Northwestern was embarrassed on its home floor on Friday. DePaul came into Welsh-Ryan Arena and left with a 67-47 win. It was the ‘Cats’ first loss to DePaul in almost seven years.
After massive roster turnover, center Luke McEldon taking a leave of absence and a 3-0 start, there were a lot of questions surrounding Northwestern. I wondered how the team would mesh, whether the personnel on the roster was good enough to compete and how real the start was. Well, a lot of answers came out of this beatdown.
Live and die by Jake West
The sophomore guard was all anybody could talk about entering this season, and for good reason. West provided a great deal of hope for the Northwestern faithful at the end of last season, and he has lived up to those expectations thus far.
In every single outing this season, West has scored 20 points with very strong efficiency. He has been the go-to guy for head coach Chris Collins. He has even been a strong playmaker for the ‘Cats, averaging 6.8 assists per game.
Against DePaul, however, West went 7-for-17 from the field, 2-for-7 from beyond the arc and turned the ball over three times while recording just one assist. Still, he finished with 20 points, 42.6% of Northwestern’s scoring.
Here’s the bottom line: if West isn’t performing, the ‘Cats aren’t winning.
West needs to be scoring efficiently every game while being the primary facilitator, creating easy offense for everyone else. If he is even remotely off that expectation, there is close to a 0% chance that Northwestern will add to its win column, as no other player on the roster has shown that ability to step up and lead the offense.
The lack of continuity matters
Northwestern had just six assists against DePaul. It also had 14 turnovers.
The offense is stagnant and clunky. There is no structure, and Collins is struggling to implement an effective system. This is largely due to a lack of chemistry on the roster.
With only three returning players, it was expected that the team would take time to get going. But what hasn’t helped that transition is that none of the transfers, except guard LA Pratt, have shown signs of consistent output. Returners Angelo Ciaravino and Phoenix Gill have shown clear signs of improvement on both sides of the ball, but I can’t say the same for the transfers.
Forward Jack Karasinski unfortunately had to go through concussion protocol, making his transition slower than usual. Forward/center Okku Federiko clearly was not ready to start and has not been making a substantial impact down low. Center Ryan Soulis and forward Colin Smith put up a combined stat line of 0 points, 0 rebounds, one assist and one turnover.
Coupling all this with freshman center Simon Ghai getting minutes due to his size, and freshman forward Jayden Hodge eventually returning, it seems like the team will not find any sort of identity anytime soon.
Big Ten competition won’t be close
Last season, the Wildcats won five conference games. I would be beyond surprised if the ‘Cats match that number this season.
Northwestern’s squad last year was far more talented than this year’s, and it had the ability to punch above its weight class. That seems unlikely this year.
Collins is relying on unproven talent from mid-major schools that have never faced competition as fierce as what exists in the Big Ten. The weight of the team rests on the shoulders of West, and if he struggles the way he did against DePaul, the offense will not score.
Furthermore, the lack of size and physicality will make it impossible for Northwestern to be imposing in the paint or win the rebounding battle on the defensive side of the ball.
The ‘Cats will struggle mightily against the majority of the conference, and games against Penn State, Oregon and Rutgers will be dogfights to avoid being at the bottom of the standings.













