Yes, but also no. That is my final answer to a question we’ll get to in a bit.
My fandom of the Pittsburgh Steelers can be traced back to 2004. I don’t know why I said “traced back” like an archeologist who is figuring out where a specific dinosaur bone came from, but that is the earliest memory I have of being a fan. In my now 22 years of watching football, Sunday night was pound-for-pound the worst performance I’ve ever seen out of a Steelers team.
Where do you want to start with how outmatched the
Steelers were? How about 484 yards to 222 in favor of the Bengals? Or Ja’Marr Chase having more receiving yards (231) than the Steelers did yards of offense. Quarterback wise, Joe Burrow had more passing yards in the first half than Aaron Rodgers has had in any game in his tenure as the Steelers’ quarterback. I could keep going – and I will. Rodgers’ 143 yards passing are the third-fewest he’s thrown in a full game as a Steeler. However, 118 of those came in the fourth quarter during garbage time. So if you took away those last two meaningless drives, Rodgers was 8-of-20 for 25 yards. The defense had by far its worse game of the season, as well, allowing Joe Burrow to put up the third-highest total EPAof any quarterback in any game this season, behind only to Drake Maye in Week 5 against the Las Vegas Raiders and Brock Purdy on Sunday against the Dallas Cowboys.
That brings me back to the teased question, which is should the Steelers be panicked? After any game like that, yes there should be more concern than not. Constant defensive miscommunications, Asante Samuel’s inability to look like an NFL caliber player when lined up agains top tier receivers, blitzes being dissected like nothing, an inability to get any pressure on Burrow, and a passing game that is completely dead in the water – those are all massive, massive concerns.
So if those are all real, major issues, what is the case for taking a deep breath and not proclaiming the season to be over? Well, the remaining schedule is much more favorable than we originally thought. Next week, they’ll play the Joe Milton-led Philadelphia Eagles, who haven’t scored more than 20 points just twice this season – that’s a game they should absolutely win. They then host the Broncos, whose defense is incredible, but offensively, they are brutal. Denver is 28th in offensive success rate and 25th in passing yards per game. At home, the Steelers can beat Bo Nix and make life hell for the Broncos’ less-than-stellar offense. They then face a Texans team that is currently 3-6 and allowed the Browns to come back from a 17-0 hole to win. On the road against the Jaguars will be tough, and I don’t expect them to beat the most complete team in the AFC. But then they have a home game against the Panthers – should be a win – followed by a road game against the Titans – should be a win. Those games are sandwiched between both tilts against the Ravens in Weeks 15 and 18, both of which are likely to not feature Lamar Jackson, especially if the Ravens are mathematically eliminated from playoff contention.
Is this all to say the Steelers are Super Bowl contenders? No, and I’m not going to gaslight you by saying they are. And if in your eyes that means that everything else isn’t worth talking about, then I don’t know what you’re doing here, frankly. A team is never as great as their greatest highs or as bad as their lowest lows. The Steelers are still a 6-3 team with seven very winnable games remaining on their schedule, and a Jaguars game that I don’t expect them to win, but you never know what can happen any given week. 12 wins is still very much on the table, 11 even more so, and 10 at the absolute worst. I can already see some of you pounding at the keyboard. “THEY AREN’T WINNING ANOTHER GAME THIS SEASON.”
Relax.
The Steelers find themselves at a crossroads, not a dead end. Was it an awful performance? Absolutely. Is that the norm this team has put on display this season? Absolutely not. Hell, the 2020 Buccaneers were blown out 38-3 on Sunday Night Football and they won the Super Bowl. Performances like this happen to every good-great team each season to varying degrees. The Steelers are still going to be a playoff team. What happens after that, we can be angry about if and when it goes south when the time comes. For now, deep breaths.
Let us know what you think in the comments. Be sure to bookmark Behind the Steel Curtain for all the latest news, breakdowns, and more!
- Steelers stock report after 38-18 loss to the Bengals
- Steelers OL Mason McCormick carted off field vs. Bengals
- Steelers safety DeShon Elliott suffers pre-game injury, out vs. Bengals
- Steelers vs. Bengals: Week 10 game picks
- Steelers TE Pat Freiermuth may not play vs. Bengals













