistic outcome for the coming month. That means that there are decent odds that it’s a coin flip by late December whether the Giants will make the playoffs, and it will all come down to that last month. It could have been so much better if they’d beaten Washington even once, never mind twice as could have happened.
Still, things could be worse. You could be a fan of a team that only won its first game of the season on Monday night, or a fan of the team they beat that jettisoned its former head coach and may watch him in the playoffs while they stay home. (By the way, if the Los Angeles Chargers run the table they have a 52% chance to sneak into the playoffs.) Talk is cheap, though. Beating Jacksonville would be worth more.













