Every week I solicit questions in the feed. Sometimes, I get a question so good that I want to spend 1200+ words diving into it. This is one of those weeks.
Was UFC 334 the worst Madison Square Garden card of all time?
Was that the worst MSG card of all time? Other than a few highlights (the Wonderboy KO, and the hilarity that was the co main), I was personally pretty bored for the entirety of that card. And I really hated the main event, which I feel I might be on an island with that take, but I just really didn’t enjoy it at all. As always, I did enjoy rewatching
your watch party afterwards though, thanks for that!
I think it’s safe to say you are on an island with your main event take. No one should call that an all-time great fight, but it was generally decent, and it was certainly exciting. I think most people had a good time watching it.
Your other question is more interesting. Madison Square Garden has become a yearly trip for the UFC, usually presented as one of the marquee events of the year, and this was the 10th trip to the World’s Most Famous Arena. While I found the main event fun, and the co-main event funny, the main card of UFC 334 did feel like a bit of a slog — probably because of the long breaks for the low blows — and so, reflexively, this feels like one of the lesser MSG outings.
So, let’s take a trip back to the other cards and rank the 10 UFC-MSG events! While ranking them, I will primarily focus on the main cards, but close decisions may be swayed by the strength of the undercards, too.
1. UFC 205 — Nov. 12, 2016
The one that started it all remains the gold standard for MSG cards. Conor McGregor made history by becoming the fight champ-champ in the UFC, Tyron Woodley and Stephen Thompson had their epic draw, and Joanna Jedrzejczyk stacked another title defense to her Hall of Fame career. Also, Yoel Romero nuked Chris Weidman, and this event was the famous start of the legend of Khabib Nurmagomedov, who begged Michael Johnson to surrender while beating the brakes off of him, then cut one of the most iconic promos in MMA history. “I want to fight with your chicken!”
2. UFC 217 — Nov. 4, 2017
This is an ignominious start to the list, as the first two years were the best, meaning it’s been all downhill ever since. But also, like 205, this card was insane. Georges St-Pierre returning and winning the middleweight title by tapping Michael Bisping, T.J. Dillashaw reclaiming the bantamweight title by smoking his friend-turned-rival, Rose Namajunas ending the reign of Joanna Champion; a bunch of cool, important stuff happened here.
3. UFC 281 — Nov. 12, 2022
A close third to 217, 281 was also a historic and significant event. Alex Pereira knocked out Israel Adesanya in the fifth round to claim his first UFC title, Zhang Weili bodied Carla Esparza to reclaim the strawweight belt and start her career-defining championship reign, Dustin Poirier and Michael Chandler put on one of the best fights of the year, and Frankie Edgar got retired by Chris Gutierrez. This card also has a better prelim card than 217, but the lack of a third title fight keeps it from winning the silver medal.
4. UFC 268 — Nov. 6, 2021
Kamaru Usman vs. Colby Covington 2 headlined this event, which was a bad-blood fight that ended up being an excellent title fight, and the rematch between Rose Namajunas and Zhang Weili in the co-main event was even more competitive. Plus, the main card opened with the 2021 Fight of the Year between Justin Gaethje and Michael Chandler. Oh, and Chito Vera kicked Frankie Edgar in the face, and Poatan made his UFC debut, too.
5. UFC 295 — Nov. 1, 2023
Depending on how heavily you value finishes, this could be higher, as all five main card fights ended in stoppages. The main event was Poatan bolting Jiri Prochazka for the first time, the co-main event was Tom Aspinall winning his interim heavyweight title by running over Sergei Pavlovich, and Jessica Andrade, Benoit Saint Denis, and Diego Lopes all scored KOs, too.
6. UFC 322 — Nov. 15, 2025
There’s a pretty clear tier break between the best MSG cards ever, and we’re now on the other side of the tracks. 322 looked great on paper, and it was MASSIVELY significant historically, but anyone who watched the main card probably didn’t love the ending, as Islam Makhachev won his second title with a dominant-but-boring decision over Jack Della Maddalena, and Valentina Shevchenko similarly smothered Zhang Weili in the co-main event. But the lead-in fights were all sick KOs from Michael Morales, Carlos Prates, and BSD, so all in all, not a terrible card.
7. UFC 334 — Nov. 14, 2026
And this is where I settled on for UFC 334 in the MSG rankings. Was this card great? No. But it was decent enough, and it certainly had a few significant things happen. As mentioned above, the main event was a very fun fight (for most people), and the co-main event was among the most significant women’s MMA fights ever. The rest of the main card was a stone-cold drag, but this gets a little bit of bonus points for Wonderboy’s splendid swan song in the final prelim bout.
8. UFC 230 — Nov. 3, 2018
The remainder of the MSG cards on this list are pretty weak, and they all struggle in particular from a lack of meaningful fights on the cards. This is the best of the bunch, with Cormier making a weak-but-acceptable heavyweight title defense over Derrick Lewis in the main event, and … not much else. Jacare, Jared Cannonier, and Israel Adesanya all get stoppages on the main card, though, and that’s still more fun than what’s to come.
9. UFC 244 — Nov. 2, 2019
It’s kind of fitting that the BMF title’s debut went so poorly, because that’s really been the story of the title: kind of fun in concept, but mostly cheap and sometimes not all that fun. Masvidal beating the brakes off Nate Diaz only to get a cut stoppage soured the whole thing for most fans, and the limited action before the main event makes this one a contender for worst MSG card ever. But one card somehow managed to beat out the card that had Derrick Lewis vs. Blagoy Ivanov on it.
10. UFC 309 — Nov. 16, 2024
Not only was this card a horrible slog to watch, I think it might have broken MMA.
Jon Jones’ “title defense” against Stipe Miocic is one of the most shambolic title fights in MMA history. The man had not fought in over three years, hadn’t won in four, and was a 42-year-old retiree who hobbled when he walked. That the UFC passed over an interim champion to do this fight a year later was unconscionable, and then, to cap it all off, the fight was bad. Miocic was a shell of his prime self, and Jones still didn’t even look good himself. The UFC threw out reason, honor, and meritocracy to feed us a useless, garbage fight, which also then allowed Jones to hold the heavyweight title hostage for another seven months.
And if that wasn’t enough, the fight capped off one of the most forgettable main cards of the year. Charles Oliveira and Michael Chandler had a scrap that was mostly uninteresting until Chandler started cheating in the fifth round, and I’ll Venmo you a quarter if you can tell me any of the other results from the main card.
So, there you have it: the definitive ranking of UFC cards at Madison Square Garden.
Feel free to disagree in the comments.
Thanks for reading, and thank you to everyone who sent in questions! Do you have any burning questions about things at least somewhat related to combat sports? Then you’re in luck, because every week I put a prompt into The Feed for your questions. Fire them there, and I’ll answer the best ones in the Mailbag and try to get to the rest in the responses.













