The Vegas Golden Knights made the decision over the weekend to fire head coach Bruce Cassidy and replace him with John Tortorella with eight games remaining in the regular season.
On the surface, it might be surprising to some. After all, Cassidy is one of the best head coaches in the entire league. Cassidy won a Stanley Cup with the Golden Knights back in 2023. He has a long track record of success dating back to his days in Boston, as do the Golden Knights since they came into the league. The Golden Knights currently
sit in third place in the Pacific division and should comfortably be a playoff team with just under ten games remaining.
For most organizations, that would be good enough as we head into the final few weeks of the regular season.
The Vegas Golden Knights aren’t most organizations.
Since the day they entered the league, they have operated with a ‘win at all costs’ mentality. It doesn’t matter who their coach is or what he has done there. The coach is as disposable as a tissue if they’re not winning. It doesn’t matter who their players are. It doesn’t matter if Marc-Andre Fleury is a fan favorite Vezina trophy winner. If Vegas can upgrade in net, they will try to do so. If they can swing a trade for Mark Stone, Jack Eichel, Tomas Hertl, Noah Hanifin, or Rasmus Andersson, they’ll do it. If they can sign a Mitch Marner or Alex Pietrangelo, they won’t hesitate. Perhaps just as importantly, they don’t let sentimentality get in the way when it comes to holding onto longtime original Misfits like Reilly Smith (who has since returned to Vegas at a discount) and Jonathan Marchessault, among others. Vegas is as ruthless and cold-hearted when it comes to personnel decisions as it gets.
Some might ask what’s the point of firing the coach with eight games left in the regular season. But if you’ve already decided as an organization that you’re going to move on once the season ends anyways, why would you wait to lose to the Oilers in six games in the first round of the playoffs to do so? Wouldn’t you make a change now just to see if you can light a fire under the team just in time for the most important games of the season?
How’s this for a novel concept…..wouldn’t you try to save your season?
It might not be the most people-friendly way of treating your own to just discard them when they’re deemed to be no longer useful when it comes to achieving your goals. But the Vegas Golden Knights have shown time and time again that they don’t care about your feelings. This isn’t summer camp where we all get a participation ribbon. It’s an environment that might rub some the wrong way and might not always work, and in this instance with Tortorella replacing Cassidy, it very well might not work. Heck, this approach has only worked once in eight seasons for the Golden Knights where they’ve won a championship.
But like it or not, that’s the high standard that Vegas has set for themselves and the culture they’ve built in their short time in the league. The standard is to win, and if you’re not helping to achieve that goal, you won’t be around for very long. If they can find someone who is better equipped to help them win, they won’t hesitate to pull the trigger and make that change. And if it does work out and they do win? Flags fly forever. See you at the parade at the Las Vegas Strip. The end justified the means.
Part of what makes the Golden Knights the Golden Knights is knowing that good enough isn’t actually good enough. Hoping things just magically get better and doing nothing isn’t a strategy, and they’re not going to just settle. It’s not good enough that they lost three in a row and six of seven before making the coaching change. It’s not good enough that at this point of the season that they barely have more points than the Devils do. It’s not good enough that Edmonton, their most likely playoff opponent in the first round, has had their number. Vegas has lost 9 of their last 10 to the Oilers, including playoffs, dating back to last season. Going from Cassidy to Tortorella might not work out, but at least they’re trying to do something to flip the script. They know they only have a limited number of kicks at the can with their core. Punting seasons for no good reason isn’t acceptable.
There will come a day where Vegas continuing to trade futures won’t work. Where signing a big free agent won’t extend their window. Where making a coaching change won’t bail them out because the roster is what it is. There will be a day where the entire house of cards that the Golden Knights are built upon collapses. They will have to do a much dreaded rebuild, and the rest of the league will show no sympathy towards them when it comes to paying them back on the ice after Vegas was on or near the top of the league for so long. Heck, its possible they’re already at that point and they’re in denial.
But the Golden Knights clearly don’t think they’re at that point yet.
They’re operating with a sense of urgency that we don’t see most teams operate with by channeling their inner Lou Lamoriello and replacing a head coach with a handful of games remaining in the regular season. They hold their own accountable, at every level. That ‘win at all costs’ approach is who Vegas is as an organization.
By the way, I’m using the words I’m using to describe Vegas for a reason. Words like ‘culture’, ‘identity’, ‘standard’, ‘accountable’ and ‘urgency’. Because when people think of the Golden Knights, what do they associate with them? Winning, first and foremost, but also, doing whatever it takes to win.
Must be nice.
So why am I waxing poetic about the Golden Knights on a Devils-centric blog?
For starters, I do admire their conviction in their beliefs and their willingness to not just accept their fate and blame injuries or bad luck. I respect that they operate in the manner they do, and I’m not ashamed to admit that I wish the Devils were more cutthroat chasing what should be the ultimate goal, which is winning a championship.
I’m not entirely sure I even agree with the decision to fire Cassidy for Tortorella. Yes, both of them are Stanley Cup championship winning coaches. I don’t know that I consider Cassidy to be the problem though when most of their issues are goaltending, shooting, and PDO related. In fact, I consider Cassidy to be one of the three or four best coaches in the league, to the point where there should be a bunch of teams holding meetings this week discussing whether or not they should fire their current coach immediately to hire Cassidy. I do think Vegas as an organization could use a kick in the pants though, and there’s probably not a better coach to do that in the short-term and get the attention of the room than John Tortorella, so from that standpoint, I get why they made this particular change.
More importantly, I respect how aggressive they are to try to achieve their goals. I respect the sense of urgency with which they operate. Why sit around and wait until the trade deadline to go get Rasmus Andersson when you can get him in January? Why go into the playoffs as flat as any team in the league when there’s a chance you get the coaching bump from Tortorella screaming at everyone and go on a run?
Some might argue that this is a panic move or an act of desperation on the part of the Golden Knights. And perhaps it is to some extent. But it also says something about who you are when you can look in the mirror and admit that what you’re doing isn’t working. If you know what you’re doing isn’t going to work, why are you continuing to do it?
That’s not desperation. That’s reading the room, seeing things aren’t going as you expected, being honest with yourself in your self-assessment, reacting with new information that has since been presented to you, and doing something to try to fix it before its too late and you threw a season away for no good reason.
Again, must be nice.
How many times have we, as Devils fans, sat around on these forums over the years and complained about the Devils not doing enough? How many times have we complained about Tom Fitzgerald sitting on his hands and not doing anything? How many times have we been told to be patient? That there’s no coaching change coming. No trades. How many times have excuses been made for why the Devils aren’t doing more, whether it’s because the team is capped out, injured, or both. How many times have the Devils refused to even so much as go and call someone up from Utica just to see if they can create a spark. How many times have we begged for scraps from top Devils brass over the years only to be given nothing?
If the roles were reversed and the Devils operated with the same standard and same urgency that Vegas does, does anyone think Tom Fitzgerald survives this season when someone above him looks at the mess he created? Would an organization like Vegas tolerate some of the terrible contracts handed out and massive draft misses that have happened under Fitzgerald’s watch?
Does anyone think Sheldon Keefe survives the season when the Devils are going through their prolonged stretch where they can’t score? Or do the Devils make a change sometime in December or January when the season was still salvageable….not unlike what Buffalo or Columbus did when those organizations fired their GM and head coach, respectively. Not unlike what Vegas is trying to do now with Tortorella.
Do you think the Golden Knights would tolerate keeping Dave Rogalski continually employed for six plus years despite no actual positive results from any of the goaltenders?
Do you think the Golden Knights, a team that has manipulated the salary cap and found loopholes more than any other team to find a way to squeeze every last dollar under the cap, would’ve unnecessarily paid Evgenii Dadonov a $250K bonus that gets charged to next year’s cap when Dadonov has done nothing and every penny matters? Or would they have said tough luck and played some rando from their AHL affiliate instead?
I think we all know the answer to those questions.
Instead, we have what we have with the Devils. A country club atmosphere where people remain in their positions for years and years despite the lack of on-ice success. That’s the culture the Devils have fostered in the post-Lou Lamoriello era. One where the Devils ‘identity’ is a jumbled mess in part because the GM had steered the roster away from what they were building. One where there is zero sense of urgency from the top down when things are going poorly. One where the Devils are content to sit on their hands while playing poorly for months on end. One where the Devils still have no answers for the Carolina problem that has plagued them for years.
One where winning, while it would be nice, isn’t the highest priority.
That’s the difference between a team that is serious about winning and one that isn’t.
At the end of the day, we’re asking for the bare minimum here from ownership and management. We want to watch a competitive hockey team that has a realistic chance of winning. And when we’re not getting that, we want to know that the people in charge are at least aware of the problem. That they give a damn about this team as much as we do as fans. That they’re not just content to see how things go or see if they can work their way out of this. I don’t pretend to have all the answers, but I also know doing nothing and expecting the problem to fix itself isn’t a plan.
