Let me paint you a picture of basketball karma that’s almost too perfect to be real.
Andrew Wiggins gets traded to Miami for Jimmy Butler. The Warriors throw a tribute video for Wiggins that damn near made
me tear up. Then, in what feels like a cosmic joke, Jimmy Butler tears his ACL against his former team in Miami. Meanwhile, Jonathan Kuminga (who requested a trade and fell completely out of Steve Kerr’s rotation) suddenly has value again because the Warriors desperately need a wing with Butler down.
And where’s Wiggins? Out in South Beach playing solid two-way basketball like he never left the Bay Area. So here’s the question that’s got Dub Nation’s head spinning: What if the Warriors just… brought Wiggins back? What if they traded Kuminga to Miami for the guy they shipped out about a year ago?
Before you laugh this off as fantasy, remember: the Warriors have done this before.
They traded James Wiseman—the #2 overall pick from 2020—to get back Gary Payton II, a player they’d literally let walk. When you realize you were wrong, or when circumstances change the equation, Golden State has shown they’re not too proud to hit the undo button. That’s not weakness. That’s organizational wisdom.
The basketball fit makes sense in ways that should scare us. Wiggins knows this system inside and out. He knows the defensive rotations, the offensive flow, the culture. There’s zero learning curve. He’s already proven he can be the second-best player on a championship team while guarding the opponent’s best wing every night.
Kuminga, for all his athletic gifts and potential, has been maddeningly inconsistent. He wanted out. Kerr clearly doesn’t trust him in big moments. And although I want every Warriors pick to dominate here in the Bay, Miami’s developmental track record with young wings could be helpful for him. Maybe a change of scenery unlocks something in JK that Golden State couldn’t?
But here’s where it gets complicated, and why I’m not saying I want this to happen; I’m just saying I’m fascinated that it could happen. The return of Wiggins after the Warriors traded him for something better in Butler would be absolutely hilarious. I spent years defending Wiggins when the entire basketball world called him a bust. I wrote Dub Nation a love letter about his play when he left. I celebrated that 2022 championship harder than anyone because it vindicated everything I believed about Maple Jordan. So yeah, part of me would love to see #22 back in blue and gold.
But the other part of me wonders if the circumstances that made Wiggins great here were lightning in a bottle. That nostalgia is a hell of a drug, especially when you’re watching Steph’s window close in real-time. The Warriors are shuffling their deck before the trade deadline, trying to give Curry the best hand possible. Whether that includes a Wiggins return is anyone’s guess.
All I know is this: if it happens, Wiggins Island is about to experience a real estate boom.
What do you think, Dub Nation? Am I crazy for even entertaining this? Drop your thoughts below.
