Last year, Cam Schlittler put in one of the most memorable Yankees’ playoff pitching performances of the century in Game 3 of the AL Wild Card Series against the Red Sox. With the series tied at one and everything at stake, he went eight innings, striking out 12 batters while scattering a couple hits and no walks. While anyone who had seen him pitch in the weeks leading up to that start could see that there was something there, that start exceeded almost everyone’s expectation. Adding to that, he was born
and raised in Massachusetts, and hasn’t been afraid to go at Boston fans on social media, clearly coming in with a chip on his shoulder, even against the team he grew up rooting for.
Flash forward a year, and Schlittler has very much looked like the pitcher he was that day in 2025, except for the entire season. With a season ERA under 2.00 and a bunch of other excellent numbers, he’s the current favorite for the AL Cy Young Award. While starting a rookie in a do-or-die game last season was something of a risk, this year he was the no-doubt choice to take the mound in Game 1 as the Yankees and Red Sox met in the Wild Card Series again.
While just on raw numbers, Schlittler wasn’t as good as he was last year, his start in Game 1 against the Red Sox looked pretty similar to 2025.
In 6.1 innings on Tuesday night, Schlittler kept the Red Sox off the board, allowing just two hits and a walk while striking out 10. Both the hits he allowed were just singles and none of any of the runners even got into scoring position while he was in the game. You always feel somewhat on edge during close playoff baseball games, but there wasn’t much actual reason to be while Schlittler was in the game. Other than maybe going eight innings like he did last year, you couldn’t really ask for much more from him.
Between his performance this year and last year, he’s writing himself quite a legacy in this rivalry.
Then there’s Ben Rice. While Rice grew up a Yankee fan in enemy territory, he grew up in Massachusetts all the same. He’s probably not going to get the award love that Schlittler will, but he’s arguably been just as important this year. With 41 regular season home runs, he’s carried the offense at points, especially with Aaron Judge injured for much of this season.
On Tuesday night, he carried the offense once again. Rice went 4-for-5 with two home runs and six RBI. He turned a close game into a more than comfortable one.
While he wasn’t involved in the first of the Yankees’ nine runs, he played a part in a whole chunk of the rest. In the fifth inning, he hit a home run to double the Yankees’ lead with the game still very close. As the Yankees started to tack on some insurance runs, he drove home one with a single as part of a two-run seventh. However, the big blow was still yet to come.
With the bases loaded and two outs in the eighth, the Yankees led 5-0 with Rice at the plate. At five runs, they had a comfortable lead, but still one you’d probably expect them to turn to closer David Bednar for, if not only to erase any doubt. With one swing, Rice put the cherry on top of the game and insured they could save some bullpen bullets for future games.
The Yankees getting these performances in big moments is always great. It’s even better when you factor in that both Schlittler and Rice are homegrown prospects. Then you add in the fact that they’re from Red Sox territory and it adds a layer of humor. That being said, no matter where they’re from, I’ll take performances like what they provided on Tuesday night.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
- New, improved notifications system!
Download the SB Nation app on iOS or Android.
