The Green Bay Packers have a Smack problem. Er, let me rephrase that. Rookie kicker Trey Smack has fallen far short of expectations in his first 10 games for the Packers. There, that’s better.
Through those 10 games, he’s converted just 71.4% of his field-goal attempts and missed three extra points. Those numbers simply aren’t good enough. Not to win the Super Bowl. Not to win the division. Not to win 10 total games.
But should we kick our Smack habit already? Sorry, I couldn’t resist. Anyway, it seems
like there’s some decent historical evidence in favor of sticking with him. For now.
Younghoe Koo is an interesting comparison. After making just three of six field goal attempts during his brief rookie stint with the Chargers in 2017, Koo was released. He eventually worked his way back into the NFL and became, on balance, a very reliable NFL kicker. His current career field goal percentage sits at 85.3% and he’s made 95.9% of extra point attempts.
But you don’t even need to leave Brown County. Mason Crosby hit a bump in the road in 2012, making just 63.6% of his field goal attempts. The team stuck with him. Not apples to apples, because that was his 6th season with the team. Even still, he kicked for eleven more seasons after that, wrapping up his career at an 81.3% make clip.
Look. I’m not naive. Neither of these examples guarantees Smack will figure things out. But they demonstrate that periods of struggle don’t necessarily define a kicker’s career.
It’s also worth noting that Smack has legitimate credentials. At Florida, he converted 82.8% of his field-goal attempts and made 10 of 13 from beyond 50 yards. There’s something there.
Still, there’s a difference between developing a young kicker and repeatedly excusing poor performance. The Packers have already experienced the consequences of getting it wrong with Anders Carlson and Brayden Narveson (fights off flashbacks).
Smack deserves an opportunity to respond, but fans deserve an opportunity to comfortably take a bathroom break during an extra point attempt. He shouldn’t be handed the job indefinitely. He needs to gain consistency rather urgently. He doesn’t need to be perfect from here on out, but if he doesn’t improve, that doesn’t bode well for his roster spot.
Packers could find surprise Trey Smack answer in former FalconYounghoe Koo is a free agent. His career average FG% would be a tremendous upgrade for the Green Bay Packers.
LISTEN: “The Packers season is not over”Justis Mosqueda joins the UnPack Podcast to talk soberly about what happened to the Packers against Minnesota, and the outlook moving forward. Spoiler: there’s room for some optimism.
Packers’ offensive rollercoaster explained by one key statDiving in to the difference in EPA-per-play while tied or leading, versus playing from behind.
Grand Theft Contract: Six Worst Packers Free-Agent Signings of GTA EraWith the release of Grand Theft Auto VI, here are six horrific free-agent contracts awarded by the Packers during the GTA era.
Packers discussion in the Feed
Is Packers OC Adam Stenavich a dead man walking? Should he shoulder part of the blame for the Packers offensive struggles?
The Feed is the place for you to share whatever it is you want to talk about, big or small.Head over to the editor to start writing today!
Go Pack Go—wherever you go!
Keep Packers coverage and conversation at your fingertips with a faster, easier game-day experience on the SB Nation app.
- Join Packers fans in our live game chat
- Browse with fewer ads
- Seamlessly move between communities
- Comment and post faster
Download the SB Nation app on iOS or Android.













