While the Dodgers are striving to be the last team standing for the third season in a row, they aren’t alone in their quest to be the best for a long stretch of time.
Shohei Ohtani won National League MVP in each of his first two years with the Dodgers, the only player in franchise history to win that award in consecutive years. But he also won American League MVP in 2023 with the Angels, so he’s on a streak of three MVPs in a row, and four in the last five years.
Barry Bonds is the only other player
in MLB history to win more than two MVP awards in a row. Bonds explored the limits of science in winning four consecutive NL MVPs with the San Francisco Giants from 2001-04, during which he hit an eye-popping .349/.559/.809 from ages 36-39.
Thirteen other players won two MVP awards in a row, and Bonds himself also won consecutive awards in 1992 with the Pittsburgh Pirates and in 1993 with the Giants. In all, there have been 17 MLB seasons in which a player was trying for a third straight MVP.
These are nearly all fantastic seasons. Bonds at age 40 in 2005 broke down and only played in 14 games. Fifteen of the other 16 seasons topped 5 WAR, using either Baseball Reference or FanGraphs, save for Roger Maris in 1962, who put up a solid 3.7 WAR the year after setting the home run record.
The average of all 17 seasons, even including Bonds’ injured year, is 6.8 bWAR and 7.0 fWAR.
Besides Ohtani and Bonds, three players got reasonably close to winning a third straight MVP, finishing second the year after winning two in a row.
Hal Newhouser is the only pitcher on this list, winning AL MVP in 1944 and 1945 with the Detroit Tigers during World War II. Then he put up a 1.94 ERA with 26 wins, both league-leading, and 275 strikeouts in 292 2/3 innings in 1946. His Tigers finished second for the pennant to the Boston Red Sox, and Ted Williams won MVP by hitting .342/.497/.667 with 38 home runs.
The 1946 voting was relatively close, with Williams collecting 224 points to 197 for Newhouser. Williams got nine first-place votes compared to three for Newhouser. The other two second-place finishes were of the distant variety.
Yogi Berra won three AL MVPs in five years with the New York Yankees, including in both 1954 and 1955. Then it was Mickey Mantle’s turn. Mantle won MVP unanimously in 1956 by winning the triple crown, with Berra coming in second place in voting. Mantle also won MVP in 1957 but finished fifth in 1958 despite 8.7 bWAR and 8.8 fWAR.
Albert Pujols won NL MVP in 2008 and 2009, and in 2010 the St. Louis Cardinals first baseman turned in another monster season by hitting .312/.414/.596 with 42 home runs. He did get one first-place vote that year, but Cincinnati Reds first baseman Joey Votto got the other 31 to win the award.
Yankees outfielder Aaron Judge won the last two AL MVPs, and has a chance to join the group of three-consecutive-MVP winners in 2026. Ohtani this year will try to join Bonds as the only players to win four MVPs in a row, perhaps buoyed by his return to full-time two-way status.
