I wanted to pen some quick thoughts on two things that made the rounds: 1) Antonio Rüdiger’s quotes about Kylian Mbappe’s defense; and 2) Vinicius Jr’s recent controversial quotes where he explained why he didn’t arrive to this season in good shape.
Rüdiger, to The Athletic, on Kylian Mbappe’s defending
“Should I tell Mbappé, who in two years has scored 100 goals for Real Madrid, to do MY job? It makes NO sense. Look at Gareth Bale, Karim Benzema and Cristiano Ronaldo. Look at the success they had. We don’t always need to talk about them defending.”
For
starters, there is absolutely nothing wrong with Antonio Rüdiger defending his teammate, or anyone on his team, in general. In fact, it’s commendable. I actually actively encourage the idea of not being 100% honest in these situations and being PR savvy. Your boys are your boys, forever. You go to war with them and you go to war for them. Honesty is preserved for behind the scenes, not for public condemnation.
But it’s also fun to explore the holes in what Rüdiger actually said.
For one, Bale and Benzema in particular are terrible examples to bring up here, because Bale and Benzema were both defensive maniacs who could press and track. Bale was a two-way force who would cover for his wing-back constantly, while Benzema’s off-ball work ethic is so good it could be studied. Ronaldo, for his part, though he didn’t defend as much as those two (nor should he have, to be clear), worked pretty hard defensively considering he is arguably the greatest player that has ever lived — and most of his ‘lack of pressing issues’ came towards the tail end of his career at Manchester United and on.
I also don’t think ‘asking Mbappe to do Rüdiger’s job’ is the equivalent of asking Mbappe to press more because no one is actually asking Mbappe to defend like a center-back. The request is to simply help keep the off-ball structure of the team in tact.
Now, to be fair to Mbappe, you see how much better the team’s defense, as a whole, has been with Yan Diomande replacing Vinicius Jr on the left wing. You can get away with one player not defending provided he’s scoring 40-50 goals per year — but having two players who don’t defend is virtually impossibly to compensate for in the modern era.
The better analogy for Rüdiger would actually be this: No, no one is asking a center-back to be a striker, but there is a request in modern football that all center-backs have ball-playing ability. So the equivalent to a center-back being good on the ball in the build-up phase does go hand-in-hand with a center-forward being able to press.
Vinicius on showing up out of shape
“I don’t think I prepared better after the World Cup because the impact of this tournament is very significant for all Brazilians. Losing so early was something we didn’t expect.
“So I took advantage of the holidays to enjoy myself, rest, relax, and spend more time with my family. I ended up training less than in recent years. This may have affected my start to the season.
“Also, regarding my contract renewal, with so many clubs interested last summer, I felt really overwhelmed, as did the situation at Real Madrid. But the season is very long.”
Full points for honesty, but honesty is not a get out of jail free card.
There’s a lot to unpack here:
- The devastation of losing the World Cup is not an excuse to show up to pre-season out of shape. You know who else was devastated after losing the World Cup? Literally every single player that didn’t play for Spain. Imagine the chaos of everyone mailing it in for the club that pays them simply because they’re allowed to sulk after losing the World Cup. You don’t see Jude Bellingham, Arda Güler, Kylian Mbappe, Yan Diomande, etc taking this approach.
- I have always believed that if you get paid a disgusting amount of money by a football club, not least Real Madrid, then you have an obligation to be in peak physical form 365 days per year. It is the bare minimum. My biggest gripe with Eden Hazard was that he took summers off simply because he wasn’t on the clock. You can take vacations, but you can’t let yourself go just because the season is over — especially if you’re getting paid like you’re the face of the franchise. It’s disrespectful to the club that has put all their faith in you — and the club that gave you a big contract extension this summer.
- Vinicius showed up to pre-season well before all the Spanish, French, and English internationals because Brazil were eliminated earlier — yet he was and is still miles behind them in terms of physical fitness.
- Having two elite football clubs bid over your services feels like, umm, very much a first world problem.
None of us know how Vinicius’s Real Madrid career will go from here, but, right now there are better, hungrier players than him. He will need to earn his place just like anyone else. I have faith in Jose Mourinho to figure that out.













