I want to take a break from the transactions. Just like the Cardinals, am I right? (Is this thing on?) I want to talk about the current roster. But not the normal way we talk about the current roster. The fun way. Well, ideally it’s fun, the results may not be as fun as I’m imagining right now. I want to look at the current roster and see who they compare most to at this point in their career.
It does mean something, although not a lot. I talk a lot about projections, and one tool that a projection will
use is to incorporate at least a little how similar players did in the past. Of course that only goes so far. Just because you look like JD Martinez at 35 does not mean a projection system is going to say your career is going to be over after your age 36 season. But it could at least be interesting to see how a Cardinals career might go based on similar players.
For this I will be using Baseball-Reference’s similarity score. If you haven’t played enough innings or taken enough plate appearances, they won’t have a similarity score section. So apologies to Cade Winquest, you are not eligible for this game. Pretty much anyone who has played a full season will be on this list. Let’s go in alphabetical order.
Justin Bruihl
Most similar at 29: Danny Coulombe
This comp is a mixed bag. Coulombe is undoubtedly a better pitcher than Bruihl, but he didn’t actually become a better pitcher until his 30s, when he was an oft-injured, but effective lefty out of the bullpen – until last year. But Coulombe spent his entire age 29 season in the minors, so at this point in time, this comp is saying he’s not MLB caliber. So good pitcher to be compared to, but not at this particular time in that pitcher’s career.
Best outcome of top 10: Matt Thornton
Thornton’s career started very late, and although Bruihl debuted at a fairly young age, he did establish himself late. Thornton turned into a fantastic reliever, delivering 10.7 fWAR after his age 29 season. As a reliever. Starting at age 31, he had 5 straight 1+ fWAR seasons.
Worst outcome of top 10: Sean Gilmartin
I mean I had a couple options, but the gist is that this guy’s career is essentially over. We’ve seen their best and it’s all downhill from here.
Conclusion
I have to say, I know Baseball-Reference’s similarity score isn’t perfect, but it actually made me more optimistic on Bruihl. It’s like 50/50 on guys who flame out soon after, and then pretty good relievers who stick around forever. Which is a better ratio than I expected! In addition to Thornton, Tim Mayza and Gabe Speier is on this list. First off, represent Gabe. Second, that’s four pretty decent left-handed relievers to be compared to when you throw in Coulombe.
Alec Burleson
Most similar: Nathaniel Lowe
Now that’s a scary one. Trade Burly immediately if you think this is his future. I’m not kidding.
Best outcome of top 10: Eric Karros
I think Brandon Belt might be the better career outcome, but Karros had the better age 28-31 seasons that would be relevant for a possible extension. Karros dropped off hard after age 31 though. Belt remained at least playable, if normally not a great player, for the majority of his career.
Worst outcome of the list: Rip Repulski
Former Cardinal Repulski did not have a good season after his age 27 season. I will say that he may be 4th on the list, because he made an All-Star team at 27, but he did not actually deserve to make the All-Star team. He had 0.8 fWAR and 1.1 bWAR. Bright side is Burly seems a lot better right now, making it less concerning of a comp.
Conclusion: Uh, I mean it’s a list designed to justify trading Burleson quite honestly. Most of them end up falling off very quickly. Josh Naylor is here, and I suppose we’ll see if he bounces back. But that’s kind of part of the problem: even if they remained good, they all spit out a dud season within a few years, most in their age 28 or 29 season!
Hunter Dobbins
Most similar: Cliff Bell
This would be an incredible outcome for Hunter Dobbins. Bell looks like a pretty good pitcher in the Negro Leagues, honestly far better than I think Dobbins could even become. But the low WAR total might be why. They did not play 162 games per season in the Negro Leagues, at least not on the official record.
Best outcome: Chase Anderson
If I knew more context of how good Bell was in comparison to his peers, I might have answered him. But I also wanted a more modern pitcher anyway for a good reference point. Dobbins has a 4 WAR season in his future on the Anderson path.
Worst outcome: Brandon Cumpton
Dobbins would throw in exactly one more game for the rest of his career if he followed Cumpton’s path.
Conclusion: Certainly some good outcomes here. It’s a varied list with two Negro League players, a player from the 1800s, and only four modern players. Ross Stripling would also be a good outcome, Nick Tropeano not so much.
Jose Fermin
Most similar: Greg Litton
On the one hand, Litton has a career year in his age 28 season, which would be a nice outcome for the Cardinals and Fermin. On the other hand, he played in just one more season after that, where he was below replacement level.
Best outcome: Joe Yeager
It was 1904, so the reason could have been tuberculosis or I had to chase an ambulance, tripped and broke my arm, but Yeager did not play at all at age 28 season. He was worth 6.4 bWAR the next three seasons after that, far exceeding anything anybody else did on this list.
Worst outcome: George Decker
I suppose this wouldn’t be the worst outcome for Jose Fermin because Decker played six more seasons in the MLB after his age 27 season. He was just a very bad player though. He was worth -1.1 bWAR in those six seasons in a surprisingly large amount of PAs, although he was also worth -0.8 bWAR prior, so he was never good at any point.
Conclusion
I mean based on this list, best case, Fermin has a fluky good year that he can’t repeat. Well there’s always the guy who played when spiking umps was a regular occurrence.
Ryan Fernandez
Most similar: Rich Croushore
That is not my favorite comparison. He might also be on the worst outcome list. Let’s find out!
Best outcome: Calvin Faucher
The best two outcomes I could find are also to be determined for career, so it might be slightly unfair. Faucher is still pitching and he wins because he has had two good seasons in the bullpen. Grant Anderson has had one good season.
Worst outcome: Take your pick
You want Croushore or Gene Stechschulte, who did not pitch after his age 28 season, a surprisingly common trait of pitchers compared to Ryan Fernandez. Like straight up their MLB career was done. Most barely had a career after even if they did pitch, like Croushore.
Conclusion
Well I know he didn’t have the most encouraging prospects, but I didn’t realize his career was on life support.
Gordon Graceffo
Most similar: Cole Sands
Sands is still pitching, but he didn’t have a particularly good 2025 and he had a bad 2026, the two seasons following his age 26 season. So I would not call this a great outcome.
Best outcome: Kevin Gregg
To be clear, if he mimicked Gregg, Graceffo won’t have a great 2027. But he bounced back the next season and ended up being a closer for about five years.
Worst outcome: Jonathan Hernandez
He is also still pitching in the majors, well maybe, he wasn’t good last year. But he has been below replacement level since his age 27 season. Although to be fair, he hasn’t actually a been a good pitcher since he had Tommy John surgery, which he got when he was 24. So I don’t think this comparison works for Graceffo.
Conclusion
Honestly, really good outcomes here. Nothing mind-blowing, but a few of the bad outcomes I felt weren’t very good comps in the first place because they didn’t have a good age 26 season.
Nolan Gorman
Most similar: Jurickson Profar
What a confusing one. Profar debuted young but took forever to adjust to the MLB. He’s been kind of up-and-down but once he adjusted, he’s been a pretty similar hitter with swings in BABIP. Gorman though is on a downward trajectory and strikes out about double Profar’s K rate.
Best outcome: Howard Johnson
By the way, this is like the opposite of Burleson. I don’t think B-R could quite figure out Gorman to be honest. Most of his comps had a very good age 26 season. I feel like that lowers my belief in these comparisons.
Worst outcome: Pedro Alvarez
Actually it’s probably Christopher Morel, but Alvarez was a lefty third baseman with huge swing and miss with questionable defense, so it felt like a much more apt comparison.
Conclusion
Well, you can tell similarity scores is not trying to project who will be similar in the future, and nowhere is that more true than Gorman’s similar players through age 26, who mostly had great years and would be incredible outcomes for Gorman: Miguel Vargas is here, Oneil Cruz, Ryan McMahon, Isaac Paredes, it’s a bizarrely good list.
Ivan Herrera
Most similar: Ke’Bryan Hayes
You heard it here first folks, Ivan Herrera can play 3B. I mean he’s being compared to Ke’Bryan Hayes, so naturally that means a Gold Glove is in his future.
Best outcome: Eric Soderholm
Also a 3B. This list is mostly 3B. I don’t understand. Good defensive 3B too. Is B-R trying to send a message to the Cardinals?
Worst outcome: Johnny Vergez
Yes, he was a 3B too. There are no catchers on this list. This is the weirdest one so far. Anyway, Vergez had a 3.3 bWAR season at 26, and then below replacement afterwards.
Conclusion
Well B-R has Herrera inputted as a good defensive 3B apparently, because Joe Crede and Tommy Edman are also here. Oh yeah and old nemesis Ty Wigginton is here too. I can’t be encouraged or discouraged, because literally everyone plays 3B on this list, making it confusing.
Kyle Leahy
Most similar: Keegan Thompson
I have a feeling there aren’t going to be many good comps to Leahy, because Thompson is certainly a bad one if you want to look at the future. Thompson wasn’t even starting when he was 29, the Cubs buried him in AAA for the entire year when he was 30, and he pitched 5 bad games for Colorado in 2026. I guess the rest of his career is to be determined.
Best outcome: Shigetoshi Hasegawa
Yeah, there are no starting pitchers in his most similar players, so none of these are all that comparable. But Hasegawa was a rather good reliever for several years, totaling 11.6 bWAR in his 9-year career, albeit 3.1 of it was in his age 29 season.
Worst outcome: Billy Muffett
I was wrong. He was a starter. It did not go well. In 1960 at age 29, he threw 125 innings, making 14 starts out of 23 games pitched. He was worth 3.1 bWAR. The next year, he was worth -1.9 bWAR in 112.2 innings and he threw 4 total innings after that in his career.
Conclusion
I mean you knew Leahy was a bad player for this kind of feature. He has just about zero players with his career path.
Matthew Liberatore
Most similar: Jonathan Sanchez
Oh yeah Liberatore is about to have a career year…. and then immediately break down and be out of baseball within a couple years after that. As long as they trade him, this would be a good outcome for the Cardinals.
Best outcome: Carl Pavano
Pretty easily too quite honestly. Except for the handedness, the comparison fits pretty well, though not perfect. Pavano was a bad pitcher through age 26 except for one random good year when he was 24. He was average at 27, and made an All-Star team at 28…. and then wasn’t actually good for another six years, mostly because he just didn’t pitch much at all.
Worst outcome: Mike Maroth
He is not actually the worst outcome, at least not technically. I mean to be clear, he is definitely a bad outcome. But he would not be my pick if he wasn’t worth -2.4 bWAR in 14 games for the Cardinals.
Conclusion: Reynaldo Lopez is also here, so I’ll just so that it’s about 50/50 whether not he has another good season in him based on the similarity score. But nobody is reliably good after age 26, it’s usually a season or two.
I wasn’t planning on making this a two-parter, but well I’m only halfway through and this thing is long enough already. I can’t promise the second part will be my next post, if the Cardinals make a trade or signing or even if I suddenly think of an idea I have to write, I’ll probably push it back. But if I’m sitting there Sunday night, and the Cardinals do nothing and I don’t get inspiration elsewhere, I’ll do the second part. What I’m saying is I’ll do the second part (he says, tempting fate)
Book corner
I really expected to have Crime and Punishment finished by now, and I am about 40 pages away, and if it wasn’t late already, I’d just power through those 40 pages to write something here. But that would be unwise for my sleep. So I’m going to use this space for something I really wasn’t intending to use it for, since it involves my own writing.
I am attempting to write a book. Know the rough outlines of my plot, I know my hook, and I have my main character relatively well sketched out. But something happens and without getting into any specifics, they hear a sound nobody else can hear from three different locations, all varying in how close they sound. I had the idea that they could create a formula based on their estimation of how close the sound was in each instance, and triangulate the likely location of that sound.
First off, is that even possible? My instinct was yes, so long as you ascribe some numerical value to the sound. And then you would need to know what I imagine is a complicated formula and then using that formula, you get that classic scene in movies where they draw a big circle over an area where it is, but you don’t actually know where within that circle the sound is coming from. So I need my main character to know how to do that. The easiest solution to this is just make the main character have a job where knowing complicated mathematical formulas is required, whether through schooling or for the actual job. My main character will be recently fresh out of graduate school, so if it’s a job that requires a lot of schooling, that will work.
So basically, what kind of profession can I give them to have them believably do something like this? And hey if what I’m describing is basically impossible, what profession would be foolish enough to think this would work, because I do have a workaround if this isn’t possible. Actually now that I’m thinking about it, I kind of like the idea of it not working a little, because it would be kind of funny if they do all this, have an “I got it” moment, and then learn the real location later, and just go “wow I was way off.” So that’s an option too.













