Predictions are one of the most fun ways to deal with a lack of baseball. Don’t have any baseball to watch? Imagine what it will look like when you do! This is especially true for those of us tasked with writing about the sport. At a certain point in the offseason, there’s very little left to say about the season past, so you have to start imagining what might happen next. That content isn’t going to make itself!
But you all trust us to be good at predictions. It’s worth noting that this doesn’t mean
being accurate at predictions. If we could all predict with a high degree of accuracy what was going to occur in an upcoming season, we’d trade our Pop-Tarts for Lamborghinis. So, rather than accuracy, we shoot for fun. Certainly, that’s what Max Rieper was going for when he made 10 bold predictions in January and when Cullen Jekel made his 26 oddly specific predictions in March. Jacob and I also made some bold predictions on the Royals Rundown podcast, and then discussed them shortly after the regular season ended.
We’ll get those more off-the-wall predictions shortly, but first let’s address the more boilerplate predictions from Opening Day:
Royals predictions
All of us but Trenton got the Best Royals hitter right, but only Jacob Milham was wise enough to avoid the oft-injured Cole Ragans and Kris Bubic in his pitcher prediction and therefore got it right with Michael Wacha. Even the most bearish among us, Matthew LaMar, couldn’t get the Royals’ record nearly right. And only 0.4% of fans guessed the Royals would win fewer than 70 games. They, of course, ultimately won 69. (Nice?) 90.7% of you agreed Bobby Witt Jr. would be the guy on the position player side, but only 6.6% imagined Wacha could lead the pitching staff. 55.9% voted for Ragans.
American League
This was a veritable prediction bloodbath. Not a single one of us correctly predicted the AL East or AL Central winners. Only Matthew LaMar picked the Astros to win the West. Cullen Jekel, Matthew, Kevin Ruprecht, and I correctly predicted the Yankees would win the first Wild Card. I was the only one to successfully predict the Red Sox for the second Wild Card. Not one of us suggested the White Sox might reach the playoffs in any shape or form.
It wasn’t much better amongst y’all, though. 41.1% picked the Blue Jays to win the East; only 0.9% gave the Rays a chance. 56.9% picked the Royals to win the Central; 3.9% thought the Guardians had a shot. 84.6% agreed the Mariners would win the West; you only gave the Astros 7.5% odds.
You did better with the Wild Cards; the Yankees got 54.6% odds, the Red Sox 44.8%. But the White Sox only collected 0.9% odds, the worst in the AL.
Matthew LaMar was, once again, the only one to believe the Royals would miss the postseason.
National League
I was SO close with my division winners. Jacob Milham and Connor Moylan made the same predictions I did and were equally right in selecting the Brewers to win the Central and the Dodgers to win the West. The Phillies were in serious competition for the East for a while, but the Mets were not, so Trenton Kraxner falls to fourth place in success here.
Unfortunately, I didn’t get a single Wild Card team right. Trenton somehow predicted the Padres to be both the first and third Wild Cards, so that’s fun. Max was the only one who thought the Cubs could be Wild Card winners. The closest were probably Matthew and Bradford Lee because they correctly imagined the Padres would grab the first Wild Card and the Phillies the last one.
Fans did pretty well here with their top six all correctly making the postseason, though they flipped Philadelphia and Atlanta.
AL Awards
More digital red ink here. Neither Carter Jensen nor Kazuma Okamoto even made the top three in Rookie of the Year Voting. Among the guesses for AL Cy Young, only Jacob’s prediction of Dylan Cease made the top 3. We did better with MVP as Bobby made the top three but only as a distant third. And Aaron Judge was nowhere to be seen after his injury issue this year.
It wasn’t any better among the fans. None of the finalists for Cy Young got a significant percentage of the vote. 5.4% of you picked Kevin McGonigle and while Junior Caminero and Yordan Alvarez didn’t appear in the votes, Bobby Witt Jr. was a heavy favorite.
NL Awards
The predictions are starting to feel like the TV aisle on Black Friday. Once again, no one got the MVP right. Those of us who predicted Shohei at least got someone in the top 3, but that’s it. Only Bradford got anywhere close on the Cy Young. And, again, we did a little better in the Rookie of the Year as Cullen, Trenton, Jacob, and Max all correctly guessed Wetherholt. But the rest of us didn’t get close.
Remarkably, you all mostly picked the same as I did. Neither PCA nor The Mis showed up in a sufficient percentage of your ballots to be listed, and Wetherholt was your third choice with 13.6% of you thinking he would get the nod.
World Series Predictions
Just call us Dr. Strangelove because we have learned to stop worrying and love the bomb.
None of us correctly predicted either of the pennant winners. Each of us picked at least one team to make the World Series that didn’t even make the playoffs, except for Jacob Milham, who picked ATL over NYY. And neither of those two teams made it out of their respective Division Series and looked awful while they were there.
You all didn’t do any better! 72.7% thought the World Series parade would feature either Royal or Dodger blue.
OK, we knew those were all going to be very wrong. What about…
Max’s ten bold predictions
The Royals will trade for Jarren Duran
That obviously didn’t happen. And, to be honest, I think I’m happier that way? In Max’s prediction, the Royals would have given up Noah Cameron and Blake Mitchell. As bad as Duran was last year, he would have made everything worse. Mitchell still has value as a trade chip, and Noah Cameron had a very strong finish to the season that gives me a lot of hope for his future.
The Royals will have a six-man rotation for some of the year
The Royals could barely put together a four-man rotation for much of the season. Six was entirely out of the question.
Vinnie Pasquantino makes his first All-Star Game
I thought this was a good call on Max’s part, but between another slow start and his hamate injury, it absolutely wasn’t in the cards. Maybe next season!
Jac Caglianone hits 30 home runs
Listen, I pegged him for at least 35. I would have taken the over on this all day long. Unfortunately, he didn’t always get the ball in the air enough and also had a slow start, so he finished the season with 23. It was a good season, and I’d expect him to easily eclipse this next year – if healthy – but it didn’t work out this time.
The bullpen becomes a problem again
Oh man, with the benefit of hindsight, this hardly even seems bold, but even Max could not have imagined how bad it would get. He thought it would be bad enough to necessitate midseason moves, and while I suppose he was technically right, I don’t think trading for Connor Thomas and Nolan Hoffman just to slow the bleeding was what he had in mind.
The Royals have two pitchers on top 50 prospect lists
He missed this one, but not by much. Kendry Chourio is a consensus top-50 pitcher, but outlets are still gun-shy on David Shields. The Royals did add multiple position players, depending on the outlet, to the top 100. So the farm system still looks much better than it did at this time last year.
The Royals win the Central Division
Nope.
Carter Jensen finishes second in Rookie of the Year voting
He’s second in my book. If I had my way, rookie hitters and pitchers would be separated since their jobs make it so hard to compare them. But ultimately, Carter did come in fourth due to some slow stretches and really outstanding performances that were a bit more high-profile ahead of him.
Kansas City announces a Washington Square Park ballpark
Technically, the Royals won’t be building the stadium in Washington Square Park, but it is a part of their larger ballpark village setup. I’d give him a green check for this one.
Two out of ten isn’t bad when you’re trying to be bold!
Cullen’s 26 oddly specific predictions
This ought to be interesting.
The Royals will win their first game of the season in their second game before taking the series from Atlanta that Sunday.
Coulda, woulda, shoulda. This was a game the Royals led by two and saw Carlos Estévez blow in spectacular fashion in his only big-league appearance of the season.
Maikel Garcia will hit the first home run of the year for the Royals in his first at-bat of the second game of the season.
Maikel’s first dinger didn’t come until game number nine.
The Royals will finish the regular season 2-4 against the Yankees, with one victory coming on April 18 in New York and the other occurring on May 26 in Kansas City.
The Royals, for the second straight season, were completely swept by the Yankees.
On June 17, Lucas Erceg will officially supplant Carlos Estévez as the team’s closer.
Unfortunately, it did not take that long. In fact, Erceg not only supplanted Estévez well before then, but he’d already been replaced in turn by Alex Lange at that point. Erceg’s final save was June 7, but Lange was already the primary closer by June 3. Erceg got the save that day because Lange had pitched too many games in a row.
I’d be willing to give this to him on a technicality if he had said “by June 17” but I guess that wouldn’t have been oddly specific.
On July 2, during a home game against the Tampa Rays, Salvador Perez will hit career home run #318, surpassing George Brett as the Royals’ all-time home run leader. The home run will come against pitcher Garrett Cleavinger.
Salvy ended up hitting 318 off of Kyle Finnegan in Detroit on July 25.
With the No. 6 pick in the draft, the Royals will select Tyler Spangler, SS, De La Salle (Concord, California).
Spangler ended up going to the Phillies with pick 26 in the first round.
These five Royals will make the All-Star game: Bobby Witt Jr., Cole Ragans, Maikel Garcia, Lucas Erceg, and Vinnie Pasquantino.
One out of five isn’t bad…
Before the trade deadline, the Royals will trade two pitchers who have started at least one game for them between 2025 and 2026, and neither of those pitchers will be Kris Bubic.
Unfortunately for Cullen, Kris Bubic was the only pitcher the Royals traded at the deadline.
On August 1, the Royals will lose to the Colorado Rockies.
He got this one right; it was the middle game of the sweep in Coors.
Cole Ragans will throw his second career complete game on August 4 against the Minnesota Twins.
Cole might not have even begun rehab on his elbow at that point.
In 2025, the Royals were shut out 15 times while shutting out their opponent 10 times. In 2026, the Royals will be shut out 10 times while shutting out their opponent 15 times.
The Royals were shut out eight times and shut their opponent out seven times.
Starling Marte will appear in exactly 100 games.
Marte appeared in 59 games. He did accrue 153 at-bats, though.
Eight Royals will finish the season with at least 10 home runs.
I’m not sure if that counts as oddly specific enough, but he was still wrong. Only seven Royals managed the feat.
Seth Lugo will lead the team in innings pitched with 193-and-1/3.
Lugo had 172.1; Wacha had 200.2.
In 2025, the Royals bizarrely managed to finish 26-26 against fellow American League Central teams. In 2026, against those same opponents, the Royals will finish 33-19 (11-2 against Chicago, 7-6 against Cleveland, 6-7 against Detroit, and 9-4 against Minnesota).
He got the record against the Guardians right; they were 8-5 against the Twins; 7-6 against the Tigers, and 4-9 vs the White Sox. Needless to say, the overall record was way off.
The Royals will win the American League Central by one game.
Nope.
The Royals hit 159 home runs in 2025, ahead of only four other teams. The Royals will increase that total to 183 home runs in 2026, led by…
They hit 170, which was an increase, but not by enough.
Jac Caglianone, who will knock 35 homers.
Nope.
Matt Quatraro will be named a finalist for American League Manager of the Year, but will not win.
Absolutely not.
Carter Jensen will finish second in voting for American League Rookie of the Year.
Not quite.
Cole Ragans will finish second in the American League in strikeouts with 216.
If only…
He will also finish second in the American League Cy Young voting.
OK, this is just getting sad.
Vinnie Pasquantino will capture his first Silver Slugger.
That honor goes to Pete Alonso.
Bobby Witt Jr. will record his third career 30-30 season with 33 home runs and 31 stolen bases.
18 and 45
He will also finally win his first American League MVP award.
So close.
The Royals will end their 2026 season on the road with a two-run loss.
They miraculously won 3-2.
Well, just like the Royals, we all have very little direction to move except up. Here’s hoping for a brighter 2027!













