There are a few indelible, memorable scenes and events that define left-hander Ted Lilly’s three and a half seasons with the Chicago Cubs.
The first is how he came to the Cubs in the first place. After a 96-loss season in 2006 and the hiring of Lou Piniella as manager, general manager Jim Hendry apparently had a mandate to bring some big-name free agents to the team — not only for a better team, but to position the team to be sold for a higher price, as Tribune Company itself had been sold and had to divest
some of its assets, notably the Cubs.
In November 2006, Hendry made a splash by signing Alfonso Soriano to what is to this day still the highest total dollar figure contract ever given to a Cub — $184 million.
Then Lilly was added — literally while Hendry was on a hospital gurney:
Hendry was to introduce Tim Wilken at the Scout of the Year banquet, but Piniella and others in the Cubs’ front office finally convinced the GM to go to a local hospital. Hendry said no to an ambulance, so Piniella drove him, along with Scott Nelson, who was the Cubs’ director of baseball operations at the time.
Hendry underwent an EKG, and thought that was it. He got dressed and made some phone calls, but the doctor wanted to do another EKG. Hendry offered to come back the next morning. The doctor said the GM might not make it to the next day.
O’Brien, unaware of what was happening, called Hendry, who was still on the gurney, hooked up to the EKG machine. Hendry said the Cubs’ final offer for Lilly was four years and $40 million. O’Brien’s response: “We’ve got a deal.”
“I don’t know why to this day I was hooked up on the gurney and had the phone in my hand,” Hendry said this week, recalling the incident. “The story is more heroic than reality. I did not know when I took the phone call from Larry O’Brien that I was going to have this potentially life or death surgery an hour later 30 miles away.”
So that was fun. Lilly put together the best year of his career in 2007, going 15-8 with a 3.83 ERA, 1.140 WHIP and a career-high 174 strikeouts.
The Cubs lost Game 1 of the 2007 NLDS to the Diamondbacks at Chase Field and sent Lilly out to start Game 2. The Cubs took a 2-0 lead in the top of the second on a home run by Geovany Soto. In the bottom of the inning, Lilly allowed a single and walk, then struck out former Cub Augie Ojeda. D-backs pitcher Doug Davis sacrificed the runners up a base, bringing up Chris Young. Lilly ran the count full on Young and then…
Young hit a three-run homer and Lilly was… not happy about it, obviously. This was the indelible image of that postseason series. Arizona won the game 8-4 and finished the Cubs off in Game 3 at Wrigley Field.
Lilly had another good year in 2008 but was not used in the postseason. In 2009, he had the best year of his career, posting 5.0 bWAR in a year he had a 3.10 ERA and 1.056 WHIP in 27 starts. The following year he took a no-hitter into the ninth against the White Sox June 13 at Wrigley Field, only to see Juan Pierre break it up with a leadoff single in the ninth:
About a month later, with the Cubs fading, Lilly was traded to the Dodgers, along with Ryan Theriot and cash, for Blake DeWitt and two minor leaguers who never made it, Kyle Smit and Brett Wallach. Lilly played for L.A. until mid-2013, when he was released.
In three-plus years with the Cubs Ted Lilly posted 15.1 bWAR and played on two Cubs teams that made the postseason. Incidentally, his full name is Theodore Roosevelt Lilly III; the original Theodore Roosevelt Lilly, Ted’s grandfather, had served with Roosevelt in the “Rough Riders” era, thus the name. Ted the pitcher and his wife had a son born in 2010 who is named Theodore Roosevelt Lilly IV.













