The Jacksonville Jaguars will be the best team the New York Giants have faced this season when the teams meet on Sunday. Let’s learn more about the Jaguars in this week’s ‘5 questions’ segment. Gus Logue of SB Nation’s Big Cat Country provides our answers.
Ed: The Jaguars, obviously, went all-in to improve the roster at the trade deadline. After going 13-4 a season and being that aggressive at the deadline, has this become a year where anything less than a Super Bowl appearance makes the season a disappointment?
Gus: At this point, anything less than a Super Bowl victory would be disappointing for the 2026 Jaguars. The new regime has been “strategically bold,” making aggressive and unorthodox moves to bolster a well-balanced roster that already boasts a great
quarterback and an even better coaching staff. Jags fans appreciate that the team is genuinely trying to win it all, especially after so many seasons in the gutter, rather than letting this opportunity slip by. Jacksonville’s moves at the trade deadline do fall in the “win now” bucket but I wouldn’t necessarily categorize it as an “all-in” approach. The Jaguars will be contenders for the next several seasons — not just for 2026.
Ed: If I gave you the option of taking Trevor Lawrence or any other current quarterback in the NFL, would you keep Lawrence? If not, who would you take?
Gus: I would definitely take Patrick Mahomes. A few other quarterbacks can match his playmaking ability from both inside and outside the pocket, but nobody does it like him in clutch moments. Josh Allen and a healthy Lamar Jackson would probably still clear Lawrence, but if I were tiering quarterbacks, I’d have a “Zeus” category for Mahomes, an “Olympians” category for Allen, Jackson, Lawrence, Joe Burrow, Drake Maye, and Caleb Williams, and maybe a “demigods” tier for guys like Jaxson Dart and J.J. McCarthy who have shown special flashes but aren’t yet considered football deities. I have zero qualms with how Lawrence is playing the position right now.
Ed: If you could take one player off the Giants’ roster and put him into Jacksonville’s lineup, who would it be? Why?
Gus: The idea of Malik Nabers in Liam Coen’s offense makes me salivate, and the thought of Arvell Reese in Anthony Campanile’s defense gives me goosebumps. I might’ve said Jevon Holland before Jacksonville traded for Jessie Bates III last week. Andrew Thomas would probably be the responsible choice. But I will go with Abdul Carter, who would arguably provide the most game-changing plays for Jacksonville. Josh Hines-Allen and Travon Walker already occupy the starting edge positions, and the team is looking forward to second-year pro B.J. Green II returning from injured reserve, but another pass rusher could not hurt. Once the team starts seeing elite quarterbacks each week in January, it’d be handy to have a guy like Carter.
Ed: Tell us about one offensive and one defensive player Giants fans should be paying attention to on Sunday?
Gus: On offense, look out for Parker Washington. This kid isn’t just a fun little success story as a former sixth-round pick who first carved out a role on special teams. At least not anymore. Washington has blossomed into a borderline top-10 NFL wide receiver and the unquestioned engine of Jacksonville’s offense. The Penn State product will be more widely recognized in the tri-state area after this weekend. On the other side of the ball, look out for fourth-year linebacker Ventrell Miller. The former Gator has filled in wonderfully after offseason 2025 Pro Bowler Devin Lloyd departed in the offseason. Miller plays like a missile against the run.
Ed: What is the Jaguars Kryptonite? On offense? Defense? If the Giants are going to win the game, how and what do they need to attack?
Gus: The Jaguars’ biggest weakness is its offensive line. It’s been a “good enough” unit for most of the season, but the teams that pose the biggest threat to Jacksonville are those with a dominant front four that controls the line of scrimmage. If you can shut down the Jaguars’ running game and constantly heat up Lawrence, you’ll have a shot. On defense, the Jaguars allow the lowest EPA/play on short passes (-0.23) and the fifth-lowest mark on intermediate passes (-0.1), but they rank sixth-worst against deep passes (+0.82). Bates was brought in to help clean that up, and Travis Hunter gets better every week, but Jacksonville has to do a better job of limiting explosive passes — even if they’re not allowing many such attempts in the first place. The Jaguars have the horses to contain Cam Skattebo but they should be wary of Nabers and New York’s front seven.













